Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: MIRACLE ON 34TH STREET at Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre

You WILL believe that this show is good Christmas fun!

Review: MIRACLE ON 34TH STREET at Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre

Dutch Apple Dinner Theater kicked off the holiday season with their current production of Miracle on 34th Street. I had assumed that this was a new musical based on the classic film, but after doing a little digging, it turns out it was written in 1963 by Meredith Wilson, creator of The Music Man. The show seems fresh with a few exceptions. Most notably, there is a patronizing love song called "Look, Little Girl" sung by the male lead.

People who are already fans of the film will find a lot to like about the show. Megan Urz plays the strong, independent Doris Walker. Cella Bernardi and Kennedy Mitchell alternate performances as her adorable and precocious daughter, Susan. Dale Givens is perfectly cast as Kris Kringle AKA Santa Claus, and Michael Santora is solid as leading man Fred Gailey.

Lancaster audience members will recognize and appreciate the antics of Jordon Ross Weinhold who plays the part of Macy's Department Store manager, Marvin Shellhammer. His character has the vocal tics of Paul Lynde and the manic physicality of Martin Short. Ross Weinhold brings a dynamic presence every time he appears on stage. It is a remarkable performance.

The play's dialogue and plot points are faithful to the classic movie's tale of proving the existence of Santa Claus. However, the music was not particularly memorable, with the exception of the rousing second act number That Man Over There is Santa Claus.

Overall, Miracle on 34th Street is an enjoyable and nostalgic way to celebrate the season. Tickets, menu items, and more information can be found on the theater's website.


BroadwayWorld Logo Vote Now for the 2022 BroadwayWorld Central Pennsylvania Awards
Vote Nowvoting ends in

From This Author - Rich Mehrenberg

Rich Mehrenberg was introduced to the magic of theater when he played "The Boy" in his first grade class production of "The Giving Tree". It has been a long term love affair eve... (read more about this author)

Review: WHITE CHRISTMAS at Fulton TheatreReview: WHITE CHRISTMAS at Fulton Theatre
November 20, 2022

Fulton Theatre’s current production of the tepid White Christmas is an excellent example of the old adage “there are no small parts, only small actors”. Fulton Theatre?

October 15, 2022

Pleasant surprises are the best kind.

Review: SATURDAY NIGHT FEVER at Dutch Apple Dinner TheatreReview: SATURDAY NIGHT FEVER at Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre
October 3, 2022

If you ever owned a leisure suit or drank a can of Billy beer, this show has something for you. However, if you expect something beyond a live version of the 1977 movie, you might be disappointed.

Review: THE BOOK OF MORMON at Hershey TheaterReview: THE BOOK OF MORMON at Hershey Theater
September 30, 2022

What did our critic think of THE BOOK OF MORMON at Hershey Theater? The Book of Mormon is a contradiction in that it is both totally filthy and wonderfully wholesome at the same time. This leads to non-stop laughs, a few gasps, and a good feeling in the bottom of your heart when it is all over.

Review: FOR COLORED BOYZ at Fulton TheatreReview: FOR COLORED BOYZ at Fulton Theatre
September 19, 2022

it will get you talking and get you thinking. It will stay with you. Theater on Fulton's 4th floor is often more complex, more intense, and more thought-provoking than what is performed on the main stage. Past shows such as Blackbird, Sweat, and I Am My Own Wife are perfect examples of this mission. However, their current production of FOR COLORED BOYZ on the verge of a nervous breakdown/ when freedom ain't enuff takes those expectations to a whole new level.