Get theatre news and discounts for New Jersey
The Cottage show poster

The Cottage at Barn Theatre

Dates: 9/12/2025 - 9/28/2025

Theatre:

Barn Theatre

Barn Theatre Logo


32 Skyline Drive
Montville,NJ 07045

Phone: 973 334 9320

Tickets: 25.00


  1. View All New Jersey Shows
  2.  > 
  3. The Cottage


FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

The Barn Theatre Kicks Off 98th Season with Sandy Rustin's Hilarious Comedy, "The Cottage"

MONTVILLE, NJ – The Barn Theatre is proud to announce the opening of its 98th season with the witty and charming comedy, The Cottage, by acclaimed playwright Sandy Rustin. The show, hailed as a modern take on a classic Noël Coward comedy, will be directed by Todd Mills and opens on September 12, 2025. It will run for three weekends, promising laughter, surprise, and farcical fun.

Set in a charming English cottage in 1923, The Cottage follows a seemingly simple tryst that quickly descends into delicious chaos. The play's events spiral into delightful absurdity when a series of unexpected arrivals—the husband of the adulterous woman and the wife of the adulterous man—lead to a hilarious web of mistaken identities, concealed secrets, and unexpected twists.

The show's success rests on its cast of six brilliantly flawed and funny characters. Making her debut at the Barn, Lisa Cortney Benke of Westfield, NJ, plays Sylvia Van Kipness, a romantic and impetuous socialite. Her lover, Beau, played by Dan Maceyak of Garwood, NJ, also in his Barn debut, is a handsome but cynical man content with the status quo. The comedy ramps up when Beau's pragmatic and eight-month pregnant wife, Marjorie, played by Emily Bonaria of Mt. Arlington, NJ, arrives with Sylvia's kind-hearted, though perhaps naive, husband, Clarke. The role of Clarke is performed by newcomer Nathan Scott Hancock of West Milford, NJ. The insanity is compounded by the unexpected entrance of Deirdre, played by Danielle Pennisi Christianson of Elmwood Park, an "awfully pretty, sometimes wise, nincompoop" who happens to be Beau's other mistress. Finally, there's Richard, played by Joseph Christianson of Elmwood Park, a "murderous yet gentle soul" with a penchant for finding and keeping his true love... no matter the cost.

Director Todd Mills expressed his excitement about the production. "I am thrilled to kick off our 98th season with The Cottage," says Mills. "This cast has truly embraced the zany energy of this farce, and it's been a joy to watch them bring these characters to life. We are especially excited to welcome three remarkable actors who are making their Barn Theatre debut with this production. Their talent and fresh energy have been a revelation in rehearsals, and I can't wait for our patrons to see the fantastic work they've done."

Performance dates for The Cottage are:

Friday September 12th, 19th, and 26th at 8:00PM
Saturday September 13th at 2:00PM
Saturday September 20th and September 27th at 8:00PM
Sunday September 14th, September 21st, and September 28th at 2:00PM

Barn Theatre, located at 32 Skyline Drive, Montville, NJ.
Tickets are $25 and can be purchased online at www.barntheatre.org or by calling the box office at (973) 334-9320.

About The Barn Theatre
For nearly a century, The Barn Theatre located in Montville, NJ, has provided high-quality, live theatrical productions to the public. As it enters its 98th season, the Barn continues its tradition of excellence and community engagement through the performing arts.
Contact: boxoffice@barntheatre.org

 

Cast and Creative team for The Cottage at Barn Theatre

Cast

Lisa Cortney Benke

Sylvia Van Kipness
Lisa Cortney Benke (Sylvia Van Kipness) Barn debut! Lisa swapped pointe shoes for power suits, conquered Wall Street, then leaped her way back to the stage two decades later. Recent favorite credits: A Chorus Line (Cassie), Sweet Charity (Charity), Nine (Claudia & Carla – '25 Perry nom), Pippin (Fastrada), The Wedding Singer (Linda), Elf (Emily Hobbs), Home, I’m Darling (Judy), Cruel Intentions (Bunny), Tuck Everlasting (Betsy Foster). Love and thanks to AAA&T!


