The Fantasticks Revival Off-Broadway Replacement Cast

(The Boy)

Erik Altemus, a graduate of the University of Cincinnati's College-Conservatory of Music, made his New York City debut as Matt (the boy) in the long-running hit musical The Fantasticks. more...

George Lee Andrews

Hucklebee

(The Boy's Father)

George Lee Andrews, known for his record-breaking run in "Phantom of the Opera," brings over 50 years of theatrical experience to his role in "The Fantasticks." more...

Whitney Bashor

(The Girl)

Whitney Bashor, who captivated audiences with her award-winning performance in The Bridges of Madison County, also showcased her talents in the Off-Broadway production of The Fantasticks. more...

Bill Bateman

(The Girl's Father)

(The Narrator)

Shavey Brown, who played El Gallo in the Off-Broadway production of The Fantasticks, has an impressive resume that includes a Tony Award-winning performance in the Broadway revival of Sunset Boulevard and roles in national tours of Hadestown and The Prom. more...

Samantha Bruce

(The Girl)

Samantha Bruce made her Off-Broadway debut in The Fantasticks, bringing her extensive regional theater experience to the iconic production. more...

Aaron Carter

(The Boy)

Aaron Carter, known for his successful music career in the late 1990s and early 2000s, also showcased his versatility by performing in the off-Broadway musical *The Fantasticks*. more...

Lewis Cleale

(The Narrator)

Lewis Cleale, known for his extensive Broadway career including roles in "Book of Mormon" and "Spamalot," also brought his talents to the Off-Broadway production of "The Fantasticks." more...

Donald Corren

Hucklebee

(The Girl's Father)

Donald Corren, known for his extensive Off-Broadway work and his role as Forensic Technician Medill on NBC's "Law & Order" from 1991-99, brings his seasoned talent to the cast of The Fantasticks. more...

Julie Craig

The Mute (u/s)

(Standby)
(The Girl)

Julie Craig showcased her talent as Luisa in the Off-Broadway production of *The Fantasticks* at the Jerry Orbach Theatre. more...

Pierce Cravens

Matt (u/s)

(Understudy)
(The Boy)

Pierce Cravens, who previously performed Off-Broadway in productions such as "HereAfter" at Theatre 80 and "Silver Nitrate" at Blue Heron Theatre, brought his talent to the cast of "The Fantasticks." more...

Max Mendoza Crumm

(The Boy)

Max Crumm, who portrayed Matt in the Off-Broadway production of The Fantasticks at the Jerry Orbach Theater, has a diverse range of roles both on and off Broadway. more...

John Davidson

(The Girl's Father)

John Davidson, who made his TV debut playing The Boy in The Fantasticks, has had a remarkable career spanning over 50 years, including notable roles on Broadway and in Hollywood, and will be performing live at Cortland Repertory Theatre Downtown for a special one-night event. more...

Bradley Dean

(The Narrator)

Bradley Dean, who previously graced the stage as El Gallo in *The Fantasticks*, has an extensive Broadway resume, including roles in *A Little Night Music*, *Spamalot*, and *Dear Evan Hansen*. more...

Joseph Dellger

(The Girl's Father)

Joseph Dellger, known for his Broadway performances in Porgy and Bess, Lestat, and Ragtime, brought his extensive experience to the cast of The Fantasticks. more...

(The Boy's Father)

(The Man Who Dies)

MacIntyre Dixon, known for his extensive Broadway career including roles in "Cyrano de Bergerac" and "Beauty and The Beast," brought his seasoned talent to "The Fantasticks." more...

(The Narrator)

(The Boy)

Anthony Fedorov, best known for his impressive run as the 4th place finalist on American Idol Season Four, made his off-Broadway debut in "The Fantasticks" alongside the show's creator Tom Jones, showcasing his remarkable journey from overcoming a childhood tracheotomy to becoming a celebrated tenor. more...

(Standby)
(The Boy's Father)

Tom Flagg, who was part of the original cast of The Fantasticks, left the show three times for Broadway productions and later trained U.S. Marines and Navy Personnel in martial arts. more...

Margaret Anne Florence

(The Girl)

(The Narrator)

Ivan Hernandez, known for his Broadway role as Billy Flynn in "Chicago" and his regional performance as The Wolf/Cinderella's Prince in "Into the Woods" at the Delacorte, brings his extensive experience to the cast of "The Fantasticks." more...

