so my genius boyfriend just pointed out that Sherie's costume was probably inspired by the vampire squid, an animal that has spikey tentacles unlike the usual suction cups.....after looking at some pics of this scary animal, I'm convinced Tatiana used this as her basis for the tentacles. Just thought I'd share cause this made me like her costume SO much more!!!
Yes the vampire squid is truly and amazing creature (one of my all time favourite squid), however it would seem odd that a costume designer would get their inspiration from this creature (not to mention its a squid not an octopus), but yes the tentacles do remind me of ursula's costume.... too bad its not quite as cool as mother nature designed it. Updated On: 12/7/07 at 11:29 PM
I can see how you'd think Tatiana got her inspiration from here, but Ursula twice mentions her suction cups. So either they're being inaccurate or she's just not based off this particular squid. Ha, I look far too deeply into things!
--------------------------
"At the late night, double feature Picture Show"
I love when Sherie raises the skirt and all the tentacles are raised around her.
Regardless of all those who hate the costume -- I don't think it could have been improved upon. It looks spectacular and Sherie works it like one amazing prop.
well it doesn't make sense according to fact... however if Pat Carrol states that, who am I to defy it? I always assumed she was an octopus because she really doesn't have the general shape or appearance of a squid, however according to general cepholopod anatomy she is neither squid nor octopus...
To me, Ursula (in the movie) resembles the latter more than the former.
I agree. I've always thought of Ursula as an octopus. The reality is that both octopus and squid have eight "arms". But, squid have two "tentacles" in addition to their eight "arms".
So, if she's a squid, the dress should have eight arms and Sherie's arms would be the tentacles, which are used by the squid to shoot out and grab things. Though the dress/costume fits the look of an octopus, not a squid. A squid does not flare out its arms like Sherie does when she works her dress, an octopus would.
Art has a double face, of expression and illusion.
I think people are thinking way to deeply about this. XD It's just a costume that happens to resemble a vampire squid that may have been the *inspiration* for the costume, not an exact replica.
If you want to get technical, she could be BOTH (in the Broadway show anyway). She goes from being a squid at one point, to being an octopus at another; two examples are that she is an octopus during I Want the Good Times Back (with eight arms) and a squid in Poor Unfortunate Souls (with eight arms, two tentacles). Now, you did say that a squid wouldn't behave like that, but look at the vampire squid- it flared out it's arms to form a protective coat around itself.
Honestly though, it's debatable (not that it should be debated, being only a costume), and I doubt there will ever be a *right* answer.
For some reason I am voting for a Vampire Squid outfit verses the new Ursula look. Sorry, it could be more stunning and a whole lot more convincing if it was better designed.
I can hardly see the resemblance. Way too many ruffles for even a Vampire Squid. That look though would have been awesome if done right. Too bad. Still an ugly pinata, bad plant eating sculpture to me.
Of course the "designer" has the right answer. Unfortunately I cannot appreciate her work on this costume at least. Updated On: 12/8/07 at 09:04 PM
i'd like to think that it's a combo of diff. things, after all, she's definately part human....I just like the fact that the designer chose spiky tentacles as they look more threatening to me than round suction cups:)
"I Want the Good Times Back" - 6 tentacles hanging off the main part of the costume
"Poor Unfortunate Souls" - 8 tentacle dress
I don't WANT to live in what they call "a certain way." In the first place I'd be no good at it and besides that I don't want to be identified with any one class of people. I want to live every whichway, among all kinds---and know them---and understand them---and love them---THAT's what I want! - Philip Barry (Holiday)
On the TLM dvd, Pat Caroll jokingly explains that in the movie Ursula only has six tentacles because it was cheaper to animate. She calls Ursula a squid.