Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals

By: Walter McBride Mar. 31, 2014

The red carpet was littered with stars at last night's opening of If/Then at Broadway's Richard Rodgers Theatre. Some of the special guests included Jesse Tyler Ferguson, Brian d'Arcy James, Stephen Schwartz, Daphne Rubin-Vega, Darren Criss and more. BroadwayWorld brings you photos from the theatre arrivals below!

If/Then follows Elizabeth as she rebuilds her life in New York, a city of infinite possibilities. This contemporary musical is set where choice and chance collide. In one moment, Elizabeth will lead parallel lives. This is the story of both. The musical stars Tony winner Idina Menzel with Anthony Rapp, LaChanze, James Snyder, Jerry Dixon,Jenn Colella, Jason Tam, Tamika Lawrence, and Jackie Burns.

If/Then is an original Broadway musical which reunites Tom Kitt (music), Brian Yorkey (book and lyrics), and Michael Greif (director), the creative team behind the Pulitzer Prize and Tony Award-winning musical, Next to Normal. If/Then is being produced by David Stone, who produced both Wicked and Next to Normal.

Photo Credit: Walter McBride

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 1 of 42
Jesse Tyler Ferguson

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 2 of 42
Jesse Tyler Ferguson

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 3 of 42
Jesse Tyler Ferguson and Justin Mikita

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 4 of 42
Jesse Tyler Ferguson and Justin Mikita

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 5 of 42
Jesse Tyler Ferguson and Justin Mikita

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 6 of 42
Jessica Rosenfeld and Corey Brunish

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 7 of 42
Jessica Rosenfeld and Corey Brunish

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 8 of 42
Gregory Maguire

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 9 of 42
Gregory Maguire

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 10 of 42
Kyle Dean Massey

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 11 of 42
Kyle Dean Massey

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 12 of 42
George C. Wolfe and Maura Tierney

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 13 of 42
Maura Tierney

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 14 of 42
George C. Wolfe and Maura Tierney

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 15 of 42
George C. Wolfe

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 16 of 42
Maura Tierney

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 17 of 42
Maura Tierney

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 18 of 42
Maura Tierney

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 19 of 42
Maura Tierney

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 20 of 42
Susie Essman

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 21 of 42
Susie Essman

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 22 of 42
Brian d'Arcy James

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 23 of 42
Brian d'Arcy James

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 24 of 42
Brian d'Arcy James

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 25 of 42
Christine Lindsay-Abaire and David Lindsay-Abaire

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 26 of 42
Stephen Schwartz

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 27 of 42
Mario Cantone

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 28 of 42
Mario Cantone posing with a poster of his husband Jerry Dixon

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 29 of 42
Michael C. Hall and girlfriend Morgan Macgregor

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 30 of 42
Morgan Macgregor

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 31 of 42
Michael C. Hall

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 32 of 42
Tom Kitt

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 33 of 42
Tom Kitt and Rita Pietropinto

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 34 of 42
Tom Kitt and wife Rita Pietropinto

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 35 of 42
Daphne Rubin-Vega

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 36 of 42
Daphne Rubin-Vega

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 37 of 42
Lin-Manuel Miranda and Vanessa Nadal

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 38 of 42
Lin-Manuel Miranda and wife Vanessa Nadal

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 39 of 42
Darren Criss

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 40 of 42
Darren Criss

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 41 of 42
Darren Criss

Photos: Inside IF/THEN's Opening Night Theatre Arrivals — photo 42 of 42
Darren Criss

Nominations Are Open for the 2026 BroadwayWorld Regional Awards!

Nominate your favorite local productions and performers before the deadline on October 31, 2026.

Nominations close in 2Days 20Hrs 56Min 18Sec

Get Show Info Info
Cast	Photos
Videos

View all Videos

Tickets From $70

Tickets From $135

Tickets From $58

Tickets From $67