Get theatre news and discounts for Tampa
Amityville '74 show poster

Amityville '74 at Carrollwood Cultural Center

Dates: 10/17/2025 - 10/26/2025

Theatre:

Carrollwood Cultural Center


4537 Lowell Road
Tampa,FL 33618

Phone: 813-922-8167


  1. View All Tampa Shows
  2.  > 
  3. Amityville '74


At 3:15 am on November 13, 1974, Ronald “Butch” Defeo took a .35 caliber Marlin Rifle and murdered his entire family in cold blood. Adapted from a series of interviews conducted over the span of four decades, this dramatic thriller explores the chilling events that occurred at the infamous Dutch Colonial on 112 Ocean Avenue, known throughout the globe as the Amityville Murder House. (For mature audiences.)

Amityville '74 by Tommy Jamerson and directed by Joshua Eberhart is presented through a special arrangement with Next Stage Press, Inc.  *An ASL interpreter will be available for the performance on October 24. Please inquire at the time of purchase.

Cast and Creative team for Amityville '74 at Carrollwood Cultural Center

Cast

Paul Berg

Ronald "Butch" DeFeo Jr (2019)


Donovan Dykes

Ronald "Butch" DeFeo Jr (1974))


Jimmy Barringer

Ronald DeFeo Sr


Melissa Mastromarchi

Louise DeFeo


Korre Trotti

Dawn DeFeo


Camilla Palacios

Julie DeFeo


Kamyla Ospino

Jenny DeFeo


Peaches Brown

Alexis Russo


Anna Hoyt

Jodie


Chelsea Smith

Peg


Mackley Fogarty

Ensemble


Samantha Sacasa

Ensemble


Creative Team

Tommy Jamerson

Author


Joshua Eberhart

Director


Jessica Duncan

Stage Manager


Paul Berg

Set Design


Daniel Gentry

Sound Design


Shelby Smotherman

Lighting Design


Jessica Duncan

Costume Design




Videos


A Tribute to Sarah Brightman and Andrea Bocelli in Tampa A Tribute to Sarah Brightman and Andrea Bocelli
The Palladium St Pete (1/8 - 1/8) Tracker
PHOTOS VIDEOS DISCOUNT
Ho, Ho, Hope, Peace, Love, & Laughter in Tampa Ho, Ho, Hope, Peace, Love, & Laughter
TheatreFor (12/12 - 12/21)

COMEDY HOLIDAY SHOW Tracker
A Christmas Carol: A Live Radio Play in Tampa A Christmas Carol: A Live Radio Play
Shimberg Playhouse, Straz Center for the Performing Arts (12/4 - 12/23) Tracker
Jeff Allen: The Human Condition - We're Still Not There Yet Tour in Tampa Jeff Allen: The Human Condition - We're Still Not There Yet Tour
Richey Suncoast Theatre (12/12 - 12/12)
ALL ARE WELCOME! 'ENGLEWOOD ELKS' presents 'SHOWER OF STARS TRIBUTE SHOW'. in Tampa ALL ARE WELCOME! 'ENGLEWOOD ELKS' presents 'SHOWER OF STARS TRIBUTE SHOW'.
Elks Lodge (1/10 - 1/10)
The Nutracker in Tampa The Nutracker
Ovations Repertory Company (12/20 - 12/20)
Into the Woods in Tampa Into the Woods
American Stage (3/25 - 4/26)
A Christmas Carol in Tampa A Christmas Carol
Carrollwood Players Theatre (12/5 - 12/21)
R.U.R. (Rossum's Universal Robots) in Tampa R.U.R. (Rossum's Universal Robots)
Carrollwood Cultural Center (8/22 - 8/23)
& Juliet in Tampa & Juliet
Straz Center [Carol Morsani Hall] (2/10 - 2/15)
VIEW SHOWS  ADD A SHOW