Skip to main content Skip to footer site map
Jonalyn Saxer, Katy Geraghty & More to Star in WHAT IF? BELOVED MUSICAL THEATRE CHARACTERS SWITCH SONGS

Jonalyn Saxer, Katy Geraghty & More to Star in WHAT IF? BELOVED MUSICAL THEATRE CHARACTERS SWITCH SONGS

Come see familiar and new faces sing unexpected combinations from the most beloved musicals, while you ponder the question, What If…

What if Regina George sang "I'm the Greatest Star" from Funny Girl? What if the groundbreaking "Dead Mom" from Beetlejuice was given to Little Red from Into The Woods? Join in for an exciting evening of "What If"s as they give your favorite musical theater songs to characters that normally have no relation to them. Come see familiar and new faces sing unexpected combinations from the most beloved musicals, while you ponder the question, What If...

54 BELOW, Broadway's Supper Club, will present What If? Beloved Musical Theatre Characters Switch Songs on December 5, 2022. After a clever first edition in October, What If? is returning to 54 Below with a collection of new songs being sung by both Broadway and up and coming stars.

Featuring: Joe Bliss (The Baker), Helora Danna (The Baker's Wife, Eponine), Erin Engleman (Regina George), Katy Geraghty (Little Red), Mia Cherise Hall (Leading Player), Gryphyn Karimloo (Marius), Abi Monterey (Heather Chandler), Mikayla Renfrow (Cinderella), Carolina Rial (Elphaba), Jonalyn Saxer (Katherine Plumber), and David Wright (Aladdin, Jack Kelly).

Produced by Jorden Amir and Cara Weglarz, with music direction by Jorden Amir.

What If? Part 2 plays 54 Below (254 West 54th Street) on Monday, December 5th at 7:00pm. There is a $35-$75 cover charge and $25 food and beverage minimum. Tickets and information are available at www.54Below.com. Tickets on the day of performance after 4:00 are only available by calling (646) 476-3551.

MORE ABOUT 54 BELOW

54 Below was founded as a place for the Broadway community to celebrate Broadway performers, both established and new, who sing not only the music of Broadway and the Great American Songbook, but also new material intended for Broadway and off-Broadway stages. The club features fine dining and superb scenic, lighting, and sound designs entirely imagined by Broadway designers. For performers, writers, musicians, and more, 54 Below gives opportunities to advance their craft, expand their repertoires, and develop their voices in a way that is more personal, making them stronger as artists. It gives Broadway fans an opportunity to see their favorite artists in a different way, deepening their relationship and understanding of their talent.

A recipient of the 2022 TONY AWARDS® Honor for Excellence in the Theatre, 54 Below celebrates Broadway musicals and writers of the past and present, promoting an ongoing engagement with their work. It is also a place for innovation in musical songwriting and performance. Collaborations born at 54 Below give rise to and help develop new theatrical projects and new musicals. In addition, its popular streaming video activities and audio recordings support these activities, helping to build a new Broadway audience worldwide, both in age and geography.

54 Below is one of the most in-demand performance venues in the city, presenting over 700 shows each year. Unique in its mission, it has become an indispensable member of the Broadway ecosystem, providing a place for seasoned and emerging artists to hone their craft, try out new work, grow their fanbases, and gather as a community. The management team includes Proprietors and nine-time Tony Award® winning Broadway producers Steve Baruch, Richard Frankel, and Tom Viertel, Creative and Programming Director Jennifer Ashley Tepper, and restaurant General Manager Mandisa Boxill.

Located at 254 West 54th Street, the club presents live shows at 7pm and 9:30pm. Tickets and information at 54below.com.



David Sabella to Kick Off International Tour with AMANDA RECKONWITH RETURNS at Pangea Photo
David Sabella - who originaled the role of Mary Sunshine in the current Broadway revival of CHICAGO - will celebrates his return to drag, after 25 years, with his critically acclaimed one person show 'Amanda Reckonwith Returns' in a special performance at Pangea on February 7, 2023, AT 7PM.

See Jennifer Holliday, the Original Broadway Cast of PIPPIN & More Next Month at 54 Be Photo
Next month, 54 BELOW will present some of the brightest stars from Broadway, cabaret, jazz, and beyond. See February's lineup and learn how to purchase tickets!

Susie Moshers Lineup Gets The Chris Ruetten Treatment Photo
It's another photo flash of Susie Mosher's weekly variety show, this time by Chris Ruetten.

Eden Espinosa & Jelani Remy to Join Samantha Pauly at Chelsea Table + Stage in Februar Photo
CHELSEA TABLE + STAGE will present the return of Samantha Pauly, from the original cast of SIX the Musical on Broadway, who continues her monthly residency on Monday, February 27 at 7:00 PM. T


More Hot Stories For You


54 SINGS BROADWAY'S GREATEST HITS to Celebrate 100th Performance in February54 SINGS BROADWAY'S GREATEST HITS to Celebrate 100th Performance in February
January 31, 2023

54 BELOW is set to mark the landmark 100th performance of 54 Sings Broadway’s Greatest Hits! 54 Sings Broadway’s Greatest Hits! plays 54 Below on February 4 at 9:30pm.

IT'S GETTING WEIRD Brings the Music of THE REAL HOUSEWIVES to Arlene's GroceryIT'S GETTING WEIRD Brings the Music of THE REAL HOUSEWIVES to Arlene's Grocery
January 31, 2023

Don’t be tardy for the party, baby! The Real Housewives are coming to Arlene’s Grocery… at least all of their hit singles are! So lace up your Herman Munster shoes, take out a life insurance policy from Vicki Gunvalson, and snag your tix to this one-night-only gay fever dream featuring the music of Countess Luann, Erika Jayne, CANDIACE, and more! They say money can’t buy you class, but it sure can buy you a front row seat to the most Shah-mazing night of your life. 

BLANK: AN ODE TO BROADWAY'S BLACK HISTORY Comes to The Green Room 42BLANK: AN ODE TO BROADWAY'S BLACK HISTORY Comes to The Green Room 42
January 31, 2023

In her directorial debut, Kaitlyn Trusty, in conjunction with Jarrett Winters Morley, will present BLANK: AN ODE TO BROADWAY'S BLACK HISTORY, on Thursday, February 23, at 7 PM. Directed by Kaitlyn Trusty and produced with musical direction by Jarrett Winters Morley, Blank: An Ode To Broadway's Black History honors Black composers, lyricists, performers, and creatives from the Broadway community through their music, and forever reminds us of their lasting impact on the theatrical community.

TOGETHER AGAIN...AGAIN! Comes to the Green Room 42TOGETHER AGAIN...AGAIN! Comes to the Green Room 42
January 31, 2023

Directed and Music Directed by Jarrett Winters Morley, and conceived by Jarrett Winters Morley & Chandler Sinks, Together Again…Again! acknowledges the difficult 18-month period when Broadway was shut down due to Covid-19, 2 years of Broadway's return, and gives an opportunity to celebrate artists whose careers were impacted by this historic event.

David Sabella to Kick Off International Tour with AMANDA RECKONWITH RETURNS at PangeaDavid Sabella to Kick Off International Tour with AMANDA RECKONWITH RETURNS at Pangea
January 30, 2023

David Sabella - who originaled the role of Mary Sunshine in the current Broadway revival of CHICAGO - will celebrates his return to drag, after 25 years, with his critically acclaimed one person show 'Amanda Reckonwith Returns' in a special performance at Pangea on February 7, 2023, AT 7PM.