Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: DIAL M FOR MURDER at Bay Street Theatre

The show is running through July 23rd.

By:
Review: DIAL M FOR MURDER at Bay Street Theatre

Being an enthusiast of old movies, I became a fan of Alfred Hitchcock's 1954 film version of Fredrick Knott's Dial M for Murder long before I attended the stage incarnation adapted by Jeffrey Hatcher. Was the film a tad slow? Perhaps. Thankfully, the Bay Street Theatre's incredible Broadway caliber production, running through July 23rd at the beautiful East End venue, put a better, modern spin on this riveting story... and went at a better pace.

Among the extremely talented cast masterfully directed by Walter Bobbie is Mamie Gummer as the well-to-do Margot Wendice, Grace Kelly's role in the movie. Margot is a pleasant woman, but also very naïve as she refuses to believe her cold-hearted husband has planned to murder her which is the premise for the story. Indeed Ms. Gummer is captivating in the role.

In absolutely excellent casting, Erich Bergen thrillingly portrays Margot's selfish, uncaring, heartless husband Tony. Tony is a former tennis star and plots Margot's murder for mostly her money, but several twists and turns abound throughout the story. I say "mostly" because what also sets Tony off is Margot's affair with Maxine Hadley (as opposed to Mark, if you've seen the movie version before) portrayed by Rosa Gilmore. In spite of the affair, you will find yourself rooting for Maxine as she actually cares about Margot.

Rounding out the rest of the top notch cast is Max Gordon Moore as Lesgate, the person who Tony blackmails into joining his murderous scheme. And, Reg Rogers gives a commanding performance as the clever Inspector Hubbard. Everyone in the cast is truly remarkable.

Another highlight is Anna Louizos' magnificent set. The first thing you see as you walk into the Sag Harbor venue is a curtain shielding the stage, which Bay Street doesn't usually have. Two British coppers ceremoniously pull back the curtain and you see the stationary set. Taking place in 1950's London, this story is told solely in the posh living room of Wendice's upper-class home. A lush couch and beautiful decor, grand desk, staircase, and stunning back doors leading to what is suppose to be a garden are well situated on the intimate stage. Heightened with Donald Holder's atmospheric lighting and Jeff Mahshie's exemplary costumes, this is certainly a visually stunning production.

Folks, this production and this cast is brilliant. I don't think I could possibly say anything further than to say if you are able, go see this one. An extraordinarily talented cast and an intriguing, twisting story make for a gripping night of theatre.

Click Here to Get Tickets

Reader Reviews

Don't Miss a Long Island News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...

Local Shows
THE WEDDING SINGER in Long Island THE WEDDING SINGER
The John W. Engeman Theater (7/09-8/23)
I Hate Hamlet by Paul Rudnick in Long Island I Hate Hamlet by Paul Rudnick
South Shore Theatre (8/22-8/22)
The Importance of Being Earnest in Long Island The Importance of Being Earnest
Theatre Three - NY (4/04-4/23)
Hamptons Summer Songbook By the Sea in Long Island Hamptons Summer Songbook By the Sea
LTV Studios (6/28-8/29)
Pinkalicious - The Musical in Long Island Pinkalicious - The Musical
Patchogue Theatre (10/25-10/25)
Drinking Habits in Long Island Drinking Habits
Theatre Box (7/24-8/02)
Stony Brook Symphony Orchestra in Long Island Stony Brook Symphony Orchestra
Staller Center for the Arts (12/05-12/05)
South Shore Theatre Experience present 15th Annual One Act Festival in Long Island South Shore Theatre Experience present 15th Annual One Act Festival
South Shore Theatre (9/04-9/04)
Million Dollar Quartet Christmas in Long Island Million Dollar Quartet Christmas
The Gateway Performing Arts Center of Suffolk County (11/27-1/03)
I Dream of Broadway in Long Island I Dream of Broadway
Southampton Cultural Center (8/14-8/14)

BroadwayWorld TV