NOW THAT’S WHAT I CALL BROADWAY! HALLOWEEN EDITION showcases favorite hits from Tony Award-winning shows over the past 30 years, performed by Broadway veterans and rising stars. The special Halloween-themed edition, produced and hosted by Zach Kelley and Katherine Schaber, invites guests to enjoy memorable numbers from productions like Hairspray, Wicked, RENT, and Legally Blonde. This lively celebration promises an engaging night filled with music, dining, and the chance to connect with fellow theater enthusiasts.
Cast and Creative team for NOW THAT’S WHAT I CALL BROADWAY! HALLOWEEN EDITION at 54 Below
Cast
Jaime Lyn Beatty
Ensemble
Kate Coffey
Ensemble
Red Concepción
Ensemble
Pasquale Crociata
Ensemble
Nesziah Dennis
Ensemble
Cara Rose DiPietro
Ensemble
Jasmine Forsberg
Ensemble
Erin Kommor
Ensemble
Chani Maisonet
Ensemble
Heather Makalani
Ensemble
Diane Phelan
Ensemble
Jana Prentiss
Ensemble
Andrea Prestinario
Ensemble
Julio Rey
Ensemble
Lexi Bodick
Ensemble
Alex Petti
Ensemble
Emmanuel Solano
Ensemble
Rachel Arianna
Ensemble
Collin Borisenko
Ensemble
Cosmo Coniglio
Ensemble
Casey Huls
Ensemble
Nicholas Ian
Ensemble
Maxwell Peters
Ensemble
Trey Plutnicki
Ensemble
Lena Simone
Ensemble
Viv Vaeth
Ensemble
Ginny Weant
Ensemble
Kyra Young
Ensemble
Abigail Aldridge
Ensemble
Bernie Baldassaro
Ensemble
Sarah Coleman
Ensemble
Katie Gray
Ensemble
Collin Hancock
Ensemble
Jataria Heyward
Ensemble
Lauren Johnson
Ensemble
Jesse Rae Jordan
Ensemble
Katryna Marttala
Ensemble
Jade McLeod
Ensemble
Sean McManus
Ensemble
Alec Nevins
Ensemble
Jenna San Antonio
Ensemble
Ivan Cecil Walks
Ensemble
Hannah Beatt
Ensemble
Amy Jo Jackson
Ensemble
Taylor Iman Jones
Ensemble
Mikayla Petrilla
Ensemble
Eleri Ward
Ensemble
Maria Wirries
Ensemble
Ehime Ora
Ensemble
Creative Team
Rissa Lavilla
Producer
Matthew B. Cullen
Director
Kaitlin Rowan
Writer
Kaitlin Rowan
Co-Producer
Kaitlin Rowan
Co-Director
Mateo Gutierrez
Production Assistant
Bruce De La Cruz
Music Director
Tiffany Keane Schaefer
Director
Brian Rasmussen
Score and Music Director
Dominick Raffaele
Producer
Mills Theatrical, LLC
Producer
Alison Holman
Director
Christopher Iain Blair
Director
John Adam
Co-Producer
Victoria Bost
Co-Producer
Sydney Stephan
Producer
Canaan J. Harris
Music Director
SUBMIT UPDATES
54 Below Frequently Asked Questions FAQ
ALL UKE NEED IS LOVE (2/8/26-2/8/26)
Mexodus (1/13/26-1/13/26)
Marilyn Maye at 54 Below (1/8/26-1/8/26)
Liz Callaway and Ann Hampton Callaway at 54 BELOW (1/1/26-1/1/26)
Joy Woods (12/31/25-12/31/25)
Charles Busch's New Year's Eve Celebration (12/31/25-12/31/25)
Charles Busch New Year's Eve Cabaret (12/31/25-12/31/25)
Robert Bannon: Twas the Night After Christmas (12/26/25-12/26/25)
The Joe Iconis Christmas Extravaganza (12/12/25-12/14/25)
Alex Wakim: Sounds of Claire (12/1/25-12/1/25)
Christine Ebersole and Billy Stritch Concert (12/1/25-12/2/25)
Videos
 |
FRANK SINGS FRANK
Dont Tell Mama (2/15 - 2/15) | |
 |
Trapped
The Green Room 42 (1/18 - 1/19) | |
|
Jeremy Sussman: From No Business to Show Business
Don't Tell Mama (2/26 - 2/26)
PHOTOS
| |
|
Richard Skipper Celebrates!
Laurie Beechman Theatre (2/27 - 2/27) | |
|
Double Trouble Debi Toni The Bubbling Blonde From Babylon
Don't Tell Mama (1/18 - 1/18)
PHOTOS
VIDEOS
| |
|
Daddy Daycare
The Motley Bauhaus - Theatrette (4/6 - 4/19) | |
|
Elvira Tortora: The Bookmaker's Daughter
Chelsea Table + Stage (4/11 - 4/11)
PHOTOS
| |
|
Everything
Don't Tell Mama (2/20 - 2/20) | ||
|
Janice McCune: Let’s Start Tomorrow Tonight!
Don't Tell Mama (1/25 - 1/25)
PHOTOS
| |
| VIEW SHOWS ADD A SHOW | ||
Get Cabaret's #1 Theatre Newsletter
All the show news & discounts for Cabaret & beyond.
