What If? Part 6 returns to 54 Below, offering a unique experience where beloved musical theater characters swap songs for one night only. Featuring performances from Grace Hodgett Young, Jordan Barrow, and a host of emerging talent from the Berklee College of Music and Boston Conservatory, audiences will enjoy unexpected pairings like Jenna Hunterson tackling “Slim Pickins” and Elphaba and Glinda singing “I Will Never Leave You.” This engaging evening invites fans to ponder the delightful possibilities of musical mashups.
Cast and Creative team for What If? Part 6 at 54 Below
Cast
Maeve Zamuner
Zoe Murphy
Alyssa Wray
Rizzo
Ayden Weinstein
Gabe Goodman
Nadia Jewel Vito
Audrey
Mikayla Renfrow
Cinderella
Juliette Ojeda
Young Allie
Kaileigh Fiorillo
Regina George
Abby McDonough
Queenie
Isabel Leoni
Heather Chandler
Bryson Battle
Ensemble
Jordan Barrow
Boq
Angelina Amato
Young Allie
Faith Alhadeff
Sally Bowles
Ellie Fishman
The Baker’s Wife
Isabela Garcia
Heather McNamara
Catie Gorton
Natalie Goodman
Callie Henrysen
Karen Smith
Grace Hodgett Young
Eurydice
Cooper LaMontagne
Young Noah
Lizzy Legregin
Gretchen Wieners
Creative Team
Jorden Amir
Music Director
Jorden Amir
Producer
Jorden Amir
Creator
SUBMIT UPDATES
54 Below Frequently Asked Questions FAQ
Alex Wakim: Sounds of Claire (12/1/25-12/1/25)
Christine Ebersole and Billy Stritch Concert (12/1/25-12/2/25)
Strange and Unusual Broadway Debuts (11/28/25-11/28/25)
Beetlejuice (11/28/25-11/28/25)
A Tall Drink of Me (11/24/25-11/24/25)
Verses and Voices featuring Jenn Grinels (11/18/25-11/18/25)
54 BELOW INTRODUCES: INTERNATIONAL MUSICALS (11/13/25-11/13/25)
Broadway, Britney, and Breakdowns (11/11/25-11/11/25)
About Time (11/7/25-11/8/25)
A Journey Through A Decade (11/4/25-11/4/25)
The Joe Iconis Christmas Extravaganza (12/12/25-12/14/25)
Charles Busch's New Year's Eve Celebration (12/31/25-12/31/25)
Joy Woods (12/31/25-12/31/25)
Liz Callaway and Ann Hampton Callaway at 54 BELOW (1/1/26-1/1/26)
Videos
Paddington Bway Transfer Possible?
Why don’t Off Bway shows report their weekly grosses?
THE QUEEN OF VERSAILLES To Close December 21, 2025
COYOTE UGLY musical adaptation with music by Diane Warren to premiere in West End in 2027
 |
FRANK SINGS FRANK
Dont Tell Mama (12/13 - 12/13) | |
 |
The Bryce Edwards Frivolity Hour
Birdland (12/15 - 12/15) | |
 |
The Tender Trapp: Christy Trapp sings Frank Sinatra
Don't Tell Mama (12/11 - 12/11)
PHOTOS
| |
|
Lina Koutrakos Singers: Merry & Blue
Don't Tell Mama (12/20 - 12/20) | |
|
Chris Autore: Look At Me Now
Don't Tell Mama (12/21 - 12/21)
VIDEOS
| |
|
STAGE TIME
Stage Time LLC (3/29 - 12/27)
PHOTOS
| |
|
The Doris Dear Christmas Special Christmas in New York
The Triad Theater (12/19 - 12/20) | |
|
Everything
Don't Tell Mama (2/20 - 2/20) | ||
|
Ava Nicole Frances: Glitter and be Gay!
The Laurie Beechman Theater (12/13 - 12/13) | |
| VIEW SHOWS ADD A SHOW | ||
Get Cabaret's #1 Theatre Newsletter
All the show news & discounts for Cabaret & beyond.
