"Once Upon a Mattress" is a musical retelling of "The Princess and the Pea," following Princess Winnifred as she tries to win the heart of Prince Dauntless while navigating Queen Aggravain's impossible tests and a marriage ban in their kingdom.
Cast and Creative team for Once Upon a Mattress at Star Playhouse at Stage 74
Cast
Jo Ann Brown
Ensemble
Amanda Cataldo
Nightingale
Brenda Festo
Winnifred
Don Frame
Wizard
Leanne Haddock
Ensemble
Sydney Henkel
Ensemble
Dominick Iadanza
Ensemble
Joe Kassner
Jester
Avian Kayam
Queen Aggravin
Ray Krahm
Ensemble
Wes Kreit
Dauntless
Bridgette Lord
Ensemble
Cara McGill
Ensemble
Justin Morris
Ensemble
Christoper Ospina
Ensemble
Karen Santaromita
Lady Larken
Mark Santaromita
King Sextimus
Arianne Shapiro
Princess #12/Ensemble
Marc Strauss
Sir Harry
Joseph Weitekamp
Minstrel
Zachary Wilson
Ensemble
SUBMIT UPDATES
Star Playhouse at Stage 74 Frequently Asked Questions FAQ
Star Playhouse at Stage 74 is at 74 Hauppage Rd, Commack, NY.
A Gentleman's Guide to Love & Murder (11/15/25-11/23/25)
A Few Good Men (3/1/25-3/9/25)
Newsies Jr. (12/13/25-12/14/25)
Mean Girls (1/17/26-1/18/26)
Videos
 |
Dance to the Holidays
Patchogue Theatre (12/16 - 12/16) | |
 |
Anastasia -The Musical
Lighthouse Repertory Theatre (11/28 - 12/28) | |
|
Gala: Mandy Patinkin in Jukebox
Staller Center for the Arts (5/2 - 5/2) | |
|
Rhythm of the Dance
Staller Center for the Arts (3/14 - 3/14) | |
|
Béla Fleck & the Flecktones: Jingle All the Way
Staller Center for the Arts (12/13 - 12/13) | |
|
DRUM TAO – The Best
Staller Center for the Arts (1/31 - 1/31) | |
|
Holiday Spectacular On Ice!
The Gateway (11/28 - 1/4) | |
|
Barnaby Saves Christmas
Theatre Three (11/22 - 12/27) | |
|
Jazz at Lincoln Center | Great American Crooners
Staller Center for the Arts (3/20 - 3/20) | |
| VIEW SHOWS ADD A SHOW | ||
Get Long Island's #1 Theatre Newsletter
All the show news & discounts for Long Island & beyond.