Dan Maceyak

Beau
Dan Maceyak (Beau) Dan is thrilled to be performing at The Barn. He was most recently seen in the Summit Playhouse production of Fun Home (Bruce) and Shrek (Farquaad) with Vanguard Theatre Company. Other NJ theatre highlights have been Nine (Guido) at Chatham and OLT, the CDC's production of A Bronx Tale (Sonny) and Songs for a New World (Man2) at UCPAC. Thanks to Kathy and Todd and this cast for this wonderful experience. Still for Dew.


Emily Bonaria

Marjorie
Emily Bonaria (Marjorie) is delighted to be back on stage at The Barn Theatre! You may have previously seen her in Lobby Hero (Dawn) and Suite Surrender (Murphy). Some of her favorite past credits include Moon Over Buffalo (Roz), The Trip to Bountiful (Thelma), The Last Days of Judas Iscariot (El-Fayoumy), Macbeth (Lady Macduff), and The Bald Soprano (Mary). She holds a BA in Theatre from Muhlenberg College. www.emilybonaria.com


Nathan Scott Hancock

Clarke
Nathan Scott Hancock (Clarke) Nathan recently moved from the city to a lovely cottage nearby & is delighted to do his first show in NJ! A Boston Conservatory grad, he is grateful for his experiences in regional & touring musicals, singing with choirs & the Boston Pops, and performing for Royal Caribbean & Disney. During the day he runs his travel business, @RubatoTravel. Love to the best husband, Brian, and to YOU darlings who are here to support.


Danielle Christianson

Diedre
Danielle Christianson (Dierdre) is so happy to be back onstage at The Barn Theatre after recently performing in Bright Star (Lucy)! Fav credits: Something Rotten (Portia), Urinetown (Hope Cladwell), The Fantasticks (Luisa), Jekyll and Hyde (Emma), It Shoulda Been You (Rebecca), Titanic (Alice Beane), Company (Jenny), Nunsense (Sister Mary Amnesia), Master Class (Sharon Graham), One Slight Hitch (Courtney), and Beauty and the Beast (Wardrobe). ilyjc


Joseph Christianson

Richard
Joseph Christianson (Richard) is excited to be working on his first play at The Barn Theatre! Barn credits: Bright Star (Ensemble), Pippin (Trumpet), Something Rotten (Ensemble), Beehive (Trumpet), Forum (Trumpet), She Loves Me (Trumpet). Acting credits: Jesus Christ Superstar (King Herod), Titanic (Wallace Hartley), Fly By Night (Crabble), Beauty & the Beast (Bookseller/Knife). Music Director credits: Sister Act, Titanic, Kinky Boots. ilydc




Barn Theatre Frequently Asked Questions FAQ

Barn Theatre is at 32 Skyline Drive, Montville, NJ.

Videos


The Wolves in New Jersey The Wolves
Old Library Theatre (12/12 - 12/14) Tracker
Mozart's Requiem in New Jersey Mozart's Requiem
New Jersey Performing Arts Center (4/18 - 4/18)
It's A Wonderful Life: A Live Radio Play in New Jersey It's A Wonderful Life: A Live Radio Play
DMK Black Box Theater - Union Arts Center (12/12 - 12/21)
Ben Folds with the New Jersey Symphony in New Jersey Ben Folds with the New Jersey Symphony
New Jersey Performing Arts Center (6/13 - 6/13)
Holiday Show in New Jersey Holiday Show
United Methodist Church of Morristown (12/14 - 12/14)
Beethoven's Fifth Symphony in New Jersey Beethoven's Fifth Symphony
Mayo Performing Arts Center (2/26 - 2/26)
Ben Folds with the New Jersey Symphony in New Jersey Ben Folds with the New Jersey Symphony
State Theatre New Jersey (6/14 - 6/14)
Comedy Night in New Jersey Comedy Night
Surflight Theatre (1/17 - 1/17)
VIEW SHOWS  ADD A SHOW