Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

EDINBURGH 2023: Review: I LOVE YOU, NOW WHAT?, Pleasance Courtyard

A tale as old as time. A couple fall in love while struggling with a family tragedy.

By:
Featured Topic Edinburgh Festival More Coverage EDINBURGH 2023: Review: I LOVE YOU, NOW WHAT?, Pleasance Courtyard

EDINBURGH 2023: Review: I LOVE YOU, NOW WHAT?, Pleasance Courtyard Image

A napkin with the writing “You might need this” welcomes punters to their seats. A man is sitting on the piano, pensive and seemingly waiting for something, when Theo crashes into his daughter at a party. What ensues is a formulaic romantic comedy set against the battle against cancer.

After their meet-cute on bonfire night, Ava and Theo embark on a potboiler story with an obvious plot. Her playful pride finds fertile soil in his nonchalant affection; both awkward in the same ways and with a penchant for incredibly lame jokes, they’re made for one another.

Sophie Craig examines love and grief, refusal to let go, and the ultimate acceptance that has to come. Unchallenging but effective comic bits lighten up a flimsy piece while director Toby Clarke attempts to add allegory with a piano that becomes central to the visuals of the project.

All in all, it’s not a great play, but it’s also not a particularly bad one either. It’s tentatively poetic but commonplace, with a dash of humdrum personal reflection in the mix. Jealousy, love, pain, bereavement; it’s a to-do list of life.

I Love You, Now What? runs at the Pleasance Courtyard on the following dates: 10-13, 15-20, 22-28 August.

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on Pleasance Courtyard
Upcoming Shows
A Foot is Not an Appropriate Prize for the Tombola
7/4 - 8/31/2026
Day of the Locust
8/1 - 8/31/2026
Recent Articles
Maxwell Caulfield to Present PILATE: The Lost Gospel to Edinburgh Fringe
Maxwell Caulfield to Present PILATE: The Lost Gospel to Edinburgh Fringe
8/10/2026
EDINBURGH 2026: Review: ONE MAN MUSICAL, Pleasance Courtyard
EDINBURGH 2026: Review: ONE MAN MUSICAL, Pleasance Courtyard
8/9/2026

Reader Reviews

Need more Scotland Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


Antigone 1989: A Town Hall Musical in Scotland Antigone 1989: A Town Hall Musical
Gilded Balloon Patter House (8/05-8/29) PHOTOS VIDEOS
Elvis in Chaos in Scotland Elvis in Chaos
Lime Studio at Greenside @ George Street (8/07-8/15) VIDEOS
To Do Lists in Scotland To Do Lists
Pleasance Courtyard (The Green) (8/05-8/31)
Tap Out! (Or I'll Hit You Again) in Scotland Tap Out! (Or I'll Hit You Again)
Gilded Balloon Patter House – Coorie (8/05-8/31)
Trainspotting The Musical in Scotland Trainspotting The Musical
Edinburgh Playhouse (10/19-10/24)
Forget About Me in Scotland Forget About Me
Forgot About Me (8/05-8/31)
Count Arthur Strong - And It’s Goodnight From Me! in Scotland Count Arthur Strong - And It’s Goodnight From Me!
EICC (5/30-5/30)
Operotica: Lovers in Every Lifetime in Scotland Operotica: Lovers in Every Lifetime
Underbelly Bristo Square (8/05-8/30)
Argonauts in Scotland Argonauts
ZOO (Playground 2) (8/07-8/30)
Friendliest in Scotland Friendliest
Gilded Balloon (The Nook) (8/08-8/31)