Skip to main content Skip to footer site map
Review: SOMEWHERE at Geva Theatre

Review: SOMEWHERE at Geva Theatre

The production runs through November 13th.

I've been covering the theatre scene in Rochester and Western NY for BroadwayWorld and various other publications since 2017. Without actually sitting down to tally them up, I'd estimate I've probably reviewed around 250-300 productions in that time, of all sizes and calibers. I can only think of three other times I've left the theatre as moved as I was after seeing Matthew Lopez's "Somewhere", currently playing at Geva Theatre until November 13th. What a stunning achievement this play is.

(If you were curious, the three other productions I referenced above were the 2018 touring production of "Fiddler on the Roof", JCC Centerstage Theatre's "Indecent", and Blackfriars Theatre's "Silent Sky").

Matthew Lopez is, of course, much more well known for "The Inheritance", which premiered in 2018 and went on to garner international praise, shower him in Tony awards, and catapult him into theatre superstardom. "Somewhere" is one of his lesser-known works, but I'd argue it's just as good, if not better, than the play that put him on the map.

"Somewhere" tells the story of the struggling Candelarias, a Puerto Rican family who live in NYC's San Juan Hill neighborhood during the late 1950's/early 1960s, a golden era of Broadway when lines for West Side Story were around the block, Chita Rivera was a household name, and members of the Candelaria family harbored dreams of the stage; Francisco (Ean Castellanos), a jokester who fancies himself the Puerto Rican Marlon Brando, Rebecca (Maria Cristina Posada Slye), a dancer extraordinaire, Alejandro (Eddie Guiterrez), who starred in "The King and I" as a child but has since left his Broadway dreams behind to help support the family, Jamie (Zach McNally), the sort-of adopted son who has achieved stardom but still remembers his roots, and Inez (Zuleyma Guevara), the pushy matriarch who dreams of seeing her children's names on a marquee. The problem, as was the case for many immigrant families in NYC during this time, is that dreams are out-of-reach luxuries when you're struggling to feed your family and keep a roof over your head, a struggle that comes to a climax when the Candelaria's learn that their entire neighborhood is going to be leveled in 30 days' time to make way for the construction of a new sprawling performance arts complex (Lincoln Center, whose controversial legacy "Somewhere" tackles quite effectively).

"Somewhere" grapples with a bevy of sociological themes; poverty, class, gentrification, and the plight of immigrants to name just a few. Lopez handles these weighty topics deftly, but so do a lot of other playwrights, a welcome sign that the artists and creators of today are paying attention to society's challenges and tackling them head-on. What sets Lopez apart with "Somewhere" is the way in which he interweaves artistry, hope, joy, and dreams in with these other societal conversations.

Because "Somewhere" isn't just a play about poverty, it's also a love letter to Jerome Robbins, Leonard Bernstein, Stephen Sondheim, and Broadway. It's a very musical non-musical (an odd quasi-genre that I happen to love), packed to the brim with showtunes and ballads and Karla Puno Garcia's stunning choreography. It crackles with the excitement of Puerto Rican music and culture. And most importantly, it puts a microscope up to the notion that we MUST dream, that dreams are *essential*, and that life is not worth living if one intends only to keep their nose to the grindstone.

There is no point highlighting standout acting performances in Geva's "Somewhere" because they are top-to-bottom superb. Nary five minutes go by without Castellano's Francisco putting the audience in stitches; Guiterrez's Alejandro delivers profound frustration and rage at his family that refuses to acknowledge reality (and my favorite line of the play, "Sometimes I think I'm the only one in this family with enough sense to be scared to death"); Guevara's Inez is at times a quintessential stage mom and at other times a woman palpably downtrodden by the cruelties of life; and, most importantly, the whole cast are outstanding dancers, injecting the perfect amount of "West Side Story" into the story.

"Somewhere" is a funny, heartbreaking, riveting piece of theatre, and you should move mountains to make sure you get to Geva Theatre to see it before it leaves on November 13th.



Interview: MEGAN HILTY AT Universal Preservation Hall Photo
Megan Hilty, theater extraordinaire, is coming to Upstate New York for an intimate holiday spectacular! She will be in Saratoga Springs at the Universal Preservation Hall on Saturday, December 3rd.

Salem Central School to Present LEGALLY BLONDE THE MUSICAL This Month Photo
OMIGOD, YOU GUYS! Salem Central School Drama Club is set to perform Legally Blonde the Musical, based on the iconic 2001 film of the same name. From Friday, December 9th through Sunday, December 11th, Harvard's beloved blonde takes the Salem Central School stage by pink storm in this fun, upbeat story of self-discovery.

Stallers Zuccaire Gallery Presents Exhibition of Black Artists and Abstraction in the 60s  Photo
The Staller Center's Paul W. Zuccaire Gallery opened a new exhibition entitled Revisiting 5+1, developed in conjunction with the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston's current feature exhibition, Frank Bowling's Americas.

Photos: Inside Woodstock Playhouses Production Of David Henry Hwangs M. BUTTERFLY Photo
See photos of the historic Woodstock Playhouse’s sumptuous production of David Henry Hwang's M. Butterfly, which dazzled from November 18-20 under direction of Randy Conti with choreography by Nina Zoie Lam, costumes by Diane Stein and lighting by Tony Michael Clayton.


From This Author - Colin Fleming-Stumpf

Colin Fleming-Stumpf is a lover of all things theatre and performing arts. A native of Rochester, Colin has acted on stages across Western New York and is active in the local theatre community as a... (read more about this author)


Review: SOMEWHERE at Geva TheatreReview: SOMEWHERE at Geva Theatre
October 30, 2022

What did our critic think of SOMEWHERE at Geva Theatre?

Review: JANE EYRE at Geva TheatreReview: JANE EYRE at Geva Theatre
September 24, 2022

What did our critic think of JANE EYRE at Geva Theatre?

Review: TOOTSIE at Rochester Broadway Theatre LeagueReview: TOOTSIE at Rochester Broadway Theatre League
September 23, 2022

What did our critic think of TOOTSIE at Rochester Broadway Theatre League? The Rochester Broadway Theatre League begins its 2022-2023 M&T Bank Broadway season with something fun and splashy, a perfect date night musical based on one of the 1980s' most beloved pop culture gems. 'Tootsie', the Robert Horn and David Yazbek musical adaption of the 1982 Dustin Hoffman film of the same name, is a light and springy show about showbiz, which also attempts to grapple with the difficulties of being a woman in a man's world. Rochester is the first stop on Tootsie's national tour.

Review: MONTY PYTHON'S SPAMALOT at Blackfriars TheatreReview: MONTY PYTHON'S SPAMALOT at Blackfriars Theatre
September 14, 2022


Review: SEUSSICAL: THE MUSICAL at Blackfriars TheatreReview: SEUSSICAL: THE MUSICAL at Blackfriars Theatre
July 26, 2022

What did our critic think of SEUSSICAL: THE MUSICAL at Blackfriars Theatre? Blackfriars' production of 'Seussical' showcases the talents of numerous young performers, from Yates' kind and sensitive Horton to Jade Hill's soulful Sour Kangaroo to the sassy stylings of the Wikersham Brothers (Danny Dobbins, J. Jake Thomas, Avery White).