New Crime Noir Drama To Each Their Own Premieres in Los Angeles Art Crush LA’s First Theatrical Production Delivers a Powerful Tale of Betrayal, Loyalty, and Redemption LOS ANGELES — To Each Their Own, a gripping modern crime noir by award-winning playwright Travis Williams, will make its world premiere at the Atwater Village Theatre in Los Angeles. The production, running from April 17 to May 4, 2025, marks the first theatrical endeavor by the nonprofit organization Art Crush LA. In a dimly lit northern Ohio tavern, three longtime friends—Doug, Benny, and Bailey—gather for what could be their last shot at escaping their dead-end lives. Their plan? A string of bank heists across the Midwest. But as the night unfolds, old grudges resurface, loyalties are tested, and the weight of past betrayals threatens to derail their future. With sharp, poetic dialogue and a tension-filled atmosphere, To Each Their Own blends gritty crime noir with dark humor, echoing the styles of Sam Shepard and David Mamet. Set against the backdrop of eroding small towns and dwindling economic opportunity, the play delves into the moral cost of desperation, the fragility of trust, and the inescapable pull of past mistakes. As the drinks flow and the plan teeters on the edge of collapse, the trio must face one final question: Is this one last job their way out—or the end of the road? A high-stakes, character-driven thriller, To Each Their Own explores how far we’ll go for redemption—and whether some sins can ever be forgiven. "This particular production has been in the works for the last two years,” said Williams. “It's been a labor of love bringing this production together with this cast and this director. There aren't enough words to express the excitement we all feel working to make this happen. We hope you enjoy the culmination of this long journey." The production is directed by Brooklyn Sample and features a stellar cast, including Jason Madera, James Lemire, Tabitha Trosen, Travis Williams, and William Wilson. Produced by Blind Toe Productions and Erin Coleman, the play promises a raw and thought-provoking theater experience. Performance Schedule Venue: Atwater Village Theatre (3269 Casitas Ave., Los Angeles, CA 90039) April 16 (Preview) – 8 p.m. April 17 (Opening Night) – 8 p.m. April 18, 19 – 8 p.m. April 25, 26 – 8 p.m. April 27 – 6 p.m. May 2, 3 – 8 p.m. May 4 – 6 p.m. Tickets: $30 General Admission; $50 VIP (reserved seating, drink ticket) Ticket link: https://www.artcrush.la/ About the Playwright Travis Williams has built a reputation for his Midwestern gothic narratives, exploring the struggles of working-class America. His works have been staged at Manhattan Theatre Works, A Red Orchid Theatre, and WildClaw Theatre in Chicago. To Each Their Own marks his first full-length world premiere. About Art Crush LA Art Crush LA (www.artcrush.la) is a nonprofit organization committed to fostering creativity, cultural exchange, and community engagement through innovative artistic experiences. From live performances and immersive art installations to car shows celebrating automotive culture, Art Crush LA provides a platform for artists and enriches Los Angeles’ cultural fabric. About Blind Toe Productions Blind Toe Productions (blindtoe.com) specializes in empowering storytellers and creating unforgettable stage and screen experiences. Dedicated to collaboration and creativity, the company pushes boundaries to deliver impactful stories. For media inquiries, interview requests, or review opportunities, please contact: Bertha Rodriguez pressmanagementservices@gmail.com 415-225-5537
Recommended for ages 18 and up. Running Time: 90 minutes.
Cast and Creative team for To Each Their Own at Atwater Village Theatre
Cast
James Lemire
Benny
James is excited and grateful to be part of the premiere production of To Each Their Own. His recent Los Angeles theater credits include Lee in True West at The Group Rep Theater, Dick Stern in A Clean Brush at Theater 40, Moose/Chief in Moose on the Loose at Theatre West, and Valentine in Conversations In Exile at the 2024 Hollywood Fringe Festival. Past credits include Walker in Two Rooms, Tupulski in The Pillowman, and Brad in Orange Flower Water.
Jason Madera
Billy
Jason is overjoyed to make his debut on the Atwater Village Theatre stage. His most recent Los Angeles stage credits include Dr. Ben Kenilworth in Suzy London’s The Ghee Ghee Pik (Group Rep Theatre) & Saul Kimmer in Sam Shepard's True West (Group Rep Theatre). Off-Broadway credits: Lopakin in The Cherry Orchard (Columbia Grad), Carlos in The Cook (INTAR), and Ivan in The Brothers Karamozov (Lincoln Center Director's Lab). Off-Broadway company credits: Second Stage, Ensemble Studio Theatre, & Puerto Rican Traveling Theatre. Other Film/Television credits: “Law and Order’s SVU,” “Over Run,” “Cut,” and “MBC Network.”. Presently, Jason is in production as the host, co-producer, and co-writer of the docu-series based on the origins and future of Cuban music, Lagrimas Negras.
