
Review: NUNSENSE A-MEN! at The Winter Park Playhouse
An entertaining, fun and funny production of an audience favorite with a unique twist.
Experiencing something familiar through a new lens can be particularly thrilling. Whether that be a story brought to the stage from a beloved book or film, an untold side of a familiar tale or a modern take on a classic - experiencing something old in a new and different way is exciting. That was my experience seeing The Winter Park Playhouse's latest production, NUNSENSE A-MEN! - a mounting of the classic Dan Goggin musical comedy with a twist - all the Nuns that in"habit" the stage are played by men (thus the "A-Men!" in the title.) And as with so many productions of this audience favorite before it, The Winter Park Playhouse's production of NUNSENSE A-MEN! delivers many laughs and a downright good time.
If you have been to a production of NUNSENSE before you know the story: Five of the Little Sisters of Hoboken are staging a fundraiser in the gym of Mt. St. Helen's Elementary School to bury four of their sisters who died, along with 48 others, after eating bad vichyssoise soup served by their chef, Sister Julia, Child of God. The sisters buried most of the deceased nuns, but ran out of money (thanks to a controversial purchase by the Reverend Mother), forcing them to stage this show to raise the funds for the remaining four funerals. The fundraiser, presented in a variety show format allows each sister to "shine in their own way", but not everything goes to plan - creating much of the comedy for the evening.
Dan Goggin's book, lyrics and music continue to hold up well in this adaptation - delivered freshly by the cast of five actors embodying the Little Sisters. Director Roy Alan has assembled a rock-solid cast who each bring their own take to these timeless characters. As the Mother Superior, Sister Mary Regina, David Michael Green brings solid comic timing and some hilarious moments to the stage, especially in the Reverend Mother's gut-busting scene at the end of act one. As Sister Mary Hubert, Bert Rodriguez is the perfect foil to Mr. Green's RevMo - delivering some of the best vocals of the evening, especially in Hubert's closing number, "Holier Than Thou". Dustin Cunningham infuses his portrayal of Sister Robert Anne with chutzpah mixed with a deep care for her chosen vocation. As Sister Mary Amnesia, Ryan J. Lynch gives the audience an innocent and subtle take on the nun who doesn't remember her real name (A crucifix fell on her head, her memory's gone, what a shame...). Finally, as Sister Mary Leo, Alexander LaPlante portrays the novice/ballerina as enthusiastic and bright eyed with some strong ballet skills to boot.
As always, the creative team for Winter Park Playhouse's NUNSENSE A-MEN! does an excellent job bringing this story to vivid life on stage. CJ Sikorski's scenic design gives these nuns a solid place to play - a realistic gym backdrop decked out for a school production of GREASE. J. Adam Smith's sound design and Sarah Griffin's lighting create a strong ambience for the evening and Monica Titus' costumes, are "good habits" as I like to say. Finally, musical director Christopher Leavy creates the perfect musical setting for the show and leads a small but mighty live band who provide the score for the evening.
Overall, The Winter Park Playhouse's production of NUNSENSE A-MEN! Is a rollicking good time. It is entertaining, fun and funny and provides a unique twist on a show that has become an audience favorite over the last forty years. So whether you have seen NUNSENSE many times before or you are a "novice", don't miss your chance to see the Little Sisters of Hoboken take The Winter Park Playhouse stage in this funny, "nunny" musical.
NUNSENSE A-MEN!, presented by The Winter Park Playhouse, runs through February 18th. Tickets range from $39 to $46 ($20 for Industry, Student and Active Military). Performances take place at The Winter Park Playhouse which is located at 711 Orange Avenue Suite C Winter Park, FL 32789. Tickets can be purchased by visiting https://winterparkplayhouse.org/ or calling (407) 645-0145.
Photo Credit: All photos Courtesy of The Winter Park Playhouse
Photos : Courtesy of The Winter Park Playhouse
Top Photo : David Michael Green
Header and Bottom Photo : (clockwise from bottom center) David Michael Green, Bert Rodriguez, Dustin Cunningham, Alexander LaPlante, Ryan J. Lynch
From This Author - Joseph Harrison
Joseph Harrison has been involved with the theatre in some form or fashion all his life. He holds a Journalism degree from the University of Georgia, but his true love is the theatre which he has b... (read more about this author)

March 12, 2023
One of the things I love about musical theatre is how it can be so many different things all at once. Shows that tackle a deep subject or address a serious social topic sit next to light and fun stories of queens and knights in shining armor, and all make great musicals. And some shows, like PRISCILLA, QUEEN OF THE DESERT tackle all of the above, but do so wrapped in a glittery, colorful wrapping. So, I was particularly excited to make it out to Titusville to see Titusville Playhouse’s PRISCILLA, QUEEN OF THE DESERT (now playing through March 26th) – and found there a rollicking, good time that also strikes a particular nerve at this moment in history.

March 5, 2023
Who is creepy, kooky, mysterious, spooky and altogether ooky? It’s the Addams family of course! This iconic, weird and wacky family first graced the pages of the New Yorker in a comic strip by Charles Addams 85 years ago and since then have spawned a fan-favorite 1960’s TV show, a series of films and even a recent hit series, “Wednesday”, on Netflix. But in Andrew Lippa’s 2010 Broadway musical, THE ADDAMS FAMILY, audiences get to see a new side of the macabre exploits of Gomez, Morticia and their family – told through the magic of musical theatre. But like everything the Addams family does, this musical is far from normal. And New Generation Theatrical’s latest production of the musical hits all the right notes (played on an old, dusty organ of course) and creates an immersive treat that is a thrill to experience.

February 28, 2023
A new cabaret series is now underway in Orlando featuring stars from some of Broadway’s most beloved musicals. The series, called “Broadway On the Rocks” will offer it’s next show on Saturday, March 4th at the newly renovated Rocks Lounge at the Hyatt Regency Orlando. During each one-hour show, performers will share songs and stories from their lives on-stage, accompanied by pianist John R. Mason, III. Taking the stage on April 22nd will be Megan Reinking (HAIR, DRACULA THE MUSICAL, HBO’s Boardwalk Empire). I caught up with Megan and talked about her theatrical career, her experience on Broadway, and her thoughts on living in Orlando.

February 12, 2023
Getting to see a newer musical produced for the first time in the area by a local theatre is a particular thrill. That is especially the case for a musical like THE PROM, which has built a following due to it’s popular Broadway run and the recent musical film on Netflix. And in the hands of the skilled creative team and fantastic cast at Theatre South Playhouse, this Central Florida regional professional premiere is in excellent hands. It is fresh and fantastic and in the intimate TSP space, the audience is given the rare chance to connect on a personal level with the frenetic and fun story unfolding on stage.

February 11, 2023
A new cabaret series is coming to the Orlando featuring stars from some of Broadway’s most beloved musicals. The series, called “Broadway On the Rocks” premieres on Saturday, February 18th at the newly renovated Rocks Lounge at the Hyatt Regency Orlando and is just the first of three concerts planned. During each one-hour show, performers will share songs and stories from their lives on-stage, accompanied by pianist John R. Mason, III. Taking the stage for the first performance in the series will be Lindsay Northen (WICKED) and Jared Bradshaw (JERSEY BOYS, CHARLIE AND THE CHOCOLATE FACTORY), a talented husband and wife duo who relocated to Orlando during the pandemic and have come to call the City Beautiful home. I caught up with Jared and Lindsay and talked about their Broadway journey, how they ended up here in Orlando, their YouTube following and what to expect during their evening of cabaret.