Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Michael Sommers — Theater Critic

New York Stage Review, New Jersey Newsroom, NJ Newsroom

Reviews on BroadwayWorld
166
Average score
6.84 / 10
Most recent review
10/9/2026
Thumbs Sideways

Reviews by Michael Sommers

9
Thumbs Up

REVIEW: ‘One Man, Two Guvnors’ delivers laughter

From: NJ Newsroom  |  Date: 4/18/2012

Led by the roly-poly and irresistibly droll Corden – an ebullient performer clad in mismatched checks as the modern-day Harlequin figure –a skilled 16-member ensemble whips through a wacky progression of pratfalls, slapstick nonsense, cheeky doings and assorted other low-comedy capers. It’s all too ridiculous for words so let’s take a pass on detailing the madness that erupts constantly for more than two hours.

9
Thumbs Up

REVIEW: ‘One Man, Two Guvnors’ delivers laughter

From: NJ Newsroom  |  Date: 4/18/2012

Led by the roly-poly and irresistibly droll Corden – an ebullient performer clad in mismatched checks as the modern-day Harlequin figure –a skilled 16-member ensemble whips through a wacky progression of pratfalls, slapstick nonsense, cheeky doings and assorted other low-comedy capers. It’s all too ridiculous for words so let’s take a pass on detailing the madness that erupts constantly for more than two hours.

7
Thumbs Sideways

REVIEW: ‘Peter and the Starcatcher’ offers magical doings

From: NJ Newsroom  |  Date: 4/15/2012

Pirates, orphans, natives, mermaids and a gigantic crocodile romp through a two-act tale bursting with dastardly doings, epic chases, daring escapes and silly humor. Co-directed by Roger Rees and Alex Timbers, the off-Broadway production offered delightful entertainment. Some of that charm is missing, unfortunately, from the Broadway version of the show, which opened on Sunday at the Brooks Atkinson Theatre.

Magic/Bird Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

REVIEW: ‘Magic/Bird’ scores high

From: NJ Newsroom  |  Date: 4/11/2012

Playwright Eric Simonson, who did so ably by a football legend with “Lombardi,” now gives sports- and theater-loving customers alike an enjoyable mix of strong story, smart writing and real-life video that zooms by in 100 minutes. Director Thomas Kail’s staging provides plenty of punch, complete with fine acting and sharp visuals.

Magic/Bird Broadway
8
Thumbs Up

REVIEW: ‘Magic/Bird’ scores high

From: NJ Newsroom  |  Date: 4/11/2012

Playwright Eric Simonson, who did so ably by a football legend with “Lombardi,” now gives sports- and theater-loving customers alike an enjoyable mix of strong story, smart writing and real-life video that zooms by in 100 minutes. Director Thomas Kail’s staging provides plenty of punch, complete with fine acting and sharp visuals.

4
Thumbs Sideways

REVIEW: ‘End of the Rainbow’ reveals trash

From: NJ Newsroom  |  Date: 4/2/2012

It’s trash. Judy swills, Judy sings, Judy vomits, Judy goes on singing. Pulp rubbish by playwright Peter Quilter. [...] In her wilder throes as Garland flailing through a number, Bennett gets awfully Kabuki about it, but you can’t deny her power even if she’s driving a third-rate hearse of a play.

7
Thumbs Sideways

REVIEW: William Shatner reveals his ‘World’

From: New Jersey Newsroom  |  Date: 2/16/2012

Bowing on Thursday for a brief sojourn at the Music Box, the actor’s solo show provides a pleasant 100-minute stroll down memory lane in this strictly fans-only attraction. ... It’s not much of a solo Broadway show compared to more ambitious events like Billy Crystal’s “700 Sundays” or Elaine Stritch’s “At Liberty,” but “Shatner’s World” will satisfy customers simply pleased to observe Shatner being Shatner in the flesh.

7
Thumbs Sideways

REVIEW: William Shatner reveals his ‘World’

From: New Jersey Newsroom  |  Date: 2/16/2012

Bowing on Thursday for a brief sojourn at the Music Box, the actor’s solo show provides a pleasant 100-minute stroll down memory lane in this strictly fans-only attraction. ... It’s not much of a solo Broadway show compared to more ambitious events like Billy Crystal’s “700 Sundays” or Elaine Stritch’s “At Liberty,” but “Shatner’s World” will satisfy customers simply pleased to observe Shatner being Shatner in the flesh.

