Skip to main content Skip to footer site map
Underscore Theatre Company Closes Permanently; Chicago Musical Theatre Festival Gains New Home

Underscore Theatre Company Closes Permanently; Chicago Musical Theatre Festival Gains New Home

Underscore’s remaining assets will be transferred to Kokandy to help ensure the Festival’s future success as an incubator for new works.

The Board of Directors of Underscore Theatre Company has announced the company will close its doors permanently after eleven dynamic years of producing musical theatre in Chicago, including 16 world premieres. However, the company's much-lauded Chicago Musical Theatre Festival will have a new home under the leadership of Chicago's Kokandy Productions, another company dedicated to raising the profile of the City's musical theatre community. Underscore's remaining assets will be transferred to Kokandy to help ensure the Festival's future success as an incubator for new works.

Comments Founding Executive Director and Board Vice President Laura Stratford, "We chose to dedicate our time during the pandemic, when we could not produce, to a nearly year-long strategic planning process talking with writers, producers, directors, and new musical makers from all across the country about what is most beneficial for their work in the new musical landscape. Underscore, like many of its peers in the storefront theatre community, operates with limited resources both in capital and human capacity. What we learned from our planning process was that to maintain a sustainable future, our model would need to undergo a dramatic shift, especially as the community continues to recover from the ongoing impact of COVID-19. Artistic Director Whitney Rhodes and Executive Director J. Sebastian Fabál recognized that what would be required to make these changes was beyond the capacity and resources of what a part-time role could allow, and both made the difficult decision to step down. After some deliberation, the Board has elected to take this opportunity to seed a new start for the Chicago Musical Theatre Festival. As an additional gift to the Chicago musical theatre community, we will publish the findings of our strategic planning process, with the hope that they may be of use to those who continue this work."

Underscore Founding Artistic Director and Board Member Alex Higgin-Houser adds, "While Underscore is closing its doors, our mission isn't over. When we founded this company over a decade ago, it was with the goal of making Chicago a hub for new musicals. We're thrilled Kokandy Productions is committed to carrying the torch of new musicals into the future by taking the reins of the Chicago Musical Theatre Festival. We also want to thank Artistic Director Whitney Rhodes and Executive Director J. Sebastian Fabál for their tireless work and leadership, particularly through the pandemic. We wish them both all the best in their future endeavors."

Kokandy Productions Artistic Director Derek Van Barham comments, "We are honored to be welcoming the Chicago Musical Theatre Festival into the Kokandy family, and to be taking charge of such an essential event for our musical theatre community. We thank our friends at Underscore for creating such an inspired opportunity for emerging artists and for entrusting us with continuing the CMTF legacy. We're excited to see the festival continue to evolve and thrive for years to come."

About Underscore Theatre Company

Founded in 2011, Underscore Theatre Company established itself as Chicago's home for new musicals, producing 16 world premiere musicals, six seasons of the Chicago Musical Theatre Festival totaling 56 festival productions, 14 readings and workshops and quarterly concerts. In that time, Underscore was nominated for 17 Non-Equity Joseph Jefferson Awards and won Best Supporting Actress in a Musical (Veronica Garza for Tonya and Nancy: The Rock Opera) and Best New Musical for Haymarket. Many of the musicals developed at Underscore have gone on to have subsequent productions and, in at least one case, to be licensed by Theatrical Rights Worldwide (Numbers Nerds).



Photos: THE BUTTCRACKER: A NUTCRACKER BURLESQUE Now Playing At The Greenhouse Theater Cent Photo
See photos of The Buttcracker: A Nutcracker Burlesque, returning this holiday season with the sixth edition of Chicago’s favorite alternative holiday show, a twist on the original story and a live event not to be missed, directed by Miguel Long and choreographed by Dylan Kerr, now playing through December 31 at the Greenhouse Theater Center, 2257 N. Lincoln Ave. 

Steep Theatre Awarded Largest Grant In Company History Photo
Steep Theatre has been awarded a $2.988 million Community Development Grant from the City of Chicago to transform its newly acquired building in Edgewater into a state-of-the-art performance venue and permanent artistic home. 

TEASE THE SEASON: A Holiday Burlesque Extravaganza is Coming to the Newport Theater This M Photo
'We're here, we're queer, and we're spreading holiday cheer!' 'Tis time for Tease the Season: A Holiday Burlesque Extravaganza at the Newport Theater!

THE BOOK OF MORMON Is Coming to the UIS Performing Arts Center for the First Time in April Photo
Single tickets for the national tour of THE BOOK OF MORMON, winner of nine Tony Awards including Best Musical, will go on sale to the general public on Monday, December 5th at 10 am.


More Hot Stories For You


Photos: THE BUTTCRACKER: A NUTCRACKER BURLESQUE Now Playing At The Greenhouse Theater CenterPhotos: THE BUTTCRACKER: A NUTCRACKER BURLESQUE Now Playing At The Greenhouse Theater Center
December 2, 2022

See photos of The Buttcracker: A Nutcracker Burlesque, returning this holiday season with the sixth edition of Chicago’s favorite alternative holiday show, a twist on the original story and a live event not to be missed, directed by Miguel Long and choreographed by Dylan Kerr, now playing through December 31 at the Greenhouse Theater Center, 2257 N. Lincoln Ave. 

Steep Theatre Awarded Largest Grant In Company HistorySteep Theatre Awarded Largest Grant In Company History
December 2, 2022

Steep Theatre has been awarded a $2.988 million Community Development Grant from the City of Chicago to transform its newly acquired building in Edgewater into a state-of-the-art performance venue and permanent artistic home. 

TEASE THE SEASON: A Holiday Burlesque Extravaganza is Coming to the Newport Theater This MonthTEASE THE SEASON: A Holiday Burlesque Extravaganza is Coming to the Newport Theater This Month
December 2, 2022

'We're here, we're queer, and we're spreading holiday cheer!' 'Tis time for Tease the Season: A Holiday Burlesque Extravaganza at the Newport Theater!

THE BOOK OF MORMON Is Coming to the UIS Performing Arts Center for the First Time in AprilTHE BOOK OF MORMON Is Coming to the UIS Performing Arts Center for the First Time in April
December 2, 2022

Single tickets for the national tour of THE BOOK OF MORMON, winner of nine Tony Awards including Best Musical, will go on sale to the general public on Monday, December 5th at 10 am.

Cast Announced for INTO THE WOODS at Paramount TheatreCast Announced for INTO THE WOODS at Paramount Theatre
December 2, 2022

Up next in Paramount Theatre’s 2022-23 Broadway Series is Into the Woods, Stephen Sondheim and James Lapine’s brilliant reimagining of the Grimm Brothers fairy tales, February 1-March 19, 2023.