Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

EDINBURGH 2023: Review: ICE HOLE: A CARDBOARD COMEDY, The Grand at Pleasance Courtyard

Impressive clowning, physical theatre and a growing pile of used cardboard

By:
Featured Topic Edinburgh Festival More Coverage

EDINBURGH 2023: Review: ICE HOLE: A CARDBOARD COMEDY, The Grand at Pleasance Courtyard ImageEDINBURGH 2023: Review: ICE HOLE: A CARDBOARD COMEDY, The Grand at Pleasance Courtyard Image

A goofy, fantastical mermaid tale told through labelled cardboard signs accompanied by an unidentifiable language that sounds like a fusion between Icelandic and Simlish? It sounds ludicrous, but strangely.... it works.

Pierre Guillois and Olivier Martin-Salvan (who brought us acclaimed hit Fishbowl last year) unfold their Molière award-winning cardboard-filled piece at the Edinburgh Fringe. Beginning in the fjords of Iceland, a man fishes in a frozen lake - both fishing rod and lake are represented by pieces of labelled cardboard. He unintentionally catches a mermaid called Serena, sparking love at first sight. After accidentally releasing her, the play showcases his strenuous journey across the globe to find his love. From bagpipe players in the Scottish highlands to baguettes in France and Flamenco dancers in Spain, our hero faces an abundance of European stereotypes while shaping a commentary on our perceptions of other cultures.

Set, props, costume pieces and animals are represented through cardboard - it is a clever, unique, surreal idea that transcends the limits of traditional theatre. The protagonist of the story rarely moves, remaining centrestage on a cardboard stool, while the other character runs frantically revealing different pieces of cardboard throughout the piece. It is a play-within-a-play, with both actors sometimes breaking character to reveal the absurdly abusive, strained relationship between them. The story gets increasingly chaotic through impressive clowning, physical theatre and a growing pile of used cardboard tossed around the stage.

It could be shorter - a few moments feel unnecessarily repetitive in order to fill out their 1 hour 15 minute time slot. The humour is silly and child-like - it works for me, but isn't for everyone. Once the thrill of the cardboard wears off, it does drag a little bit. 

Overall a surreal, unique theatrical experience highly recommended at the Fringe.

Ice Hole: A Cardboard Comedy is at Pleasance Courtyard until August 28

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on The Grand At Pleasance Courtyard
Upcoming Shows
Garry Starr: Classic Penguins
8/5 - 8/30/2026

Reader Reviews

Need more Scotland Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


Antigone 1989: A Town Hall Musical in Scotland Antigone 1989: A Town Hall Musical
Gilded Balloon Patter House (8/05-8/29) PHOTOS VIDEOS
Elvis in Chaos in Scotland Elvis in Chaos
Lime Studio at Greenside @ George Street (8/07-8/15) VIDEOS
Chris Grace: 88% in Scotland Chris Grace: 88%
Assembly George Square (8/05-8/31)
Safety in Scotland Safety
Underbelly, Daisy (8/05-8/30)
Ian Stone: The Pleb's Pow Wow in Scotland Ian Stone: The Pleb's Pow Wow
The Ballroom at Laughing Horse at The Counting House (8/06-8/30)
Tale of the Firebird in Scotland Tale of the Firebird
Assembly Roxy (Central) (8/06-8/30)
How Not to Make it in America in Scotland How Not to Make it in America
Summerhall (Former Gent’s Locker Room) (8/06-8/31)
Rockpools in Scotland Rockpools
Pleasance Courtyard (Bunker 3) (8/05-8/30)
Sapphire McIntosh: Squeaky Bum Time in Scotland Sapphire McIntosh: Squeaky Bum Time
Unerbelly Bristo Square - Daisy Room (8/05-8/30)
This Is How I Got Arrested (after smuggling drugs across the border but never actually getting caught with any drugs) in Scotland This Is How I Got Arrested (after smuggling drugs across the border but never actually getting caught with any drugs)
ZOO (Playground 3) (8/07-8/30)