7
Thumbs Sideways

REVIEW: ‘Porgy and Bess’ revamped as a Broadway musical

From: NJ Newsroom  |  Date: 1/12/2012

Certainly the show is a must-see due to Audra McDonald’s beautifully sung and fiercely acted portrayal of Bess. Sporting a scar on her cheek, fire in her eyes and plenty of star power, McDonald fleshes out a believably human portrait of a flawed, fallen woman struggling to get back on her feet. Extra thrills that McDonald delivers include her spooky rendition of “Leaving for the Promised Land” and a deeply-felt “I Loves You, Porgy.”

7
Thumbs Sideways

REVIEW: ‘Porgy and Bess’ revamped as a Broadway musical

From: NJ Newsroom  |  Date: 1/12/2012

Certainly the show is a must-see due to Audra McDonald’s beautifully sung and fiercely acted portrayal of Bess. Sporting a scar on her cheek, fire in her eyes and plenty of star power, McDonald fleshes out a believably human portrait of a flawed, fallen woman struggling to get back on her feet. Extra thrills that McDonald delivers include her spooky rendition of “Leaving for the Promised Land” and a deeply-felt “I Loves You, Porgy.”

Bonnie & Clyde Broadway
7
Thumbs Sideways

REVIEW: ‘Bonnie & Clyde’ shoot it out on Broadway

From: NJ Newsroom  |  Date: 12/1/2011

The show occasionally jolts but it generally fails to electrify viewers or inspire much pity for its hard-luck protagonists. Perhaps a full-blown operatic treatment is the only way to illuminate a story as dark as this one.

8
Thumbs Up

REVIEW: Hugh Jackman arrives ‘Back on Broadway’

From: NJ Newsroom  |  Date: 11/10/2011

Opening with 'Oh, What a Beautiful Morning,' Jackman expertly cavorts through several tuneful medleys, most notably a high-kicking salute to classic movie musicals. A freely-interpreted 'Somewhere Over the Rainbow' and a resonant journey through Billy Bigelow's 'Soliloquy' from 'Carousel' are other standouts, while a segment involving the Australian outback and its native musicians offers a soulful change in mood.

8
Thumbs Up

REVIEW: Hugh Jackman arrives ‘Back on Broadway’

From: NJ Newsroom  |  Date: 11/10/2011

Opening with 'Oh, What a Beautiful Morning,' Jackman expertly cavorts through several tuneful medleys, most notably a high-kicking salute to classic movie musicals. A freely-interpreted 'Somewhere Over the Rainbow' and a resonant journey through Billy Bigelow's 'Soliloquy' from 'Carousel' are other standouts, while a segment involving the Australian outback and its native musicians offers a soulful change in mood.

1
Thumbs Down

'Relatively Speaking' involves a joyless threesome

From: New Jersey Newsroom  |  Date: 10/19/2011

John Turturro staged the plays. Because the material is so poor it’s impossible to assess his work. Three-time Tony-winning designer Santo Loquasto provides a trio of homely settings. Since each play involves unattractive characters being unpleasant, these environs prove to be relatively appropriate.

The Mountaintop Broadway
3
Thumbs Down

Samuel L. Jackson ascends ‘The Mountaintop’

From: New Jersey Newsroom  |  Date: 10/14/2011

Evidently “The Mountaintop” was taken very seriously last year in London, where it won an Olivier Award. Frankly, I think the play is well-meaning rubbish that trivializes an extraordinary man.

Man and Boy Broadway
9
Thumbs Up

‘Man and Boy’ studies a scoundrel and his son

From: New Jersey Newsroom  |  Date: 10/10/2011

Sure, Roundabout Theatre Company's 'Man and Boy' revival may be dismissed as merely so much cheese and ham by some viewers, but I find it yummy. Anyone with a taste for old-fashioned Broadway theatrics richly furnished will enjoy the production that opened Sunday at American Airlines Theatre.

