Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: THE CHILD IN THE SNOW, Wilton's Music Hall

A tonally confused and unengaging project inspired by Elizabeth Gaskell’s Victorian novella.

Review: THE CHILD IN THE SNOW, Wilton's Music Hall

Review: THE CHILD IN THE SNOW, Wilton's Music Hall It doesn't take much for Wilton's Music Hall to be atmospheric. The Victorian building, with its balcony, stripping paint, and heartbreakingly beautiful cast-iron pillars, lends itself very well to Christmas ghost stories. All of this, combined with Tom Piper's ambitious set design and Hayley Egan's overachieving projections, seems like the perfect production for the theatre's festive comeback. Too bad The Child In The Snow is a tonally confused and unengaging project.

Inspired by Elizabeth Gaskell's Victorian novella The Old Nurse's Story, children's novelist Piers Torday migrates the tale to a post-war Britain. Hester Thornthon (Safiyya Ingar) has just come back from the front, where she was a volunteer nurse. She seeks Mrs Lenard (Debbie Chazen) to reach into her past and gain her memory back, as she suffers from severe PTSD. As the medium goes in and out of trance, Hester is transported back to a lonely Christmas in the moors.

Sadly, director Justin Audibert's project is underwhelming at best. The window dressing is stunning, but the execution of the material falls short. While the humour is scathing and probably the best bit of it all as delivered by Cazen, it feels extreme compared to the excessive and boring dramatics of the rest of the show. Ingar doesn't truly succeed in getting her public invested, either. As she steps on stage in a gas mask, surrounded by smoke and eerie lights, her address is very declamatory. Her delivery is nervous, and she only relaxes into the role towards the end, but by then it's too late to make us care.

Chazen holds a collection of peculiar characters in her pocket. From the eccentric, high-pitched spiritualist to the caring, limping housekeeper, they all share a cartoonish and overdone nature. Yet, it's the most compelling element of the performance. Torday's writing is overly literary and lacks the profound Gothic ingredient needed to make it an uncanny narration. It's left to the design department to set it on the right path, but they can't perform miracles.

The visuals are impressive with dark mahogany and warm lamps set against the stark cold given by the digital art on the screens. Projected snow falls relentlessly, broken apart by bold effects that drive the play and only glitch once or twice. The company use the architecture of Wilton's Music Hall to their advantage by expanding the action to the balconies and leaning on the natural ambience of the auditorium.

The original story has somewhat lost its shine in this new retelling. It's certainly wintery and the Hall always manages to have its wow factor, but The Child in the Snow doesn't have the appeal it could.

The Child in the Snow runs at Wilton's Music Hall until 31 December.



Review: THE BARBER OF SEVILLE, Royal Opera House Photo
Whether you see this because of the scintillating score or because a night at the opera is now cheaper than heating your home, The Barber Of Seville is sure to warm the cockles of your heart.

Photos: See Luke Thompson & More in Rehearsals for A LITTLE LIFE Photo
Go inside rehearsals for A Little Life, which will be playing at the Richmond and Harold Pinter Theatres.

Photos: Go Inside Rehearsals for THE BEACH HOUSE, Coming To Park Theatre Photo
Get a first look at The Beach House, which will premiere at Park Theatre having been shortlisted for Liverpool Hope Playwriting Prize.

Review Roundup: TITUS ANDRONICUS at Shakespeares Globe Photo
Read the reviews for Titus Andronicus at Shakespeare's Globe.


From This Author - Cindy Marcolina

Italian export. Member of the Critics' Circle (Drama). Also a script reader and huge supporter of new work. Twitter: @Cindy_Marcolina

... (read more about this author)

Review: A MANCHESTER ANTHEM, VAULT FestivalReview: A MANCHESTER ANTHEM, VAULT Festival
February 1, 2023

A snapshot of class divide that doubles as a melancholic love letter to the city.

Review: A SOCIETY (FOR THE CUTTING UP OF MEN), VAULT FestivalReview: A SOCIETY (FOR THE CUTTING UP OF MEN), VAULT Festival
February 1, 2023

It becomes more and more evident that we don’t need the traditional conventions displayed at the beginning. While these are probably meant as a visual juxtaposition against the minimalist, more blunt and hands-on approach of the climax, the start is unnecessary. It nearly drives the show to the ground before it’s even started.

Review: DEAD DAD SHOW, VAULT FestivalReview: DEAD DAD SHOW, VAULT Festival
January 30, 2023

Some shows are great even when everything goes wrong. Some shows shine through missed cues, nerves, line prompts, and failing tech. Some shows are simply excellent trainwrecks. Simon David’s Dead Dad Show is one of those. With a personality the size of a football stadium and the effortlessness of a consummate entertainer, he saves his own piece. It could have all gone so very wrong, but it didn’t.

Review: INTRUDER/INTRUZ, VAULT FestivalReview: INTRUDER/INTRUZ, VAULT Festival
January 30, 2023

Remi Rachuba moved to Glasgow from Poland in the late 90s to pursue his dreams and become an actor. A bright young man with stars in his eyes, he learns swear words at his teaching job in a special needs school. Mugged twice, he’s left severely traumatised. He constantly looks behind his shoulder for his “intruder”.

Review: BUTCHERED, VAULT FestivalReview: BUTCHERED, VAULT Festival
January 29, 2023

There are some shows that fit perfectly within the walls of The Vaults. Magic is made when old bricks and humidity meet the right production. Expial Atrocious’ Butchered is one of those that feel at home enveloped by the horrid architecture and the rumblings of Waterloo Station. The love child of Sweeney Todd and Hannibal, it’s a grim look at life and death in a dog-eat-dog world.