Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: Languid Production of FRANKENSTEIN Will Have No One Clamoring, “It's Alive!”

Review: Languid Production of FRANKENSTEIN Will Have No One Clamoring, “It's Alive!”
Harrison White and Michael Manuel.
Photo by Craig Schwartz

The California Premiere of Nick Dear's adaptation of FRANKENSTEIN features a heartbreaking performance by Michael Manuel as a creature born innocent but ugly, taught to hate and rebel against humanity. Manuel carries the production on his hulking shoulders, which becomes crippling due to a confounding script and unusually lifeless direction from Los Angeles star director Michael Michetti.

The hand-made monster (Manuel), built and rejected by his genius creator, Victor Frankenstein (Kasey Mahaffy), rampages through the countryside of Switzerland after learning that his compassion and intellect will be spurned by everyone just because he is frightening looking. Though a kindly blind man (Harrison White) educates him in language and morality, the creature is cast off until he has no empathy for civilization. He returns to his creator and demands Victor grant him the one thing he lacks, companionship. He wants a bride.

Dear's script is problematic. Choosing the creature as the focal point is logical and gives the audience a chance to spend time with the creature bonding with the blindman, but the script robs the title character, the doctor, of a portrayal. The opening scene gives no indication that Victor created the monster or the mechanics of how, which is often the most exciting scenes in past adaptations, particularly the films. Victor stumbles upon the creature early and runs in terror, but there's no context for the audience to know their connection at this point. Had this been a movie, one would assume the projectionist skipped a reel.

Once the audience spends time with Victor, he is such an unformed character that the audience never really understands him. Michetti directs much of the play in a languid rhythm, as if this were a drawing room drama, not a horror show. The pacing never really picks up.

Thanks to a grant by the David Lee Foundation, Michetti and Movement Director Rhonda Kohl had spent a rigorous week training Manuel to ignore all his instincts about walking and enunciating his words and to learn everything fresh as an infant would. The time spent was well worth it, for the opening scenes with Manuel discovering his legs, his hair, and the animals surrounding him bonds the creature immediately with the audience. Throughout the show, Manuel infuses his role with a tragic desperation to learn and to love. It is clear the play stands behind the creature, judging him as heroic while the rest of humanity fails.

Often, the Doctor has been played two different ways, as a sympathetic gentleman over his head (as Colin Clive and Gene Wilder played the role in the 1931 Universal and Mel Brooks comedy, respectively) or as a psychopath who builds an id creature to do his evil bidding (as Peter Cushing played the role in the Hammer films). Mahaffy chooses an alternative way, as a clueless fop bent on histrionics. He's neither a protagonist nor an antagonist, his character is a nuisance. This unbalances the drama, which never recovers once the two characters play scenes together. White stands out as the naïve but loving teacher and Erika Soto is strong as the frustrated but empathetic Elizabeth, Victor's fiancée. Their scenes with Manuel are the best in the production.

François-Pierre Couture effectively uses an understated scenic design of descending wood panels and movable mirrors to abstractly form forests, shacks, and a laboratory. Jared A. Sayeg utilizes flashing stark white light to simulate the lighting that brings the creature to life. Shannon Hutchins' make-up gives Manuel texture without going grotesque. Garry Lennon's costumes are simple but time appropriate.

A misfire, Michetti's production of FRANKENSTEIN is slow and ponderous when it should be thrilling and hair-raising.

FRANKENSTEIN will be playing at A Noise Within (3352 E. Foothill Blvd. Pasadena, CA 91107) through September 8th. Tickets can be purchased at

From This Author - Jonas Schwartz-Owen

August 10, 2022

South Coast Repertory presents the Broadway musical Million Dollar Quartet at the Mission San Juan Capistrano under the stars as part of its new Outside SCR program, and the quality production recalls the good, old days of Summer Stock. SCR has collected a talented cast and put on an enchanting evening.

Review: MOULIN ROUGE! THE MUSICAL at Pantages TheatreReview: MOULIN ROUGE! THE MUSICAL at Pantages Theatre
July 22, 2022

There have been jukebox musicals for decades, but never has a jukebox been so overstuffed that the 45s came spiraling out of the cabinet, spinning off the stage to decapitate the audience. This Tony-winning musical extravaganza is completely ridiculous and utterly intoxicating. It pounds you into submission, and before you know it, you're having a marvelous time.

April 6, 2022

Lucas Hnath is an ambitious playwright. He turned his mother's harrowing recollections of being abducted in the '90s into a riveting, intimate one-woman tale, Dana H, where the actress lip-syncs to the recording that his mother had made. Despite such legends as Harold Prince, Betty Comden and Adolph Green flopping with a sequel to Ibsen's A Doll's House, he soldiered on with A Doll's House, Part 2, creating a funny and absorbing examination of 19th Century gender wars. Now, he examines the life of Walt Disney in A Public Reading of an Unproduced Screenplay About the Death of Walt Disney. And though Hnath appears to have a focused vision, this time his deliberate touch distances the character from the audience and leaves this reviewer nonplussed.

BWW Review: ANYTHING GOES Starring Sutton Foster Hits the Big ScreenBWW Review: ANYTHING GOES Starring Sutton Foster Hits the Big Screen
March 23, 2022

The buzz on the internet about Sutton Foster playing Marian the Librarian in the latest Music Man revival was polarizing to say the least, but NO ONE can claim that Sutton Foster wasn't born to play Reno Sweeney in the classic Cole Porter musical farce, Anything Goes. Foster won a Tony playing the role on Broadway in 2011, and in 2021, returned to the role at the Barbican Theatre in London, belting out standards like the title number, 'I Get A Kick Out Of You', and the famous list song, 'You're The Top'. Trafalgar Entertainment and Stage2view filmed the cast during the London run and will now air the presentation in American movie theaters for two nights.

BWW Review: THE LEHMAN TRILOGY at Ahmanson TheatreBWW Review: THE LEHMAN TRILOGY at Ahmanson Theatre
March 10, 2022

Three men stand on a stage for over three hours, trekking through 150 years of history in The Lehman Trilogy and it's the most invigorating evening imaginable. Directed by Sam Mendes and written by Stefano Massini—and adapted by National Theatre dramaturg Ben Power -- the play is a remarkable journey of three immigrant brothers from Bavaria, who travel to America to start a small business that evolves into the money-making machine known as Lehman Bros.