Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: THE MIKADO Brings a Hundred-Year-Old Operetta to Life at The Kaye Playhouse At Hunter College

Review: THE MIKADO Brings a Hundred-Year-Old Operetta to Life at The Kaye Playhouse At Hunter College

The Mikado has an enduring place in popular culture. Over 130 years old, the musical has been oft-referenced in shows like Frasier and the Simpsons, and is the origin of the term "Grand Pooh-Ba," which has entered the English lexicon (you may remember it from the Flintstones). Even if you've never heard of the English composer-lyricist team Gilbert and Sullivan, chances are very good that you're familiar with at least some part of their work, especially if you're a musical fan. They were hugely influential on American musical theater, earning references in shows like Thoroughly Modern Millie and Hamilton.

These days, it's becoming rare to see fully-staged professional productions of Gilbert and Sullivan's work. The New York Gilbert and Sullivan Players (NYGASP) is a non-profit devoted to "giving vitality to the living legacy of Gilbert & Sullivan."

The Mikado is especially in danger of not being performed, since it's troubled by a racist past. Set in a mythical Japan that's meant to satirize Victorian England, the operetta has been sometimes performed in yellow face, and contains language and naming choices that seem to mock Japanese culture, like Peep Bo and Nanki-Poo.

Following a protest by NYU students and the Asian-American theater community, NYGASP pulled a production a few years ago and brought back the Mikado Reimagined in December 2016. The production does away with much of the problematic language and costuming choices, and brought Asian-American actors and creators to the forefront, with costuming designs that blend Western and Japanese clothing styles instead of the kimonos of previous productions.

David Auxier, Matthew Wages, and David Macaluso in the Mikado at NYGASP
David Auxier, Matthew Wages, and David Macaluso in the Mikado at NYGASP. Photo Credit William Reynolds

The new revised production has an original prologue by David Auxier that frames the musical as the imaginings of W.S. Gilbert, an English man swept up in the Japan craze of the late 1800s, who had never been to Japan. The revised version earned critical acclaim and praise from the original protestors.

Die-hard musical theater enthusiasts and fans of opera will love the Mikado, one of Gilbert and Sullivan's strongest scores. With quick-witted and clever lyrics that satirize society, you can easily see the influence G&S's works like The Mikado had on the works of American musical theater composers Rodgers and Hart, Stephen Sondheim, and Harnick and Bock. Some of the standout numbers from the score that you're probably already familiar with (or if not, you should be) include "Three Little Maids," "The Flowers That Bloom in the Spring (Tra La)" and "Tit-Willow."

Though the libretto is a little dated (a key element of the plot involves a woman so ugly that men have to fight over who doesn't have to marry her), for a hundred-year-old show, the sexism is surprisingly mild - it's nothing worse than, say, My Fair Lady or Oklahoma. There is an ugly woman trying to coerce an attractive young man to marry her, but there's also an ugly man trying to coerce an attractive young woman to marry him. At the end, they both get what they deserve.

NYGASP has added little touches to update the dated references. In Koko's "I've Got a Little List," in which he ticks off irritating people he'd like to execute, most of the lines have been modernized ("the people who on using hashtags do insist - they'd none of them be missed, #NoneOfThemBeMissed.)

Caitlin Burke and ensemble of NYGASP's The Mikado
Caitlin Burke and ensemble of NYGASP's The Mikado. Photo Credit William Reynolds

The entire cast has fantastic voices, especially Caitlin Burke as Katisha and Sarah Caldwell Smith as Yum-Yum. The full orchestra does justice to Sullivan's wonderfully inventive score. The musical is infused with zany humor, making it no wonder that it was a favorite of classic comedians like Groucho Marx, who appeared in a filmed version in the 60s. (Here's a clip of him singing "There Is Beauty in the Bellow of the Blast" with his daughter Melinda.)

The production has plenty of physical comedy and slapstick, making it a family friendly choice, and at $25 to $100 a ticket, it's a family outing that won't break the bank. (NYGASP offers an introduction to the musical at their Monday December 30th and Saturday January 4th matinees geared to help children enjoy the operetta).

The Mikado is playing now through January 5 at the Kaye Playhouse at Hunter College on 68th Street Between Park & Lexington Avenue. Tickets are available online.



Premiere of FLIGHT DELAY By Peter Anderegg Will Open at The Tank Next Week Photo
On December 1st Thisbe Theater Company opens Peter Anderegg's Flight Delay directed by Kelly Morgan at The Tank. The production runs until the 18th at 312 West 36th Street in New York City.

LEAVES by Victor Vauban Jr. to be Presented at Teatro LATEA in December Photo
'LEAVES” by Victor Vauban Jr. will be presented at Teatro LATEA Nov.30th, Dec. 2nd & 4th. The primary themes of this play include assimilation, colorism, the importance of family and mental health.

Vangeline Theater/New York Butoh Institute to Host Fundraising Gala in December Photo
Vangeline Theater has announced a Fundraising Gala on Sunday, December 11, 2022 at 8pm at Temple NYC, Brooklyn. Proceeds from the gala will support sending dancers to Houston, Texas, from February 6-10, 2023 to make history conducting a pilot study for The Slowest Wave - the first neuroscientific study of Butoh.

Cast Announced For the Festival of New Jewish Plays Photo
The Jewish Plays Project has announced casting for the Festival of New Jewish Plays, running November 30 and December 1 at the JCC.


From This Author - Rebecca Kaplan

Rebecca Kaplan is a writer living in New York. She writes fiction and edits online literary magazine The Furious Gazelle under the pen name Tess Tabak. You can follow her on Twitter/Instagram ... (read more about this author)


BWW Review: NYGASP Returns With A Delightful Production of PIRATES OF PENZANCEBWW Review: NYGASP Returns With A Delightful Production of PIRATES OF PENZANCE
April 14, 2022

Pirates of Penzance is a charming, lightly funny musical of inconsequential plot. The New York Gilbert & Sullivan Players (NYGASP) put on a splendid production at Hunter College's Kaye Playhouse.

BWW Review: MasterVoice'S ANYONE CAN WHISTLE Elevates a Sondheim Flop at Carnegie HallBWW Review: MasterVoice'S ANYONE CAN WHISTLE Elevates a Sondheim Flop at Carnegie Hall
March 11, 2022

If Anyone Can Whistle must be a concert, please, let it be a concert like this. MasterVoices, an organization dedicated to elevating choral works, brought the show to Carnegie Hall for a one-night engagement. They masterfully adapted the show as a scaled-down concert version, dropping any bells and whistles.