So I'll be in NY for a week in October, and will be left to my own devices on a thursday afternoon; Are there any shows that have matinees on this day other than PHANTOM and MOULIN ROUGE? I've been having a hard time verifying off-broadway schedules.
Where you can put in the date you are interested in and see all sorts of Broadway, Off Broadway, and other events in NYC for a specific date. You'll have to scroll thru to find times to separate matinees from evenings and to eliminate non-theater all together, but you can find what you are looking for there.
Play That Goes Wrong has a matinee tomorrow. Maybe more for your visit?
Check TKTS to see what's on the board tomorrow and look for Off Broadway matinees that might pop up there, too.