Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: ESCAPE TO MARGARITAVILLE at Dr. Phillips Center Is Far from Paradise

Review: ESCAPE TO MARGARITAVILLE at Dr. Phillips Center Is Far from Paradise

I would never drink on the job, but at ESCAPE TO MARGARITAVILLE, "pour me something tall and strong" is part of the mandate - and the show writers are clearly counting on tequila to carry them through.

Margaritaville is an island getaway where the drinks are strong, Jimmy Buffett is god, and every single inhabitant has exactly one personality trait.

It's definitely the cheeseburger version of paradise.

We meet Tully, a hunky, love-em-and-leave-em surfer dude who isn't smart like Rachel, the brainy science student on vacay... but at least he knows how to let loose.

Do you think Rachel could learn a thing or two from Tully? Do you think their differences might lead them to love? Only time and formula will tell.

But something about ESCAPE TO MARGARITAVILLE did surprise me: it makes a more concerted effort than most jukebox musicals to justify its lyrics narratively. While it is ultimately nothing more than two hours of unrelated Jimmy Buffett songs stuffed into a story that exists solely to cash in on that catalog, writers Greg Garcia and Mike O'Malley do find clever ways to plant narrative seeds that will turn up in song lyrics later. Or maybe they only seemed clever to me because I am admittedly unacquainted with most of those songs and so didn't see the payoff coming a mile ahead.

I ran into a friend in the lobby who is both a Parrothead and a PhD. He made an impassioned case for Jimmy Buffett's artistic integrity, arguing persuasively that the catalog is deeper and richer than its lettuce-and-tomato flagship might imply. I believe him. But if there's more to Mr. Buffett than salt shakers and songs that sound the same, this show doesn't know it.

My friend must have agreed, because I don't think I saw him again after Act I.

That's the breezy half, where the light-and-uncomplicated proceedings have the airy likeability of an old Annette Funicello beach bash. I admit that, even as I thought to myself, "This isn't very good," I was having a good time - a testament to the good company I was keeping, the high spirits of those around me (one woman was dressed as a cheeseburger), and undoubtedly the Dr. Phillips' Center worth-the-money margarita (or "Paradise-rita," priced at $15 with a complimentary flavor shot of your choice).

Alas, the good times run flat by Act II, which leaves the island behind and belabors an already barely-there story. If ever there were a candidate for a one-act show, this is it. Cut a couple of songs and knock this thing out in 90 minutes, please, lest "it's 5:00 somewhere" have us all longing for the A.M. hour when the obvious ending will finally be behind us.

Having debuted on Broadway in 2017 to zero Tony nominations and zero wins, leaving Buffett just four awards away from an EGOT, ESCAPE TO MARGARITAVILLE is now on tour with a non-Equity cast. The performances are capable across the board, though none stun you, nor does the material give them an opportunity to do so.

As Rachel's dorky but fun-loving friend Tammy, Shelly Lynn Walsh is funny and belts some of the brightest notes. Her chemistry with co-leads Peter Michael Jordan (who plays Brick, one of Tammy's dimwitted love interests) and Sarah Hinrichsen (Rachel) help to make the dull dialogue more believable than it ever could have been on paper. The show's choreography is lively, and the whole company handles it well. On opening night, Trent Soyster seemed especially dedicated to his duties on stage (lifting a suitcase with noticeable gusto during one particularly showy scene, elevating the proceedings), and Nico DiPrimio's dancing stood out in an ensemble of talented dancers (several people around me would say, "Oh he's back! He's back!" each time DiPrimio returned to the stage).

It's a cast that does its best in a show that doesn't try to, but if you're a longtime Parrothead and in it for an easy trip down Memory Lane, you'll find what you're looking for. Just find your way to the bar before the curtain goes up. Get tickets or subscribe to the new season at the official theatre website.

Review: ESCAPE TO MARGARITAVILLE at Dr. Phillips Center Is Far from Paradise


What do you think of ESCAPE TO MARGARITAVILLE? Let me know on Twitter @AaronWallace.

Photo Credit: Sarah Hinrichsen as Rachel and Chris Clark as Tully in Jimmy Buffett's ESCAPE TO MARGARITAVILLE. © Matthew Murphy.


Vote Now for the 2022 BroadwayWorld Orlando Awards
voting ends in




From This Author - Aaron Wallace

Aaron Wallace is a podcaster, attorney, and the bestselling author of several books on travel and entertainment, including read more about this author)


Review: With a Surprise Appearance by Jodi Benson, DISNEY PRINCESS - THE CONCERT Brings Big Talent to Dr. Phillips CenterReview: With a Surprise Appearance by Jodi Benson, DISNEY PRINCESS - THE CONCERT Brings Big Talent to Dr. Phillips Center
November 17, 2022

The Disney Princesses were only five songs into their set when the iconic Jodi Benson made a surprise appearance on stage. The original voice behind Ariel in 1989's The Little Mermaid, Benson may be best known on screen as a princess, but to a crowd of theatre aficionados and adoring Disney fans, she's a queen...

Review: Why a 'Weird Al' Concert Without Any Parodies Is the Most 'Weird Al' Concert of AllReview: Why a 'Weird Al' Concert Without Any Parodies Is the Most 'Weird Al' Concert of All
October 19, 2022

An evening with 'Weird Al' on stage is always a blend of concert, comedy, and community. The Unfortunate Return of the Ridiculously Self-Indulgent, Ill-Advised Vanity Tour feels like an opportunity to give back — letting Al show us everything else he can do while indulging our own inner geeks at the same time. When you think about it, being into something really specific and relatively unpopular is really what nerdom is all about, which makes a parody-free “Weird Al” show surprisingly the “Weird Al”-iest show of all.

BWW Review: Even Refreshed for its 50th Anniversary, JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR Remains Dated & Divisive — Dr. Phillips CenterBWW Review: Even Refreshed for its 50th Anniversary, JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR Remains Dated & Divisive — Dr. Phillips Center
June 9, 2022

What did our critic think of JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR at Dr. Phillips Center? The show remains fundamentally a relic of the precise moment in time that Short summed up so well, when the convergence of counterculture and rock & roll meant that an irreverent but ultimately thin concept like this one — “the Bible but make it a concert” — seemed utterly avant-garde...

BWW Interview: Julie Andrews Talks AFI Life Achievement Award, Princess Diaries 3, New Memoir & MoreBWW Interview: Julie Andrews Talks AFI Life Achievement Award, Princess Diaries 3, New Memoir & More
June 8, 2022

On the cusp of her AFI Lifetime Achievement Award, we talk with Julie Andrews for an update on The Princess Diaries 3, her next installment in her series of memoirs, the potential of her returning to the Broadway stage and the upcoming Minions movie.

BWW Review: BEAUTIFUL - THE CAROLE KING MUSICAL Returns to Dr. Phillips Center; Still Better Than Most Jukebox MusicalsBWW Review: BEAUTIFUL - THE CAROLE KING MUSICAL Returns to Dr. Phillips Center; Still Better Than Most Jukebox Musicals
May 16, 2022

But BEAUTIFUL is structured differently than most 'backstage biomusicals.' It's not a rags to riches story, exactly, nor the routine tale of one woman's ascent to superstardom. Mercifully, we are spared the obligatory plot points of that particular formula. King never learns her contract is unconscionable nor fires a manager in dramatic fashion. There is no descent into addiction, fall from grace, dramatic career slump, or climatic comeback...