Review: AN IRISH CAROL at Keegan Theatre

Of the too-many stage variations of Charles Dickens’ Scrooge story this time of year, the one that’s found its place in my cold, black heart is the Keegan Theatre’s “An Irish Carol.”

Now in its 14th year, revisiting the solid play by Matthew J. Keenan, who also devised the detailed set, is as comfortable as stopping into a neighborhood bar during the holidays —  to see old friends, sure, but also to get away from the sickly sweet and often insincere fare elsewhere.

Three of the main cast members have been in their roles for all 14 seasons, chief among them Kevin Adams as the brooding bar owner David with the worst holiday attitude, and Timothy H. Lynch as the wiseguy in corduroy and a Santa cap, Frank. One can’t imagine “An Irish Carol” without either of them.  

And did I hear that Daniel Lyons was returning to his role as Michael after a long absence, just as his character had been estranged for years from his former friend who owns the Dublin bar? 

There are multiple actors listed for some of the roles, but it was Jared H. Graham and Sarah Chapin who came in to add a little youth to what looks like a bar of old men on Christmas Eve. Working the bar like the Bob Cratchit he is was Taylor Witt, portraying the Polish immigrant bartender, adding a bit of light and hope to what would seem a dreary work situation. 

Michael Replogle has settled comfortably in his role — and his barstool — a long-abiding customers who have been watching this decline of David into his darkness.  Mike Kozemchak is a brother who’s at his wit’s end at trying to get him over for dinner. 

Keenan’s “Carol,” under the direction of Mark A. Rhea, has a number of comparable plot points as Dickens’ original — with relatives and charity workers angrily dismissed, ordering Bartek to work Christmas Day despite a special aged child (a little girl, not a Tiny Tim). 

And while there are opportunities for David to look back at his life, consider its present, and get a chilly glimpse of his dim future, there’s no need to bring in the rigamarole of three ghosts ushering in each at the stroke of each hour. 

It’s almost as if the fuss and what’s become cliché in the Christmas Carol has been scrubbed such that underlying pain is still there. And David’s character is not motivated by money, as Scooge was, but has developed an anger at the world because of a lost love we eventually learn about. Adams’ wordless reaction to a letter from beyond the grave provides the nudge to the beginnings of a turnaround and while it does seem to happen quickly, it’s not as instant as the usual giddy Scrooge turkey scene.

I have learned that “An Irish Carol” is not for everybody. Without carols and with very little sentimentality, the play with a lot of cursing (but some well-timed laughs) may as off-putting to some as visiting dive bars is for the genteel. For those of us who revel at the flawed humanity in such scenes, it’s just the right holiday tonic each year. 

Running time: 90 minutes, with no intermission.

Photo credit: Kevin Adams in “An Irish Carol.” Photo by Mike Kozemchak.

More on Keegan Theatre

Upcoming Shows

The Play That Goes Wrong

6/6 - 7/12/2026

The Play That Goes Wrong

6/6 - 7/12/2026

Recent Articles

Review: THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG at Keegan Theatre

6/17/2026

Cast Set For THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG at Keegan Theatre

5/14/2026