Skip to main content
Vote for the BWW Delaware Awards
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
Coney Island Christmas show poster

Coney Island Christmas at Second Street Players

Dates: 11/28/2025 - 12/7/2025

📍 Theatre: Second Street Players


2 South Walnut St
Milford, DE 19963

Phone: 302-422-0220

Tickets: $27 general admission; $25 students, seniors, members


Share

Pulitzer Prize-winner Donald Margulies weaves together nostalgia, music, and merriment in this new seasonal classic story. A holiday show afor people of all ages and all faiths, CONEY ISLAND CHRISTMAS introduces us to Shirley Abramowitz, a young Jewish girl who, much to her parents’ displeasure, is cast as Jesus in the school’s Christmas pageant. As Shirley, now much older, recounts the memorable events to her great-granddaughter, the story comes to life and captures a timeless and universal tale of holiday traditions.

Coney Island Christmas at Second Street Players Schedule

Friday, November 28, 2025: 7 PM;
Saturday, November 29, 2025: 7 PM;
Sunday, November 30, 2025: 2 PM;
Friday, December 5, 2025: 7 PM;
Saturday, December 6, 2025: 7 PM;
Sunday, December 7, 2025: 2 PM.
$27 general admission; $25 students, seniors, members

News About Coney Island Christmas at Second Street Players

About the Theatre

Second Street Players Facebook

2 South Walnut St
Milford, DE 19963

Phone: 302-422-0220

🌙 Make a Night of It

Loading nearby places…

Similar Shows Nearby

Scrooge!

The Candlelight Theatre
11/14/2026 – 12/22/2026

Second Street Players Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ

What shows are coming up next at Second Street Players?

FrUiTCaKeS (11/27/26-12/06/26)
Cheaper by the Dozen (03/20/29-03/29/26)

What shows have played recently at Second Street Players?

Beetlejuice JR. (10/09/26-10/18/26)
Ken Ludwig's Baskerville: A Sherlock Holmes Mystery (08/21/26-08/30/26)
Gypsy (07/10/26-07/19/26)
Girls' Weekend (05/08/26-05/17/26)
Little Shop of Horrors (10/10/25-10/19/25)
See more shows at Second Street Players

Where is Second Street Players located?

Second Street Players is at 2 South Walnut St, Milford, DE.

The Lightning Thief The Percy Jackson Musical  in Delaware The Lightning Thief The Percy Jackson Musical
Griffin Theatre (12/11-12/20)
She Loves Me in Delaware She Loves Me
Possum Point Players (11/13-11/22)
The Dinner Detective Wilmington True Crime Mystery Show in Delaware The Dinner Detective Wilmington True Crime Mystery Show
The Dinner Detective Wilmington (12/19-12/19)
The Dinner Detective Wilmington True Crime Mystery Show in Delaware The Dinner Detective Wilmington True Crime Mystery Show
The Dinner Detective Wilmington (12/12-12/12)
ELF: The Musical in Delaware ELF: The Musical
The Milton Theatre (11/19-12/13)
Irving Berlin's White Christmas in Delaware Irving Berlin's White Christmas
Smyrna Opera House (12/04-12/13)
FrUiTCaKeS in Delaware FrUiTCaKeS
Second Street Players (11/27-12/06)
Descendants The Musical  in Delaware Descendants The Musical
Griffin Theatre (11/13-11/22)
Winter Lights & Voices: A Holiday Celebration in Delaware in Delaware Winter Lights & Voices: A Holiday Celebration in Delaware
Grand Opera House (8/03-8/01)
The Dinner Detective Wilmington in Delaware The Dinner Detective Wilmington
The Dinner Detective Wilmington (12/05-12/05)