This may be a bit of a weird question, but oh well, it's worth a shot...
Does anyone know from which shows these are? Whenever something is blown into the audience or if something falls from the sky, I take one of those goodies with me as a memento (unless it's a Spider-Man actor). I usually label them - no kidding - but now I found these three unlabeled ones and I really can't remember which shows had these.
They're definitely from a NY show, most likely Broadway, that played anywhere between 2009 and 2012. The red one is definitely not from First Date. I keep thinking Follies for the pink and / or red ones but I'm not sure. The feather, I have no idea at all.
I had a look at the list of shows that I saw during that period and removed the ones where these goodies are definitely not from. Ended up with this list (unless I overlooked something):
Mamma Mia The Story Of My Life West Side Story Shrek The Musical Billy Elliot 9 to 5: The Musical La Cage Aux Folles Bye Bye Birdie Hair Finian's Rainbow A Little Night Music The Miracle Worker Promises, Promises Lend Me A Tenor Sondheim On Sondheim Everyday Rapture Women On The Verge Of A Nervous Breakdown A Little Night Music Elf Spider-Man: Turn Off The Dark Catch Me If You Can Anything Goes Priscilla: Queen Of The Desert Arcadia How To Succeed In Business Without Really Trying Wonderland: A New Alice Sister Act The Book Of Mormon Follies The Mountaintop Godspell Harvey The Fantasticks Newsies Evita
Thanks for your help, everyone! As to the feather: I think I remember which show it's from! I believe it's from the pillow fight scene in The Mountaintop.
Since I saw The Mountaintop and Follies during the same trip, it's quite possible that the rose petals are indeed from Follies.