| Outstanding Featured Actress in a Play | Frances de la Tour | The History Boys |
| Outstanding New Play | Alan Bennett | The History Boys |
| Outstanding Revival of a Musical | Sweeney Todd | Sweeney Todd |
| Outstanding Actor in a Musical | Martin Short | Fame Becomes Me |
| Outstanding Actor in a Musical | John Lloyd Young | Jersey Boys |
| Outstanding Actor in a Musical | John Gallagher, Jr, Jonathan Groff | Spring Awakening |
| Outstanding Actor in a Play | Richard Griffiths | The History Boys |
| Outstanding Actress in a Musical | Christine Ebersole | Grey Gardens |
|
| Outstanding Actress in a Musical (tie) | Ashley Brown | Mary Poppins |
| Outstanding Actress in a Musical (tie) | Lea Michele | Spring Awakening |
|
| Outstanding Actress in a Musical (tie) | Kristin Chenoweth | The Apple Tree |
| Outstanding Actress in a Play | Meryl Streep | Mother Courage and Her Children |
| Outstanding Actress in a Play | Sandra Oh | Satellites |
| Outstanding Actress in a Play | Blythe Danner | Suddenly Last Summer |
| Outstanding Actress in a Play | Orlagh Cassidy | The Field |
| Outstanding Actress in a Play | Annie Parisse | The Internationalist |
|
|
| Outstanding Actress in a Play | Lois Smith | The Trip to Bountiful |
| Outstanding Book of a Musica | Julian Fellowes | Mary Poppins |
| Outstanding Book of a Musica | Steven Sater | Spring Awakening |
| Outstanding Book of a Musical | Bob Martin, Don McKellar | The Drowsy Chaperone |
|
| Outstanding Choreograph | Matthew Bourne, Stephen Mear | Mary Poppins |
| Outstanding Choreograph | Bill T. Jones | Spring Awakening |
| Outstanding Choreography | Kathleen Marshall | The Pajama Game |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Santo Loquasto | Suddenly Last Summer |
|
| Outstanding Costume Design | Catherine Zuber | The Coast of Utopia |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Gregg Barnes | The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Outstanding Director of a Musical | John Doyle | Sweeney Todd |
| Outstanding Director of a Play | John Doyle | Company |
| Outstanding Director of a Play | Michael Mayer | Spring Awakening |
| Outstanding Director of a Play | Ciarán O'Reilly | The Hairy Ape |
|
| Outstanding Director of a Play | Nicholas Hytner | The History Boys |
| Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical | Aaron Lazar | Les Miserables |
|
|
| Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical | Brooks Ashmanskas | Martin Short: Fame Becomes Me |
| Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical | Gavin Lee | Mary Poppins |
| Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play | Samuel Barnett | The History Boys |
| Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play | Jim Dale | The Threepenny Opera |
| Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical | Celia Keenan-Bolger | Les Miserables |
| Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical | Beth Leavel | The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Outstanding Featured Actress in a Play | Rita Wol | The American Pilot |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Richard G. Jones | Sweeney Todd |
|
|
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Natasha Katz, Kenneth Posner, Brian MacDevitt | The Coast of Utopia |
| Outstanding Lyrics | Bill Strauss, Elaina Newport, Mark Eaton | Capitol Steps |
| Outstanding Lyrics | Scott Wittman | Martin Short: Fame Becomes Me |
| Outstanding Lyrics | Steven Sater | Spring Awakenin |
| Outstanding Lyrics | Lisa Lambert, Greg Morrison | The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Outstanding Music | Duncan Sheik | Spring Awakening |
| Outstanding Music | Lisa Lambert, Greg Morrison | The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Outstanding Music | Paul Leschen | Twist: Please, Sir, May I Have Some More? |
|
|
| Outstanding Musical | Mary Poppins | Mary Poppins |
| Outstanding Musical | Spring Awakening | Spring Awakening |
|
| Outstanding New Musical | The Drowsy Chaperone | The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Outstanding Orchestrations | Sarah Travis | (Sweeney Todd) |
| Outstanding Orchestrations (tie) | Mary Mitchell Campbell | Company |
| Outstanding Orchestrations (tie) | Duncan Sheik | Spring Awakening |
| Outstanding Orchestrations (tie) | Jonathan Tunick | The Apple Tree |
| Outstanding Revival of a Musical | Company | Company |
|
| Outstanding Revival of a Musical | Di Yam Gazlonim | Di Yam Gazlonim |
| Outstanding Revival of a Musical | Les Miserables | Les Miserables |
| Outstanding Revival of a Musical | The Apple Tree | The Apple Tree |
| Outstanding Revival of a Play | Clifford Odets | Awake and Sing |
|
| Outstanding Revival of a Play | The Hairy Ape | The Hairy Ape |
| Outstanding Set Design of a Musical | Bob Crowley | Mary Poppins |
| Outstanding Set Design of a Musical | David Gallo | The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Outstanding Set Design of a Play | Michael Yeargan | Awake and Sing |
|
|
| Outstanding Solo Performance | Nilaja Sun | No Child… |
| Outstanding Solo Performance | Anna Manahan | Sisters |
| Outstanding Solo Performance | Ed Harris | Wrecks |
| Outstanding Sound Design | Steve Canyon Kennedy | Jersey Boys |
| Outstanding Sound Design | Mark Bennett | The Coast of Utopia |
| Unique Theatrical Experience | Absinthe Amajuba: Like Doves We Rise | Absinthe Amajuba: Like Doves We Rise |
|
| Unique Theatrical Experience | Be | Be |
| Unique Theatrical Experience | Brundibar/But the Giraffe | Brundibar/But the Giraffe |
|
| Unique Theatrical Experience | Christine Jorgensen Reveals | Christine Jorgensen Reveals |
