Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: Shuffle Over to the Secret Room for a Night of TRUFFLES

An Italian family in the midst of a celebration, thrown into disarray by a missing prized truffle, looming money issues and an unsolved murder...it really can't get better than this, am I right? What sounds like the next great television drama is given a musical flare and thus becomes a production that is equally as entertaining as it is creative. What we have here is Truffles: Music! Mushrooms! Murder!!!, an interactive theatrical experience that brings an unsuspecting audience into the world of the Donati family as they prepare for the annual auction of their two pound truffle. A night destined to be filled with delicious food, big bucks and the deadly comedy of untold family grievances, Truffles returns for its second installment with a renewed zest that will leave audiences craving the songs and drama that only a prized truffle can inspire.

After a four-year NYC run with original creators Billy Manton, Sonia Carrion and Hal Galardi, Truffles Consortium, LLC now presents the second "season" of Truffles at the Secret Room in the heart of Times Square. Written by Gregg Ostrin, featuring songs by Jenni Lark, Hal Galardi and Cassie Nadeau and under the direction of Matthew McVey-Lee, Truffles is the newest hit in town, hosted by Engine Room New York and Urbani Truffles. Within the depths of the beautiful Secret Room, where the joys of dinner and entertainment come together for a truly enjoyable experience, Truffles provides an exciting evening of whodunnit murder, mystery and hearty chuckles that pair well with a scrumptious meal and something bubbly to drink. The show is a unique interactive experience that puts the audience in the center of the Donati drama...without the casualties. Review: Shuffle Over to the Secret Room for a Night of TRUFFLES

Upon entering the Secret Room (when you locate the unmarked door on 8th Avenue), you are shown to your seats and also find yourself in the company of a stocked bar and waitstaff who are ready to make the evening as pleasant as possible. The pianist on the stage in the room's center begins to play, and a woman serenades the audience with popular songs whose lyrics have been slightly changed (thanks to Austin M. Tracy) to reflect the evening's star: the truffle. The lights dim and the show begins; with drink in hand and the warm feeling one has when in the city on a Saturday night, the audience is ready for a night of drama and laughs. We meet the Donati family: Dante, Olga and Isabella who, with employees Carlo, Virgil and Chef Bruno, are preparing for the annual auction of the family's famous two-pound truffle. With the intention of paying back mob boss Don Fiola and thereby saving their restaurant from financial ruin, the evening becomes one to remember when Dante is unexpectedly murdered and the prized truffle goes missing.

What ensues from there is nothing short of hilarious. Actors scramble around each other to discover who is responsible for these heinous crimes, while the audience is entertained (and remains thus so) as each character's involvement in the master plot becomes clear. Chef Bruno sings about his undying love for the prized truffle, Isabella is more concerned about the release of her second album than the death of her father and there is a bounty on everyone's head if the money owed isn't repaid. The plot becomes entertainingly wacky when romances spring up amidst the chaos, a handbag's secret compartment is larger than the bag itself and everyone sings their heart out as the audience determines who is truly not aware of what's going on, and who is simply playing dumb.

By choosing to attend a performance of Truffles, you're granting yourself a simple, lighthearted night of entertainment, brought to you by a very talented group of actors who are clearly having fun with what they do. There is so much personality on that stage, spread across the very colorful characters who are all at odds with one another, but somehow make the Donati business work. Whether or not you choose to have dinner with the show (which is very good, by the way), you're sure to have a great time that isn't just about beating down the crowds to get tickets to Broadway's hottest show. With the scene set and commendable actors who use their talents to bring the plot of Truffles to life, it is simply an enjoyable night out which I'm sure will leave you in much better spirits than when you first arrived. This show is wacky, hilarious, unique and all things that make a show memorable; you're sure to have a wonderful time.

Credit must be given to all those involved: John "JohnG" Guild, Lindsay Lavin, Willie Marte, Cassie Nadeau, Steve Tardio and Eddie Varley; kudos also to the creative team and crew not listed here.

Truffles: Music! Mushrooms! Murder!!! began performances at the Secret Room (located at 707 8th Avenue, between 44th and 45th Streets) on November 2nd and will continue thru December 28th. Ticket prices vary. Bar seating (show only) is $50, seats plus a three-course meal are $95, and the VIP package (which includes the three-course meal, champagne, VIP seating and an exclusive gift from Urbani Truffles) is $150 - must purchase two tickets for this option. Tickets can be purchased by clicking here, or by calling (212) 279-4200. All shows begin at 6:30 pm, but doors open at 5:45 pm and the pre-show begins at 6:00 pm. For the performance schedule and more information on the show, please visit the production's page here. The show runs two hours and is appropriate for all ages. Please be advised that the venue is not wheelchair accessible; there is a flight of stairs leading down, with no elevator.

Enjoy the show!



Related Articles View More Off-Off-Broadway Stories


From This Author - Kristen Morale

Kristen is a graduate of both Saint Francis College and Hunter College, with degrees in English and Musical Theatre. She enjoys going to any show, from community theater to Broadway productions, and... (read more about this author)

Previews: The Cape Playhouse Presents ALWAYS…PATSY CLINE Starting July 6th
July 2, 2022

For those of you looking for another year of quality and professional New England theater, The Cape Playhouse is set to continue its 2022 summer season with its upcoming production of ALWAYS...PATSY CLINE, which begins its run on July 6th.

BWW Review: Downtown Urban Arts Festival Celebrates 20 Years This June at Theatre Row
June 7, 2022

The Downtown Urban Arts Festival (DUAF) was founded in 2001 on this basis: to bring a collection of new American works that, in their words, 'speaks to a whole generation whose lives defy categorizing along conventional lines.' In its attempts to bring the spirit of real playwrights and characters to the stage, DUAF has been recognized as one of the world's best festivals for new works - a platform well known for the freedom it provides for artistic expression. Twenty years have passed since its founding, and what better way to celebrate such a pillar of New York theater than with the newly introduced 2022 lineup of new works - a month-long showcase of raw talent that has already undoubtedly left its mark on a New York audience.

BWW Review: Peter Welch's LARRY AND LUCY A Work of Sheer Beauty at Theater for the New City
April 14, 2022

A story of two people sets the stage for some wondrous things to happen. Each understands what the other is going through, and ultimately becomes what the other needs. The story of Larry and Lucy is such a story. An Uber driver jaded by life meets a teenage girl who has turned to drugs in her attempt to alleviate the unrelenting boredom of her life. Through their shared search for purpose do these two characters portray how unfortunate many are to suffer, but also how lucky are those who see their hopes finally realized in the form of fated companionship - by those who, they realize, can make things better.

BWW Reviews: The Conflicts of Fact, Fiction and Freedom in Solnik's THE UNAMERICAN
March 18, 2022

Recently concluding performances at Theater for the New City, The UnAmerican questions the power that is supposedly given to those who believe they are above the consensus of the many. Directed by Joe John Battista, Solnik’s play follows the troubled triad of relationships between Marilyn Monroe, Elia Kazan and Arthur Miller - three legendary figures who are criticized and tried for their Communist affiliation

BWW REVIEWS: Sunday Afternoon With LIMELIGHT THEATRE COMPANY'S MARRY ME A LITTLE
March 4, 2022

Directed by Stephanie Scuderi, Marry Me a Little is Limelight Theatre Company’s next venture in bringing more inclusive and affordable performing arts to the greater NYC area.