Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: Searing ADMISSIONS Shines at The Gamm

Review: Searing ADMISSIONS Shines at The Gamm

Joshua Harmon's ADMISSIONS is a play that wants to challenge well-meaning white people to reconsider how they seek to lift up people of color. That may make it seem like it's a slog, or like it's a bitter pill one should swallow, but thankfully the biting dialogue and exceptional performances all around make this 110 minute play zing by. Harmon does a great job of raising the stakes for all the players until the tension reaches a satisfying crescendo, but, in the end, the payoff isn't quite as satisfying as it could be. However, that could also be part of the point.

Sherri Rosen-Mason (Deb Martin) is the admissions officer at Hillcrest, an exclusive private high school in New Hampshire, and during her tenure at the institution, she has sought to increase the diversity among the student population. She seeks to make the school reflect the diversity of the nation, and is hopeful she will reach the 20% mark of non-white students by the end of the year. Her husband Bill (Jim O'Brien), is the head of school, and is fiercely liberal; and their son Charlie (Jacob Osbourne) is a student hoping for early admission to Yale. However, their views on increasing diversity in education are set aside when their white son is waitlisted.

Right from the beginning it is very clear that this play is going to pull no punches. The action opens with Rosen-Mason in conversation with Roberta (Wendy Overly) about how the catalog that goes out to prospective students doesn't feature as many diverse faces as the school actually contains. Overly steals every scene she is in as she tries to understand why a bi-racial student is black enough for admission to school, but not black enough to photograph as black for the catalog. The few scenes between Overly and Martin are absolutely hysterical as Martin seems to be trying every tactic under the sun to avoid saying anything that makes it sound like she's looking for racial quotas, while Overly tries to parse her dense subtext into plain English. Overly comes off as dippy, but well-meaning, and Martin is firmly grounded in her sense of herself as a good person.

In his Gamm debut, Jacob Osbourne is perfect as Charlie. He manages to comes across both as a believable teen who has had his dreams crushed, but also as someone who has taken the best of the lessons his parents have taught him about how to be an ally to those with fewer advantages firmly to heart. His eye-rolls at some of his parents' more self-righteous statements are spot-on, and his character is the member of the Mason family who you most want to root for, even though his parents mostly say the "right" things.

Jim O'Brien is excellent as Bill Mason, the patriarch who takes Charlie to task when Charlie's complaints take a step beyond petulance. O'Brien always has an air of affability as his default, which makes it all the more jarring when his attitude switches. Rounding out the cast is Karen Carpenter as Ginnie Peters, a family friend constantly clad in athleisure. She seems easy to dismiss at first, but Carpenter gets to deliver a heartbreaking moment toward the end that really resonates.

Sets by Patrick Lynch and costumes by Amanda Downing Carney perfectly create the world this play inhabits, right down to the all-white kitchen straight out of HGTV and Sherri's apron adorned with images of Frida Khalo. Every single detail is meticulously crafted in a way that is thoroughly satisfying.

Admissions is effective at poking holes in the notion of a liberal bubble, and how that actually plays out when real life gets messy, but there are times when it feels like it lets its characters off the hook a bit too easily. Possibly Harmon didn't want to completely alienate what (one assumes) are his target audience, but for a show that comes out swinging, it ends with a bit of a whimper, more than a bang. Even so, it's thought-provoking and laugh-out-loud funny, especially when performed by such an exceptional cast.

Admissions runs January 16-February 9 at The Gamm Theatre, 1245 Jefferson Blvd., Warwick, RI. Tickets are $45, $55 and $65; preview performances (January 16-19) are $33. Tickets: 401-723-4266 or

Photo: L to R: Jim O'Brien as Bill Mason, Jacob Osborne as Charlie Mason, Deb Martin as Sherri Rosen-Mason. Photo by Peter Goldberg.

Related Articles View More Rhode Island Stories

From This Author - Andria Tieman

Andria Tieman is a lifelong theatre fan. She has an MFA in fiction, play & screenwriting and presently works as an academic librarian and special lecturer in Providence teaching students... (read more about this author)

BWW Review: Heartfelt DEAR EVAN HANSEN at Providence Performing Arts Center
April 6, 2022

BWW's Critic Writes 'We’ve probably all been in a situation where a white lie or a misunderstanding ballooned into something bigger and unexpected.  DEAR EVAN HANSEN takes this idea and turns it up to eleven when teenage Evan Hansen becomes linked to a classmate who commits suicide.  It’s an interesting examination of how in mourning, we may try to rewrite the narrative of a dead person’s life, but there’s no way to get past the icky feeling that Evan’s actions leave, despite catchy songs and excellent performances.'

BWW Review: An Officer and a Gentleman at Providence Performing Arts Center
February 20, 2022

The movie An Officer and a Gentleman came out in 1982 to both critical and popular acclaim, but turning this story into a jukebox musical many years later seems like a strange choice.  The cast in this touring production are across the board excellent, but some of the musical choices seem forced, and the plot seems torn between conveying the serious themes of the movie and wanting to lean into the more cheesy aspects of the 80s.  The result is an odd hodgepodge that suffers from an identity crisis, but is still entertaining thanks to the efforts and talents of the cast.

BWW Review: The Gamm's AN OCTOROON Is Not To Be Missed
February 2, 2022

In AN OCTOROON, Jacobs-Jenkins seems to delight in taking audiences on a shock-and-awe tour through America’s history and present. In turns horrifying and hilarious, this work manages to elicit almost every emotion a human being can feel as it burrows into your psyche.

BWW Review: HELLO DOLLY Dazzles But Disappoints at PPAC
March 4, 2020

HELLO DOLLY first landed on Broadway in 1964, and the current (2017) revival, playing at Providence Performing Arts Center through March 8, won the Tony Award for Best Revival and Best Actress for Bette Midler. While those who have nostalgia for this show will no doubt think it's fun, the uninitiated may find themselves wishing for a few of the less memorable songs to be traded for more robust character development. Not unlike the recent revival of Miss Saigon, which tried to win new audiences by actually casting Asian actors to play Asian roles and by spending a tremendous amount of money on technical wizardry; this revival of Hello Dolly went all out on sets and costumes, presumably to distract from mostly forgettable songs and a book that is bloated, dated and not nearly as charming as it thinks it is.

BWW Review: Spectacular MARIE ANTOINETTE At Brown/Trinity MFA
February 29, 2020

Providence theatre-goers have the opportunity to spend considerable time in 18th century France this spring--both at Trinity Rep's A Tale of Two Cities, and now at Brown/Trinity's MFA production of MARIE ANTOINETTE.  Seeing both productions back-to-back makes for an interesting juxtaposition as Tale of Two Cities takes us into the lives of the over-taxed working class, and MARIE ANTOINETTE takes us into the opulent palace that those taxes built.  While Marie Antoinette is not exactly an empathetic figure, it's easy to see why movies and plays are produced about her life. Excess -- in fashion, wealth, and consumption of all kinds -- makes for a visually spectacular extravaganza, and this production leans into that in the most delightful way.