Tabitha Trosen
Bailey
Tabitha is over the moon to be making her Los Angeles theatrical debut in this incredible new work. If you were a theatre goer in Portland, OR, you may have seen her as Marilyn Monroe in Insignificance, Kayleen in Gruesome Playground Injuries, Erica in sUburbia, Guildenstern in Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead, or Paulinka in A Bright Room Called Day. You can also find her in the new web-series, Renting (which she co-produced), at your local YouTube. Tabitha is immensely grateful to this truly inspiring cast and crew for welcoming her with open arms into their beautiful storytelling family. Oh and thanks to Morgan, for putting up with all of her sh*t.
Travis Williams
Irving
Travis is thrilled to be collaborating with so many talented artists for the world premiere of To Each Their Own. Travis developed his playwrighting and acting skills in Chicago before moving to LA. He is a multi-finalist and 2016 winner of Deathscribe: The International Festival of Horror Radio Plays with Wildclaw Theatre in Chicago. Travis’ writings specialize in character-driven horror with a Midwestern Gothic twist. Always and forever love to my beautiful wife, Elizabeth.
William Wilson
Doug
William is much obliged to be invited to tell this story with these artists. Thank you for your words Travis.. “sharp like a dagger. “You just absorb it. Then you take a step into it.” Most recently William was seen as Austin in The Group Rep’s production of True West directed by Brooklyn Sample. Other credits include Edgar in King Lear, Dali in Hysteria, and Hamlet for The Southwest Shakespeare Company, with recognition as Best Actor Broadwayworld Regional.
His performance in To Each Their Own is dedicated to his father, Christopher.
*Actors Equity Member
Creative Team
Brooklyn Sample
Director
Director, producer, actress, and writer for stage and screen. A proud graduate of the American Academy of Dramatic Arts-West. Co-Founder of Blind Toe Productions, a collaborative, creative, consulting team with a focus on storytelling for the stage, screen, and podcasting. Notable directing credits include True West, Keep Me (Director/Writer), Murder at the Howard Johnson’s, Godspell (Co-director), and MAMMA MIA! (Asst. Director). A current, founding board member of Future Artists of Los Angeles and Art Crush LA. She is honored to partner with this brilliant team of creatives on this raw and relevant story.
Erin Coleman
Producer
Erin Coleman is an actor, director, and teaching artist. She moved to Los Angeles after completing her BFA at Sweet Briar College to complete the two-year conservatory program at the American Academy of Dramatic Arts-West. She has also studied at The Groundlings, UCB, and the Second City Conservatory program. She has worked in theater, television, and film with credits at ABC, FOX, Showtime, FX, and AMC. She has traveled with her comedy troupe That's What She Said to the San Francisco Sketch Festival, The Chicago Women's Funny Festival, The Diversity in Comedy Festival, and the Comedy Central Stage. She is an Associate Faculty member and director at the American Academy of Dramatic Arts-West, a Youth Program Instructor at the New York Film Academy, and a teaching artist at the Barnsdall Junior Arts Center. She is a proud board member of Mojo Theatre Ensemble and a founding member and board member of Future Artists of Los Angeles.
Jade Santana
Stage Manager
Luke Moyer
Lighting Designer
Tom Brown
Set Designer
Marc Antonio Pritchett
Fight Choreography
Matt Sample
Marketing & Art Direction
Bertha Rodriguez
Public Relations
SUBMIT UPDATES
Atwater Village Theatre Frequently Asked Questions FAQ
Atwater Village Theatre is at Los Angeles CA, Los Angeles, CA.
"Trauma Play" (5/22/25-6/2/25)
One Jewish Boy (3/20/25-4/28/25)
Bat Boy: The Musical (2/28/25-4/6/25)
Don't Touch My Hair (2/13/25-2/24/25)
NIGHTINGALE (11/8/24-11/17/24)
Clarkston (9/13/24-10/21/24)
The Bauhaus Project (7/19/24-8/25/24)
Arrowhead (2/8/24-3/4/24)
Radical or, are you gonna miss me? (11/11/23-12/11/23)
Certain Death and Other Considerations (9/24/23-10/15/23)
"Trauma Play" (5/22/25-6/2/25)
Videos
 |
MILF And Cookies
Dynasty Typewriter (12/16 - 12/16) | |
 |
2 Pianos 4 Hands
North Coast Repertory Theatre (12/11 - 12/31) | |
 |
Samantha Pauly
Feinstein's at the Nikko (12/12 - 12/13) HOLIDAY SHOW | |
 |
Disney's The Little Mermaid
Redondo Beach Performing Arts Center (1/9 - 1/11) BUY NOW & SAVE | |
|
Peter and the Wolf
Renée and Henry Segerstrom Concert Hall (2/28 - 2/28) | |
|
OTR: Saint Vegas
Chance Theater (5/13 - 5/17) | |
|
The Firebird
Segerstrom Center for the Arts (1/18 - 1/18) | |
|
Nutcracker the Mousical
Old Town Temecula Theater (5/8 - 5/10)
PHOTOS
| |
|
A Winnie-the-Pooh Christmas Tail
The Phantom Projects Theatre at La Habra Depot (12/12 - 12/21) | |
| VIEW SHOWS ADD A SHOW | ||
Get Los Angeles's #1 Theatre Newsletter
All the show news & discounts for Los Angeles & beyond.
