Skip to main content Skip to footer site map
Review: WILD HORSES at the Phoenix Theatre

Review: WILD HORSES at the Phoenix Theatre

This one-woman show runs through March 5th.

A one-woman show starring two of Indy's finest leading ladies, Wild Horses is a fascinating concept with a big payoff. Constance Macy and Jen Johansen rotate nights for their performances in the coming-of-age story. The one-act play flies by because it feels like chatting with an old friend who's regaling you with stories from her past. From first crushes to alcohol concoctions only the underaged would dare to drink, the show captures the electric, reckless feel of youth.

The night I attended, Johansen was in the driver's seat and she kept up the break-neck pace for the entire 80-minute show. Solo shows rest entirely on the shoulders of the actor and Johansen was perfect for the role. She imbued each scene with humor and heartbreak. She was full of energy and captured the emotional peaks and valleys of adolescence. She skips easily between half a dozen impressions and voices as she tells the story of the summer when she was 13 and the world was both full of excitement and crumbling around her. The show feels reminiscent of all the best coming-of-age moments, with pieces of Stand by Me, Stranger Things, and Now and Then mixed in together.

Music is a huge element in the production and each scene features 1970s rock songs and love ballads. Kudos to the lighting designer, Laura E. Glover. She manages to convey everything from a wildfire to a herd of horses in clever ways. The set, designed by Zac Hunter, looks like a lovely art installation. It's functional, allowing space to weave around, but also beautiful.

Wild Horses reminds us of the importance of those moments that shape us in that malleable season of life. We may part ways with our childhood friends, but those shared experiences stay with us forever.

Don't Miss the Show

To buy tickets or for more information about The Phoenix Theatre and its upcoming season, visit phoenixtheatre.org.

Performances: The show runs until March 5th at the Phoenix Cultural Center, 705 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46204. There is adult language and themes throughout the show. You can choose the play based on the actress performing or, if possible, go see both!

Photos Courtesy of Indy Ghost Ligh



Buck Creek Players Presents ARE YOU BEING SERVED? Photo
Buck Creek Players will continue its 49th season with this live event on the mainstage. Join in for the six live in-person performances at the playhouse starting Friday, March 31st and running through Sunday, April 9th. 

Review: LES MISERABLES Returns to Clowes Memorial Hall Photo
Les Miserables returned to Indianapolis, again, in excellent fasion, propagating its underlying message that theater can suppress the multitudes. It can be ambitious and weighty, thematically sacred, and blatantly tear-jerking.

Karl Kenzler, Deirdre Lovejoy & More to Join INDY SPELLING BEE at The New Harmony Proj Photo
The New Harmony Project will present Indy Spelling Bee on April 1. The event will be produced by the creator of the Tony Award-winning Broadway musical, The 25 Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee.

Review: MURDER ON THE ORIENT EXPRESS Brings A Tantalizing Whodunnit To Civic Theatre Photo
There’s a reason that Agatha Christie is the best-selling novelist of all time: she sure knows how to write a story. Her works have been immortalized in many ways, and the stage production of MURDER ON THE ORIENT EXPRESS adapted by Ken Ludwig is another great example of her storytelling prowess come to life. Audience members get to gasp, laugh, and analyze in their turn as Poirot works his mystery-solving magic.


From This Author - Melissa Hall

Melissa Hall has been reviewing live theater since 2006. She lives in Indianapolis and enjoys the city's thriving local arts scene. She is a member of the American Theatre C... (read more about this author)


Review: WILD HORSES at the Phoenix TheatreReview: WILD HORSES at the Phoenix Theatre
February 6, 2023

What did our critiA one-woman show starring two of Indy’s finest leading ladies, Wild Horses is a fascinating concept with a big payoff. Constance Macy and Jen Johansen rotate nights for their performances in the coming-of-age story. The one-act play flies by because it feels like chatting with an old friend who’s regaling you with stories from her past. From first crushes to alcohol concoctions only the underaged would dare to drink, the show captures the electric, reckless feel of youth.c think of WILD HORSES at Phoenix Theatre?

Review: HEROES OF THE FOURTH TURNING at American Lives TheatreReview: HEROES OF THE FOURTH TURNING at American Lives Theatre
January 17, 2023

Empathy is often in short supply when it comes to how we feel about people on the opposite side of the political divide. Heroes of the Fourth Turning, a Pulitzer-prize finalist, explores that tricky topic in an intense and memorable way. The show is perfectly in line with American Lives Theatre’s mission to provide provocative and entertaining plays to Indy.

Review: CLUE at Beef & Boards Dinner TheatreReview: CLUE at Beef & Boards Dinner Theatre
January 3, 2023

Clue, the classic whodunit farce, kicks off Beef and Boards Dinner Theatre's 50th anniversary season. The mystery show takes the famous board game and film and turns it into a play. Each character is given a weapon and a motive and the murders begin. Eddie Curry directs the fast-paced production and keeps the actors as close to their movie counterparts as possible. 

Review: ALADDIN at Broadway Across AmericaReview: ALADDIN at Broadway Across America
November 17, 2022

Broadway Across America does big musicals well. Obviously, the trend of movie-to-musical has touched every genre, but Disney musicals tend to translate well in that medium. Aladdin is no exception. Everything is big, bright, sparkling, and bursting with color. The special effects don’t disappoint. There are lightning-fast costume changes and spectacular sets. The Cave of Wonders is particularly impressive.

Review: TICK, TICK…BOOM! at Phoenix TheatreReview: TICK, TICK…BOOM! at Phoenix Theatre
October 18, 2022

The story resonates with any artist who has questioned their future. By the end, you feel like you're part of the tight-knit trio as they navigate the difficult passage from their 20s into the next inevitable stage.