Review: Brelby's Allegiance to THE PLEDGE Yields Magical Results

Review: Brelby's Allegiance to THE PLEDGE Yields Magical Results
Brelby Theatre's Production of Megan O'Connor's The Pledge

Megan O'Connor's The Pledge is a startlingly clever new play that opened last Friday at Historic Downtown Glendale's Brelby Theatre Company.

This review is going to sound weird, but there's no getting around it. The play is about illusionism - sleight of hand, "misdirection," beguilement - good old fashioned magic. As such, its secrets can't be told. More precisely, its truths can't be revealed without - literally - spoiling the whole thing. Thus - the weird review.

Directed by Brelby co-founder Brian Maticic, the production unfolds in two crisp acts that blaze through time and space and entirely upend their own premise, leaving the witness dizzy and somewhere between sobs and incredulous shock.

Review: Brelby's Allegiance to THE PLEDGE Yields Magical Results
Jen Gantwerker in Megan O'Connor's The Pledge

At the center of the excellent production is Jen Gantwerker as Natty, a "magician's wife" and pastry chef. Gantwerker is wicked smart, enormously talented, and plays the hell out of her sharply written, complicated role.

Clayton Caufman's David is both frustrating and endearing. An emerging magician, David is all over the map psychologically and seems emotionally at once conflicted and detached.

During an impressive magical card trick, Caufman asks for a volunteer from the audience. The play suddenly becomes a traditional magic show. At the performance this writer attended, a tall, striking woman stepped out of the house and onto the stage. It was hard to believe she wasn't rehearsed, so poised was she. I learned at intermission that she's Shandi Ilyse, a theatre artist who has performed on Brelby's stage. You won't get to see her in The Pledge, but the trick is great fun and that moment will be informed by whomever is that "actor" who goes there with Caufman's David.

Alex Tuchi, always interesting and unpredictable, playfully and sometimes angrily renders a rather labyrinthine barista. Willa Eigo and Jessie Tully play characters I can't actually talk about without giving away magician's secrets. The same goes for James Beneze's character or characters - you have to see the show to decide what it is he's doing, and even then - good luck. What I can tell you is that Eigo, Tully and Beneze are talented, strong and entertaining. Katelyn Landaal makes her stage debut in a bit part that puts the whole thing in perspective - if there is such a thing in a work as disorienting as is The Pledge.

Brian Maticic's nimble staging is unselfconscious, clean and economic. There's nothing sloppy or superfluous about any moment in the production. The set, lights, costumes, hair/makeup, sound and even the building's constantly humming fans/air conditioning all feel concomitant - even we, sitting in the audience, have a feeling we were part of the design.

I expect we'll hear more from Megan O'Connor and her most impressive first full-length play. Huge respect and gratitude go to Brelby for their commitment to their artists and to original, new work.

If you're smart, you'll get your tickets asap, because The Pledge runs only through July 1. Tickets and information can be obtained at


Review: Brelby's Allegiance to THE PLEDGE Yields Magical Results
Brelby Logo

Mission Statement

The mission of the Brelby Theatre Company is to foster an environment for artists to imagine and grow freely, create quality intimate theatre, and inspire our community.

Company Vision

Through the production of professional quality shows, and the operation of high quality classes and workshops, the Brelby Theatre Company will work to become the epicenter of theatre in the West Valley arts community, and a valuable member of the arts in Arizona. Brelby Theatre Company strives to provide directors, writers, designers and actors with a safe environment to enhance their creative abilities and explore their talents, through the creation of live theatre. Through all of this the Brelby Theatre company aims to be recognized around the state and the southwest as an example of a thriving arts and entertainment organization.

Company Values

As theatre is a collaborative art, we are looking for individuals who are not only well-rounded, but interested in learning about new aspects of the art form. Our company members will each be expected to take roles in various facets of each season.

Related Articles

Phoenix Metro THEATER Stories | Shows  Follow BWW Arizona

From This Author Jeanmarie Simpson

Jeanmarie Simpson Jeanmarie (Simpson) Bishop has been a BWW contributor in Tucson, Reno/Sacramento and Toronto, before landing in Phoenix. She is Founding Artistic Director of the Universal (read more...)

  • 1070 Dedicated to Slain Civil Rights Activist Heather Heyer
  • Review: DROPPIN' JOHNS at B3 Theatre
  • BWW Feature: Women of DOGFIGHT at Brelby Theatre Company
  • Ilana Lydia's DROPPIN' JOHNS Opens July 14th at SIC Sense
  • Review: Brelby's Allegiance to THE PLEDGE Yields Magical Results
  • BWW Interview: Jennifer Gantwerker of THE PLEDGE at Brelby Theatre Company
  • Before you go...