3
Thumbs Down

'Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark' zips open

From: New Jersey Newsroom  |  Date: 6/14/2011

Watching this elaborate if numbing attraction at the Foxwoods, theatergoers with long memories may recall the Andrew Lloyd Webber musical “Starlight Express,” which opened in 1987 and was the most expensive-ever show of its day. Costing a cool $8 million, the musical involved roller-skating performers impersonating trains running on tracks laid around the auditorium, lasted 700-odd performances and never paid off its investment both commercially and as satisfying theater for adults. While there is certainly a significant audience for junk food-style entertainment on Broadway, I wonder whether the million empty calories represented by “Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark” will be tasty enough to attract sufficient customers for a very long time.

Baby It's You! Broadway
7
Thumbs Sideways

Jersey girls raid the jukebox for ‘Baby, It's You!'

From: New Jersey Newsroom  |  Date: 4/28/2011

Meanwhile, those vintage song hits just keep on coming and Baby Boomers who are pushovers for nostalgic entertainment may well be diverted by “Baby, It’s You!,” which is synthetic in composition but thoroughly expert in delivery.

Baby It's You! Broadway
7
Thumbs Sideways

Jersey girls raid the jukebox for ‘Baby, It's You!'

From: New Jersey Newsroom  |  Date: 4/28/2011

Meanwhile, those vintage song hits just keep on coming and Baby Boomers who are pushovers for nostalgic entertainment may well be diverted by “Baby, It’s You!,” which is synthetic in composition but thoroughly expert in delivery.

The Normal Heart Broadway
9
Thumbs Up

'The Normal Heart' pounds with anger over AIDS

From: New Jersey Newsroom  |  Date: 4/28/2011

Directed by George C. Wolfe and Joel Grey (who took over the role of Ned from Brad Davis during the original run), the production clearly is a labor of love. Under their guidance, the company’s acting is bold and powerful, with a genuinely raw edge to its emotions that rubs the starch out of the play’s overtly socio-political contents. The look is appropriately stark, with a white box of a set subtly designed by David Rockwell that gradually grows darker with the play’s mounting toll of mortality.

5
Thumbs Sideways

'The House of Blue Leaves' leaves everything to be desired

From: New Jersey Newsroom  |  Date: 4/26/2011

Newcomers to “The House of Blue Leaves” are unlikely to see beyond Cromer’s misguided staging to appreciate the play itself while people who know and love it are advised to skip this unworthy occasion.

Born Yesterday Broadway
10
Thumbs Up

'Born Yesterday' revival delivers timely laughter

From: New Jersey Newsroom  |  Date: 4/24/2011

Cynics may feel they're watching an animated civics lesson, but the play's plentiful humor drowns their doubts in laughter. Kanin’s potent mix of mirth and truth is expertly served by Frank Wood as the glib, self-hating attorney, Terry Beaver as the uneasy Senator up for sale and Patricia Hodges as a sporty Congressional matron. Never removing his fedora in the 'cherce' role of the junkman's cousin and slavey, Michael McGrath lopes around like a guy out of Damon Runyon.

Jerusalem Broadway
7
Thumbs Sideways

'Jerusalem' speaks to England's changing culture

From: New Jersey Newsroom  |  Date: 4/22/2011

An award-winning hit in London, “Jerusalem” is very, very, very English in its cultural references and significance. As the play wends its garrulous way towards a baleful conclusion, some American viewers may wonder why they should care about Johnny, a messy wastrel who idly corrupts adolescents. But that would be missing the higher pretensions of Butterworth’s drama and certainly not appreciating Rylance’s deeply-immersed depiction of Johnny.

Sister Act Broadway
9
Thumbs Up

'Sister Act' makes a joyful noise

From: New Jersey Newsroom  |  Date: 4/21/2011

Regarding the buffet of new Broadway tuners concocted from recent movies: If “Priscilla Queen of the Desert” is too hot and “Catch Me If You Can” is too cold for the taste of middle-of-the-musical-road consumers, then “Sister Act” is juuuuuust right.

Wonderland Broadway
5
Thumbs Sideways

'Wonderland' opens on Broadway

From: New Jersey Newsroom  |  Date: 4/18/2011

Bowing on Sunday at the Marquis Theater, “Wonderland” sports good performances, snazzy costumes and even some attractive tunes by Frank Wildhorn but writer-director Gregory Boyd’s approach proves pointless because it sheds no bright or at least interesting 21st-century insights on the Victorian material.

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Buy Tickets
Hot Show
Buy Tickets
Hot Show
Tickets From $58
Hot Show
Tickets From $102