Review: WUTHERING HEIGHTS, Royal & Derngate

For what it's worth, I think Emily Brontë would probably love this new production of her then controversial 19th century novel, Wuthering Heights. The bold new staging from Inspector Sands seems as likely to thrill audiences hungry for radical reinterpretation as it is to aleinate the traditionalists. With a bleak split level set, an intstructively updated family tree and a cast of six, Brontë's story of passionate, enduring love is deconstructed and reassembled, with prejudice and trauma at the forefront.

Ben Lewis has adapted this unruly tale in two acts, commencing with an offstage voice icily questioning the long-suffering housekeeper, Nelly Dean (Giulia Innocenti). From Nelly's perspective, we are introduced in turn to a then innocent Hindley (John Askew), his already wild sister, Catherine (Lua Bairstow), and their newly adopted brother Heathcliff (Ike Bennett). Bennett's Heathcliff is believable in both his adventurous youth and later gentility but lacks conviction where it matters most. He is ultimately more petulant than rageful and comes off as ineffectual, rendered an inconvenience in the plot rather than the ruthless romantic he could be.

The cast is completed by Leander Deeny and Nicole Sawyerr who are at their best in the second act with winning takes on the previously mentioned characters' descendants: Linton and Young Cathy.

Infused with a modern sensibility, the female characters are emboldened with agency but not presented without criticism, and the relationship between Catherine and Heathcliff is framed as a toxic, hierarchical impossibility. Additionally, it is a powerful choice to conceive Heathcliff as an African immigrant, characterising his early mistreatment and romantic dismissal with an ugly, racist sentiment, though this is scarcely followed up on.

The production's most distinctive aspect is its tone - alternately brash and absurd, though the plot rarely seems lighthearted enough to justify the comic approach. A playfully anachronistic soundtrack sees young lovers serenading each other with classic Backstreet Boys lyrics moments before a visceral depiction of corporal punishment. The laughs come more readily in the second act, when the gravity of the plot is a lesser concern, though the production's two moods still struggle to coexist throughout. Perhaps, like the story's central characters, they are inherently irreconcileable.

Lucinka Eisler's direction is rich with atmosphere and intrigue but inconsistent in its approach. We endure a violent storm instilled by swinging overhead lamps (a striking component of Ben Ormerod's lighting design) and experience Nelly's survivor's guilt via an increasingly cacophonous chorus of amplified voices. Perplexingly, pre-recorded dialogue is mimed at pivotal emotional moments in order to achieve a breathy, whispered quality, despite four largely underutilised onstage microphones being within arm's reach. There is also little to distinguish location as we shift between two neighbouring residences and despite much talk of windows, the production does without any.

Though it offers distinct stark and entertaining moments, this production is ultimately familiar of a theatre in education performance that condenses classics for school assemblies, except for the fact that it has a 135 minute duration (interval not included). Though there is some tremendous prop work with vegetables it is neither an entirely hilarious send up, in the vein of the recent, award-winning Pride and Prejudice (*sort of), nor does it blaze with a contemporary urgency it craves.

Wuthering Heights is at Royal & Derngate until 6 May

Photo Credit: Alex Brenner

To post a comment, you must register and login.

Test and expand your Broadway knowledge with our new game - The Broadway Match-Up! How well do you know your Broadway casting trivia?	Play the Daily Game, explore current shows, and delve into past decades like the 2000s, 80s, and the Golden Age. Challenge your friends and see where you rank!
How well do you know your Tony Awards history? Take our never-ending quiz of nominations and winner history and challenge your friends.	Can you beat your friends? Play today’s daily Broadway word game, featuring a new theatrically inspired word or phrase every day!