A play by Rick Elice | Based on the Novel by Dave Barry and Ridley Pearson | Music by Wayne Barker | Directed by Christopher Donovan Enter a whimsical world where a nameless orphan, a courageous young girl, and a motley crew of pirates set sail on the high seas in search of a mysterious cargo. This imaginative prequel to the beloved tale of Peter Pan brims with swashbuckling action and the magic of childhood dreams. Peter and the Starcatcher is presented through special arrangement with Music Theatre International (MTI). All authorized performance materials are also supplied by MTI. www.mtishows.com
Peter and the Starcatcher at Little Theater Schedule
Cast and Creative team for Peter and the Starcatcher at Little Theater
Cast
Aden Hicks
Boy (Peter)
Jacob Schmitt
Black Stache
Allie George
Molly
Maximilian Schrader
Alf
Megan McMurray
Smee
Kailah Wright
Prentiss
Cadence Corcoran
Ted
Hannah Grace Lobb
Lord Aster
Olivier Lubin
Captain Scott
Ally Johnson
Mrs. Bumbrake
Kennedy Walsh
Slank/Hawking Clam
Noelle Maher
Grempkin/Fighting Prawn
Cristian Velasquez
Sanchez/Max/Teacher
Joey Pittman
Boy (Peter) US
Gracie Youngman
Molly US
Jaxin Hruby
Alf US
Danika Simon
Smee US
Abby Bodell
Ted US
Lainey McCarter
Lord Aster US
Creative Team
Christopher Donovan
Director
Phoenix Gould
Assistant Director
Addie Fernous
Stage Manager
Alex Theodoracopoulos
Assistant Stage Manager
Ellie Buening
Dramaturg
Vincent Gunn
Scenic Design
Sara Roelof
Costume Design
Sam Weiser
Lighting Design
Daniel DeGeorges
Sound Design
Michael Gugliotti
Technical Director
SUBMIT UPDATES
Little Theater Frequently Asked Questions FAQ
Carousel (11/21/25-11/23/25)
Little Theater is at 720 Northern Boulevard, Brookville, NY.
Carousel (11/21/25-11/23/25)
Emilia (10/24/25-10/26/25)
Three Sisters (10/3/25-10/5/25)
Post Concert Dance Company Spring Concert (5/2/25-5/4/25)
Vincent (4/4/25-4/6/25)
R.U.R. (2/21/25-2/23/25)
Into the Woods (11/22/24-11/24/24)
The Oresteia (10/4/24-10/6/24)
Videos
 |
Dance to the Holidays
Patchogue Theatre (12/16 - 12/16) | |
 |
Anastasia -The Musical
Lighthouse Repertory Theatre (11/28 - 12/28) | |
|
Joe Louis & the Groove to Perform at Long Island Music & Entertainment Hall of Fame Dec. 14th
Long Island Music and Entertainment Hall of Fame (12/14 - 12/14) | |
|
Stony Brook Symphony Orchestra
Staller Center for the Arts (3/28 - 3/28) | |
|
Circus Vazquez New York City, November-December 2025
Citi Field (11/25 - 12/14) | |
|
Barnaby Saves Christmas
Theatre Three (11/22 - 12/27) | |
|
Brighton Beach Memoirs
Theatre Three (1/17 - 2/8) | |
|
Christmas with Chris Ruggiero LIVE in East Islip, NY on December 21, 2025
Bayway Arts Center (12/21 - 12/21) | |
|
Godspell
Theatre Three (2/21 - 3/22) | |
| VIEW SHOWS ADD A SHOW | ||
Get Long Island's #1 Theatre Newsletter
All the show news & discounts for Long Island & beyond.
