Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: ONCE ON THIS ISLAND at Blackfriars Theatre

Now through April 8th

By:
Review: ONCE ON THIS ISLAND at Blackfriars Theatre

While Rochester may still be immersed in the cold and blustery late-winter climate, one need only head to East Main Street for reprieve, as Blackfriars Theatre's "Once on this Island" will transport you to the warm tropics of the Caribbean and tell the story of love, resilience, and the spirit of hope.

"Once on this Island", with book and lyrics by Lynn Ahrens and music by Stephen Flaherty, debuted on Broadway in 1990 and is based on the 1985 novel "My Love, My Love; or, The Peasant Girl" by Rosa Guy, a Caribbean-set retelling of Hans Christian Andersen's fairy tale The Little Mermaid. From Stage Agent: "Once on this Island" is the story of the peasant girl Ti Moune (Daniyah Jezel), an orphan chosen by the Gods who is taken into a simple and loving family; though content, she feels like she was destined for something more. After a terrible accident caused by a wicked storm, Ti Moune falls for a handsome, ailing stranger named Daniel (Ian Cannioto) whom she tries desperately to nurse back to health. She bargains with the Gods for his life, but to do so she must make the ultimate sacrifice. This sets our young peasant girl on the ultimate quest to answer the age-old question, can love conquer death?"

OOTI is no easy undertaking. While fun and energetic throughout, it also tackles themes of colonialism and class. It calls for a very large ensemble cast featuring almost entirely BIPOC performers of all ages, and with a runtime of only 95 minutes and no intermission, it moves with a lightning-fast pace. Blackfriars is well up to the task, pulling together a cast featuring familiar faces as well as folks new to the BT stage, all of whom shine individually and collectively. Special shoutout to Alvis Green, Jr. (Asaka), a familiar face to Rochester theatregoers whose Asaka is funny, radiant, and energetic.

By far the most vibrant and riveting aspect of Blackfriars' OOTI is the choreography, under the direction of Jayme Bermudez, Assistant Artistic Director of Borinquen Dance Theater who also serves as a cultural consultant on the production. Dance is such a pivotal component of this show, as it's infused from top to bottom with the movement, sights and sounds of the Caribbean. Bermudez brings authenticity and island flair to OOTI.

Blackfriars' production of "Once on this Island" is colorful and full of life, and is playing until April 8th; for tickets and more information, click here.



Reader Reviews

To post a comment, you must register and login.





Need more Central New York Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


Oklahoma! in Central New York Oklahoma!
The Glimmerglass Festival (7/10-8/17)
Doja Cat at Madison Square Garden in Central New York Doja Cat at Madison Square Garden
Madison Square Garden (12/01-12/01)
Taste of Lebanon - July 23, 2026 in Central New York Taste of Lebanon - July 23, 2026
DEERFIELD FIRE HOUSE PAVILION (7/23-7/23)
Taste of Lebanon in Central New York Taste of Lebanon
DEERFIELD FIRE HOUSE PAVILION (7/23-7/23)
PIPPIN, A Bridge Street Theatre Emerging Artists Production in Central New York PIPPIN, A Bridge Street Theatre Emerging Artists Production
Bridge Street Theatre (7/09-7/19)
Anastasia: the Musical in Central New York Anastasia: the Musical
Geva Theatre (5/28-6/28)
Just in Time in Central New York Just in Time
Proctors Theatre (6/01-6/06)
SWAN LAKE by The United European Ballet Company in Central New York SWAN LAKE by The United European Ballet Company
Lehman Center for the Performing Arts (12/10-12/10)
OFC Creations Theatre Presents: The Witches of Eastwick in Central New York OFC Creations Theatre Presents: The Witches of Eastwick
OFC Creations Theatre (3/04-3/21)
Freestyle Feast: TKA in Central New York Freestyle Feast: TKA
Catholic Health Amphitheater At Bald Hill (7/25-7/25)