Liz Holtan

(Standby)
(The Girl)

Kimberly Immanuel

(Standby)

Kimberly Immanuel, who served as the standby for Luisa and The Mute in the Off-Broadway production of The Fantasticks, boasts an impressive resume that includes roles in national tours of Wicked and Hadestown, as well as multiple regional theater accolades. more...

Jeremiah James

(The Narrator)

Jeremiah James, who previously graced the stage in the Off-Broadway production of The Fantasticks, boasts an impressive resume that spans Broadway, West End, regional theater, radio, TV, and film. more...

(The Boy's Father)

Matt Leisy, who has graced the stage in productions such as The Fantasticks at the Jerry Orbach Theatre, has an impressive resume that spans Broadway tours and regional theater, showcasing his versatility and talent in the world of musical theater. more...

(The Girl)

(Standby)
(The Boy’s Father)

Stuart Marland, known for his versatile performances, was part of the original cast of "Tales of the City" at A.C.T San Francisco in 2011, where he showcased his talent by playing multiple roles including Charles Hilary Lord, Mr. Tolliver, Dr. Kinkaid, and Mr. Siegel. more...

(The Girl)

(The Narrator)

(Replaced in previews)

James Moye, who has an extensive background in both Broadway and regional theater, including a Helen Hayes nomination for "110 In the Shade," was a standout in past productions of "The Fantasticks." more...

Rita Neidich

(Standby)
(The Girl)

Rita Neidich, who has an extensive background in both Off-Broadway and regional theater, previously graced the stage in the iconic Off-Broadway production of The Fantasticks. more...

(The Man Who Dies)

Michael Nostrand is thrilled to revisit The Fantasticks, having previously played Mortimer at the Sullivan St. Playhouse for over 1,000 performances. more...

(Understudy)

Madison Claire Parks captivated audiences with over 400 performances as Luisa in THE FANTASTICKS Off-Broadway at the Jerry Orbach Theatre in New York. more...

Dennis Parlato

(The Narrator)

Dennis Parlato, known for his extensive Broadway credits including "A Chorus Line" and "Chess," as well as his memorable TV roles on "One Life to Live" and "The Guiding Light," brought his seasoned talent to the cast of "The Fantasticks." more...

(The Girl)

Andrew Polec, known for his dynamic performance in Bat Out of Hell, also captivated audiences Off-Broadway in the timeless production of The Fantasticks. more...

(Standby)

(Understudy)
(The Narrator)

Richard Roland, a third-generation Broadway veteran and versatile performer, captivated Off-Broadway audiences with his role in The Fantasticks, showcasing his extensive experience and talent in the world of theater. more...

Steve Routman

(The Girl's Father)

Steve Routman, who brought his extensive theater experience to the stage, was a notable cast member in "The Fantasticks." more...

Daniel Rowan

Matt (u/s)

(Understudy)
(The Boy)

Daniel Rowan, an actor and writer hailing from small-town East Texas, recently showcased his talents in The Fantasticks, following his notable performances in productions such as Candide with Bradley Cooper and Carey Mulligan, and Bernstein's MASS, which premiered on PBS in February 2020. more...

Jim Schubin

(The Boy)

Jim Schubin, a New York-based actor-singer, captivated audiences as Matt in the Off-Broadway production of The Fantasticks, showcasing his talent in one of the longest-running musicals in history. more...

Jonathan Schwartz

(The Boy)

Jonathan Schwartz, who has performed in Broadway hits like Aladdin and Elf, showcased his talent Off-Broadway in The Fantasticks, bringing his diverse experience to the beloved classic. more...

Drew Seigla

Drew Seigla, a Richmond, VA native, captivated audiences with his “stunning tenor voice” during his Off-Broadway debut as Matt; The Mute in The Fantasticks, where he performed for a remarkable two-year run. more...

Dan Sharkey

Hucklebee

(The Boy's Father)

Dan Sharkey, who has an impressive Broadway resume including roles in "Amazing Grace" and "The Bridges of Madison County," also brought his talents to the stage in the past with "The Fantasticks." more...

(The Man Who Dies)

(Standby)
(The Narrator)

Nick Spangler

(The Boy)

Nick Spangler's acclaimed Off-Broadway performance as Matt in The Fantasticks earned him the prestigious Theater Hall of Fame Elaine and Jerry Orbach Fellowship Award. more...

(The Old Actor)

(The Girl)

(The Boy)

(The Old Actor)

(The Girl)

Cathryn Wake, known for her diverse roles in world-premiere productions, also showcased her talents in the Off-Broadway production of THE FANTASTICKS. more...

Edward Watts