Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: The Phoenix Theatre Company Presents JERSEY BOYS ~ Oh, What A Show!

Review:  The Phoenix Theatre Company Presents JERSEY BOYS ~ Oh, What A Show!

Cues soirées là! Oh, what a night! By whatever language, Opening Night of The Phoenix Theatre Company's production of JERSEY BOYS was quite a night! A vibrant retrospective of the song classics that made The Four Seasons one of the most popular and prolific groups of the '60's-70's. And, a dramatic perspective on their roller-coaster relationship from the lamplit street corners of Newark to induction into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.

From Antonio Leroy King's opening rap solo of Yannick's pop hit to the cast's celebratory closing (Who Loves You), the show ripples with energy.

Justin Albinder (Frankie Valli), James D. Gish (Bob Gaudio), Anthony Fortino (Tommy DeVito), and Tommy McDowell (Nick Massi) successfully recreate the power doo-wop style and sweeping movements of the originals. And, oh, how they harmonize! Perfectly! With Albinder achieving Valli's characteristic range and falsetto.

As the show progresses, each takes a turn, in accordance with the four seasons of their group's life, to tell his side of the story ~ spring (DeVito), summer (Gaudio), fall (Massi), and winter (Valli). The songs thematically align with the narrative.

In this regard, Marshall Brickman and Rick Elice's construction of the musical is possessed of a symmetry and poetry that makes for engaging entertainment ~ even though it falters at times in historical and representational accuracy.

For example, for whatever reason, Bob Crewe, a principal lyricist for many of the group's songs and a musical genius in his own right, is presented merely as their producer and characterized with far more flamboyance than was actually the case.

However, the characterization is carried out with superb panache by Terry Gadaire, one of the Phoenix area's most versatile performers.

The show, directed by Larry Raben, enjoys some pivotal moments when it ascends into the zone of excellence.

The first belongs to the appearance of James Gish as Gaudio and his rendition of Cry for Me. Gish is terrific throughout the production.

Then, there is the show-stopping performance of Sherry.

And, one after another, the record-breaking songs (Big Girls Don't Cry, Walk Like A Man, Can't Take My Eyes Off of You) that placed The Four Seasons (along with The Beach Boys) at the top of the charts.

Beyond the chemistry and dynamism of the four principals, the tone and mood of the production is heightened by Daniel Davisson's resplendent lighting. Alan Ruch and his orchestra deliver the distinctive sound and rhythms of Gaudio's music to exhilarating perfection.

Yes, indeed! Oh, what a show!

JERSEY BOYS runs through March 10th at The Phoenix Theatre Company.

Photo credit to Reg Madison Photography

The Phoenix Theatre Company ~ 1825 N Central Ave, Phoenix ~ (602) 254-2151 ~

Photos: First Look at A DOLLS HOUSE, PART 2 at Theatrikos Theatre Company Photo
Theatrikos is currently bringing the most frequently licensed show of 2019 to the Flagstaff stage:  A Doll’s House, Part 2, running through February 12, 2023. Check out the photos here!

THE ANDREWS BROTHERS is Now Playing at Hale Theatre Photo
Did you ever hear of the Andrews Brothers? You will soon, as they slip into the Andrews Sisters’ skirts and tap shoes to perform a USO show for World War II troops after the Sisters’ appearance became unavoidably canceled. The guys have plenty of experience, sort of, as USO stagehands.

KODO To Explore Traditional Japanese Performance Art In Scottsdale Photo
The professional taiko drumming troupe KODO will perform on Feb. 15 and 16 at Scottsdale Center for the Performing Arts.

The Bridge Initiative & Estrella Mountain Community College Launch Partnership With LI Photo
The Bridge Initiative will be in residence this spring at Estrella Mountain Community College, the inauguration of a new professional/educational theatre partnership launching with the world premiere of Arizona playwright Elaine Romero's “Like Heaven.”

From This Author - Herbert Paine

Herb Paine ~ Herb has served as Senior Contributing Editor and lead reviewer for BWW's Phoenix Metro Region since 2014. He has been acclaimed as BEST THEATRE CRITIC by PHOENIX magazin... (read more about this author)

Review: THE LIFESPAN OF A FACT at Theatre Artists Studio ~ A Work of Timely ImportanceReview: THE LIFESPAN OF A FACT at Theatre Artists Studio ~ A Work of Timely Importance
January 24, 2023

THE LIFESPAN OF A FACT ~ a play of consequence, superbly directed by Richard Powers Hardt and featuring stellar performances by Tom Koelbel, Jake Nichols, and Debra Rich, runs through February 5th at Theatre Artists Studio in Scottsdale AZ.

Review: LA RUTA at Stray Cat TheatreReview: LA RUTA at Stray Cat Theatre
December 5, 2022

The importance of LA RUTA's subject needs to be seen and the story it tells needs to be known. Stray Cat Theatre presents this stunning and disturbing production through December 17th at Tempe Center for the Arts.

Review: A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Hale Centre TheatreReview: A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Hale Centre Theatre
December 2, 2022

The full experience of Hale Centre Theatre's production of A CHRISTMAS CAROL is captured in this review. Runs through December 26th.

Review: The Phoenix Theatre Company Presents Rodgers and Hammerstein's CINDERELLAReview: The Phoenix Theatre Company Presents Rodgers and Hammerstein's CINDERELLA
November 20, 2022

Chosen as its holiday season family special, this regional production of CINDERELLA, directed by Michael Barnard, is a prime example of the excellence that The Phoenix Theatre Company has developed over the years. Runs through January 1st.

Feature: THE OTHER SIDE OF THE SEA- Acts Of Conscience And Support On Behalf Of The People Of UkraineFeature: THE OTHER SIDE OF THE SEA- Acts Of Conscience And Support On Behalf Of The People Of Ukraine
November 16, 2022

Hsuan Yu Pan's THE OTHER SIDE OF THE SEA captures the human dimension of the tragedy in Ukraine and the response of New York's community of artists to raise awareness and support. The film will be showcased on December 16th at the Soapbox Gallery in Brooklyn.