Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: Intensity and Absurdity of THE GOAT, OR WHO IS SYLVIA? Tackled at Baxter Theatre Centre

Review: Intensity and Absurdity of THE GOAT, OR WHO IS SYLVIA? Tackled at Baxter Theatre Centre

A play intended to shock the conservative and probe at society's typical imaginings of marital breakdown, the Baxter's latest offering of the award-winning THE GOAT, OR WHO IS SYLVIA? has an equally acclaimed director and cast behind it; making it stand in good stead as a must-see for those brave enough to approach what they cannot "unsee".

From the same playwright of WHO'S AFRAID OF Virginia Woolf?, Edward Albee's later work of THE GOAT, OR WHO IS SYLVIA? famously implores audiences to explore their own morality as they are faced with what has been described as a "superficially ludicrous bestiality story" painted with profanity and provocation. Albee noted the inspiration of structure and language from that of classical Greek tragedy, while the play falls so easily into unimaginable tragedy that it can only emerge at times into farcical comedy.

Winner of the best new director at the Fleur du Cap Awards in 2016, Mdu Kweyama proves he has not lost his directorial flair by tackling Albee's play. He uses the Golden Arrow Studio's space very well and creates an unexpected connect and disconnect with the audience throughout THE GOAT, OR WHO IS SYLVIA?. His choice of cast is also to be commended for this.

Lionel Newton plays middle-aged architect, Martin, who has taken a turn for the worst at age 50 and started a questionable love affair with some livestock. Opposite his effortlessly enjoyable stay-at-home wife, he appears slightly awkward, tense, even pathetic, at the beginning; perfect for his character arc. Newton develops as a formidable presence throughout the play; while still maintaining a pitiful undertone. Aside from stellar acting, one has to commend him on taking on such a mentally complex character to begin with.

While the storyline focuses on Martin's affair, his wife Stevie, played by Jennifer Steyn, is the one who truly captured my attention. In dialogues with Newton, it's hard to take your eyes off of her as she floats between comedy and tragedy expertly. She is so entirely comfortable and natural playing devoted wife and then scorned lover that there is a feeling one is staring through the window of their homely apartment, rather than watching the drama on stage. This is helped by her chemistry with Newton, as the two construct a perfectly convincing couple thrown into a wildly inconceivable situation.

Review: Intensity and Absurdity of THE GOAT, OR WHO IS SYLVIA? Tackled at Baxter Theatre Centre

Martin's best friend, Ross (Paul Savage), of two decades is arguably the catalyst for what unfolds in the 90-minute drama. There are moments where Savage moves with ease in his relationship with Newton, but there are also times when his lines feel a bit forced. The same can be said of Sihle Mnqwazana in the role of Martin and Stevie's emotionally volatile 17 year old son Billy. Believable at times, Mnqwazana appears self-conscious during more intense scenes, but shows great potential developing as a young actor.

The natural lounge setting where THE GOAT, OR WHO IS SYLVIA? takes place is appropriately complete with certain additions that work with the details of the play. It looks like a typical Observatory/Woodstock installation - making the perversion of THE GOAT, OR WHO IS SYLVIA? all that much closer to home and making one all the more uncomfortable with witnessing a breakdown of a typical domestic slice-of-life. Technicalities such as sound is minimal, but lighting can be mentioned for its organic accompaniment.

The play's subject matter is deeply upsetting, as A4 pages outside pre-warn patrons. THE GOAT, OR WHO IS SYLVIA? is not for the faint-hearted; but if you're interested in the darkly comedic macabre or simply want to bask in the acting glory of Newton and Steyn, then this production is worth a ticket.

Photo credit: Oscar O'Ryan


THE GOAT, OR WHO IS SYLVIA? will be performed at Baxter Golden Arrow Studio until 18 May 2019 at 7.30pm nightly, with Saturday matinees at 3pm. Ticket prices range from R120 (for block bookings of 10 or more), to R160 and R180. Booking is through Webtickets or selected Pick n Pay stores.


