Skip to main content Skip to footer site map
Review: MYSTIC PIZZA at The John W. Engeman Theatre

Review: MYSTIC PIZZA at The John W. Engeman Theatre

Northport's gorgeous John W. Engeman Theatre certainly has another hit on their hands with their current offering of Mystic Pizza.

Northport's gorgeous John W. Engeman Theatre certainly has another hit on their hands with their current offering of Mystic Pizza. Indeed, this is a new jukebox musical that is an adaptation of the adorable 1988 Julia Roberts movie. In other words, they took the rom-com's story and sprinkled it with some of our favorite hits from the 80's.

Wonderfully directed by Engeman regular Igor Goldin, the female-led tale centers on three friends in their early-mid twentys in the waterfront town of Mystic, Connecticut. We follow them figuring out life's ups and downs as we all can relate to at that age. They all work hard at a pizza restaurant - hence the title - on the brink of closure and navigateing relationships. Each of them has their own story, but they all come together to support and encourage one another. Additionally, it is great to see how well show creator Sandy Rustin pretty much kept in line with the movie incarnation.

Emily Rose Lyons is excellent as Daisy, Ms. Roberts' role from the movie. Daisy's younger sister is Kat adorably portrayed here by Brooke Sterling. Indeed, the sisters are very much opposites. Kat, in addition to working at the pizza shop, is going Yale for astronomy and works at the planetarium. Kat also picks up a job babysitting all to raise money for school. Kat is a very hard working and disipline person. Daisy's goal is to have as much fun as possible. Their friend, Jojo portrayed by Michelle Beth Herman, contemplates if she wants to marry Bill, portrayed by Stephen Cerf. Another audience favorite is Kathryn Markey superbly portraying Leona, the owner of Mystic Pizza. I really could go on and on (and on!) about the cast as they are all top-notch. It is a delightful, charming show and everyone in the brilliant cast seems to be enjoying their time in this production.

On the clever creative team, Kyle Dixon's set is well done. It's a reletively stationary set and several rolling pieces are utilized making for seamless scene transitions. This is heightened by Jose Santiago's superb lighting design and, of course, there's nothing like a live orchestra. Headed up by sensational Music Director Sarah Wussow, the excellent orchestra sounds incredible. As for the score, you will hear some of the 80's biggest hits. This is including "Take My Breath Away", "Small Town", "Girls Just Wanna Have Fun", "Hit Me With Your Best Shot", and "Hold On" among many others and the emotional roller coaster of a story is really gripping. An interesting choice was including Melissa Ethridge's "I'm The Only One" which - if I remember correctly - was released in the early 90's. But, as they say... a reason for everything.

And so, this is a delicious show to see as we sadly wind down the Summer. You really can't go wrong at this equisite venue. A brilliant, broadway-caliber cast, a relatable yet emotional story, and fun music make for a great night of theatre.



Review: GRUMPY OLD MEN: THE MUSICAL at Elmont Library Theatre Photo
What did our critic think of GRUMPY OLD MEN: THE MUSICAL at Elmont Library Theatre?

FIRESIDE SESSIONS WITH NANCY ATLAS to Return toBay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center  Photo
The popular concert series, Fireside Sessions with Nancy Atlas, is returning to Bay Street Theater in January, with four live concerts at the theater starting Saturday, January 7, at 8 p.m. Performances continue every Saturday through January at 8 p.m.

Review: THE WIZARD OF OZ at CM Performing Arts Center Photo
What did our critic think of THE WIZARD OF OZ at CM Performing Arts Center? As soon as CM Performing Arts Center's live orchestra struck up the first few chords of 'The Wizard of Oz's' iconic overture, a wave of nostalgia hummed throughout the Noel S Ruiz Theatre. Multiple generations filled the house at the opening weekend matinee. Children, parents, grandparents, and children at heart visibly delighted in the stellar stagecraft, vibrant costumery, and charming performances featured in CM's Season 49 finale.

Review: A CHRISTMAS STORY at The John W. Engeman Theater Photo
What did our critic think of A CHRISTMAS STORY at The John W. Engeman Theater?


From This Author - Melissa Giordano

Melissa has been covering theatre for BroadwayWorld for the past eight years and has loved every second of it. She is consistently inspired by the talent of the artists of her beloved Long Island a... (read more about this author)


Review: A CHRISTMAS STORY at The John W. Engeman TheaterReview: A CHRISTMAS STORY at The John W. Engeman Theater
November 24, 2022

What did our critic think of A CHRISTMAS STORY at The John W. Engeman Theater?

Review: CHARLES DICKENS' A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Theatre ThreeReview: CHARLES DICKENS' A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Theatre Three
November 17, 2022

What did our critic think of CHARLES DICKENS' A CHRISTMAS CAROL at Theatre Three?

Review: ALL THINGS EQUAL: THE LIFE AND TRIALS OF RUTH BADER GINSBURG at Bay Street TheaterReview: ALL THINGS EQUAL: THE LIFE AND TRIALS OF RUTH BADER GINSBURG at Bay Street Theater
November 10, 2022

What did our critic think of ALL THINGS EQUAL: THE LIFE AND TRIALS OF RUTH BADER GINSBURG at Bay Street Theater?

Review: OVER THE RIVER AND THROUGH THE WOODS at Hampton Theatre CompanyReview: OVER THE RIVER AND THROUGH THE WOODS at Hampton Theatre Company
November 3, 2022

What did our critic think of OVER THE RIVER AND THROUGH THE WOODS at Hampton Theatre Company?

Review: MATILDA at the Noel S. Ruiz Theatre at CM Performing Arts CenterReview: MATILDA at the Noel S. Ruiz Theatre at CM Performing Arts Center
October 20, 2022

What did our critic think of MATILDA at The Noel S. Ruiz Theatre At CM Performing Arts Center?