In 2015, Olney Theatre produced the Rolling World Premiere of I And You by Lauren Gunderson, which went on to become one of the most-produced plays in America. Now, we’re bringing you the World Premiere of the musical adaptation of her hit play. Anthony turns up in Caroline’s bedroom one night bearing waffle fries, a beat-up book, and a homework assignment they’re supposed to do together: explore Walt Whitman’s poem “Song of Myself.” Chronically sick, Caroline hasn’t been to school in a while… and can’t even remember meeting some kid named Anthony, which dials up both her suspicions and her “snark-o-meter.” But as the two get to know each other, they finally learn of the deeper mystery that brought them together. Whitman’s powerful poetry inspires the music and lyrics by American Idol veteran Ari Afsar, which expands the magic of Gunderson’s remarkable story.
Ages: If this were a film, it would be rated PG-13 for strong language and mature themes.
Little Miss Perfect (2/12/26-3/8/26)
Appropriate (3/18/26-4/19/26)
Carla Hall - Please Underestimate Me (6/3/26-7/12/26)
A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder (7/2/26-8/23/26)
Olney Theatre Center is at 2001 Olney-Sandy Spring Road, Olney, MD.
A Christmas Carol: A Ghost Story of Christmas (11/28/25-12/28/25)
Hello, Dolly! (11/6/25-1/4/26)
A Christmas Carol: A Ghost Story of Christmas (11/24/23-12/31/23)
Fiddler on the Roof (11/8/23-12/31/23)
The Brothers Paranormal (9/27/23-10/29/23)
The Most Wonderful Time of the Year (12/16/22-12/31/22)
Dance Nation (9/28/22-10/30/22)
The Music Man (6/17/22-7/24/22)
The Joy That Carries You (5/11/22-6/12/22)
Imagination Stage's Mother Goose at Olney Theatre Center (4/23/22-4/24/22)
Videos
Why are audiences so poorly behaved these days?
Thomas Kail to direct Michelle Williams, Tom Sturridge, and Bryan D'Arcy James in ANNA CHRISTIE
![]() |
Chanukah in the Dark
Theater J (12/6 - 12/21) | |
![]() |
ho ho ho ha ha ha ha
Woolly Mammoth Theatre Company (11/13 - 12/21) | |
![]() |
Guys and Dolls
Shakespeare Theatre Company (12/2 - 1/4) | |
![]() |
Step Afrika!'s Magical Musical Holiday Step Show
Arena Stage at the Mead Center for American Theater (12/5 - 12/23) | |
![]() |
The Snowman and The Snowdog
Imagination Stage (11/22 - 1/4)
VIDEOS
| |
![]() |
Catch Me If You Can
Shenandoah Conservatory (2/26 - 3/1) | |
|
Hello, Dolly!
Olney Theatre Center (11/6 - 1/4) | |
|
Birthday Candles
1st Stage (12/4 - 12/21) | |
|
The Motion
Arena Stage at the Mead Center for American Theater (5/6 - 6/14) | |
|
It's My Party!
video-on-demand (1/22 - 2/5) | |
|
How Shakespeare Saved My Life
Folger Shakespeare Library (6/9 - 7/5) | |
| VIEW SHOWS ADD A SHOW | ||