BroadwayWorld Logo Vote Now for the 2022 BroadwayWorld South Africa Awards
Vote Nowvoting ends in



BUDDY The Buddy Holly Story Comes to South Africa in 2023 Photo
Pieter Toerien presents a brand-new, full-scale stage production of the HIT rock 'n roll jukebox musical, Buddy: The Buddy Holly Story, LIVE onstage at the Artscape Opera House, from 28 March to 16 April, and The Teatro at Montecasino from 21 April to 28 May.

Review: AUNTY MERLE: THINGS GET REAL at the Baxter Theatre Centre Is Destined to be Anothe Photo
My family and I have been avid fans of the AUNTY MERLE musicals since the first of the three productions graced the Baxter stage in 2017. When AUNTY MERLE: IT’S A GIRL came out in 2019, my brother and I adored it so much that we saw it twice. So, when I heard that there was a third instalment in this musical series, I just about danced my way to

Voting Now Open For The 2022 BroadwayWorld South Africa Awards Photo
Voting is now open for the 2022 BroadwayWorld South Africa Awards! Nominations were reader-submitted and now our readers get to vote for their favorites.

Review: A CHRISTMAS CAROL is a festive must-see at Theatre On The Bay Photo
This beautiful adaptation by the team from VR Theatrical is pretty much just what the doctor ordered for the festive season. It combines song, animation, puppetry, voice overs, beautiful acting and a healthy dose of humour to warm the heart.


From This Author - Lindsay Kruger

Lindsay is a born and bred South African who lives in Cape Town after studying English, Media and Art, and Teaching at Stellenbosch University. She fell in love with musical theatre when she first ... (read more about this author)


BWW Review: Taking a Twist on Classic Tales in Delightful New Children's ShowBWW Review: Taking a Twist on Classic Tales in Delightful New Children's Show
December 13, 2021

TALES OF A BIG BAD WOLF opened this past weekend at Kalk Bay Theatre to much enjoyment from young and old alike.  With a cast ranging in characters from Red Riding Hood, Sleeping Beauty, Rapunzel, Prince Charming and more, this brand new children's theatre show from Sophab Productions makes for the perfect theatre outing this holiday season.

BWW Review: CINDERELLA at Masque Theatre an Unexpected Toe-Tapping DelightBWW Review: CINDERELLA at Masque Theatre an Unexpected Toe-Tapping Delight
December 10, 2021

CINDERELLA opened this past week at the Masque Theatre. A lighthearted, modernized take on a well-known fairytale, this production from the Masque Theatre and Constantiaberg Theatre Players can be described as nothing short of whimsical.

BWW Review: ALL TOGETHER NOW! Shines Bright Spotlight on Local TalentBWW Review: ALL TOGETHER NOW! Shines Bright Spotlight on Local Talent
November 16, 2021

LAMTA'S year-end production, ALL TOGETHER NOW!, opened over the weekend to standing ovations. In collaboration with Music Theatre International and Pieter Toerien productions, ALL TOGETHER NOW! was a fantastic celebration of well-known musical theatre numbers that combined the best of established and up-and-coming local talent.

BWW Review: ALCHEMY - Cape Town City Ballet Astounds with Energetic Triple BillBWW Review: ALCHEMY - Cape Town City Ballet Astounds with Energetic Triple Bill
November 8, 2021

Cape Town City Ballet has entered its Spring season with a vibrant trio of performances in ALCHEMY - THREE DANCES. Honouring three of the world's most celebrate male choreographers from the 20th century, ALCHEMY stands as a programme dominated by accomplishments of athleticism.

BWW Interview: Entertainment Marketing Powerhouse Noeleen Bruton on Opening New AgencyBWW Interview: Entertainment Marketing Powerhouse Noeleen Bruton on Opening New Agency
September 15, 2021

From THE LION KING to The Parlotones, Noeleen Bruton has had a wealth of experience in entertainment marketing and is now co-owner of new Cape Town based marketing and digital agency, Marketing Grit. Ready to take new strides on a well-walked path, Noeleen chats with BroadwayWorld.