Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: MEAN GIRLS at Saenger Theatre

Now on stage at the Saenger Theatre

Review: MEAN GIRLS at Saenger Theatre

It's time to bust out your favorite pink clothes and sharpen your claws as the Broadway sensation MEAN GIRLS plays at the Saenger Theatre in New Orleans this week.

Based on the 2004 Tina Fey-scripted film, this super-colorful and animated stage show offers a look into the trials and tribulations of high school cliques with Pepto pink panache. The dream team behind the musical is book writer Fey, composer Jeff Richmond (Fey's husband), Nell Benjamin (lyrics), and director/choreographer Casey Nicholaw.

The script follows the film, telling the story of Cady Heron (Mary Beth Donahoe), a new girl trading in the backdrop of Kenya for the wilds of Chicago. Cady is more apt at knowing the sounds of different bird calls than teenage culture. And at the prompting of high school misfits Janice (Adrianna Scalice) and Damien (Eric Huffman), she attempts to fit in with the Plastics. They're the A-list clique at her new school. Only she finds out how shallow her new friendships are after she falls for the ex-boyfriend of "Apex Predator," Regina George (Olivia Renteria).

Onstage Donahoe and Renteria give dynamic performances that showcase their immense individual talent as Cady and Regina. Scalice shines as the feminist Janis, providing the show with some of its most emotional high notes. Huffman's funny Damian serves as a moral compass in a role filled with exceptional singing and outrageous comedy.

The other two Plastics, Gretchen Wieners (Jasmine Rogers) and Karen Smith (Morgan Ashley Bryant) are mostly yes women who follow Regina's whims. Gretchen, who suffers from low self-esteem, begs for Regina's approval while being knocked down a peg by her friend at the same time. Rogers' emotional performance "What's Wrong With Me" shows an emotional nuance to the character of Gretchen.

Karen, "the stupid one," has random bursts of hilarious insight and a few touching moments to show that she's the least toxic person in school. Karen's heart is anything but plastic, and Bryant's performance was very endearing to audience members.

Devoted fans and those new to MEAN GIRLS will find much to enjoy about the musical and the laughs that have become meme-worthy over the years. Fey follows the major beats of her original script but has also updated it with new, contemporary gags such as updated dialogue and the influence of social media on a teenager's life (btw, this year's talent show is #scandalous). But the one thing that remains the same is the sharp humor of the script, which deserves nothing but straight A's.

Not to mention director/choreographer Nicholaw got the assignment. The ensemble is excellent with enthusiastic energy, great dancing and vibrant vocals for the two-and-a-half-hour performance. The stage moves and bends with non-stop swirling traffic in perfectly executed dance movement. During the song "Where Do You Belong," the ensemble uses lunch trays as instrumental bright red props while moving lunch tables around seamlessly. And thanks to the large-scale LED video screens, scenes effortlessly transform from the high school hallways to the shopping mall to a Halloween party.

Indeed, MEAN GIRLS was a refreshing and engaging night of theatricality. It's not like a regular musical. It's a cool musical.

MEAN GIRLS runs now through May 22nd at the Saenger Theatre.



Related Articles View More New Orleans Stories


From This Author - Tara Bennett

Tara Bennett is a Jill-of-All-Trades who currently serves as the head Arts & Entertainment writer for DIG Magazine in Baton Rouge, as well as the Media Coordinator for the Hammond Regional Arts Center... (read more about this author)

Interview: Edred Utomi of HAMILTON at Saenger Theatre
July 5, 2022

The Broadway phenomenon that is HAMILTON is back in the Crescent City. This epic, historical reimaging by Lin-Manuel Miranda is currently running at the Saenger Theatre now through July 10th. As one of the most impactful musicals to ever hit the bar, the question isn’t so much are you going, but when are you going. BroadwayWorld.com sat down with Alexander himself, Edred Utomi, to talk all things about his role as one of our Founding Fathers.

BWW Review: PORCUPINE at Bywater Wonderland
June 2, 2022

Dr. Sigmund Freud is making a return visit to the United States, this time as a literary figure in the immersive theatrical experience, PORCUPINE.

BWW Review: MEAN GIRLS at Saenger Theatre
May 20, 2022

It’s time to bust out your favorite pink clothes and sharpen your claws as the Broadway sensation MEAN GIRLS plays at the Saenger Theatre in New Orleans this week.

BWW Review: FOR WHOM THE SOUTHERN BELLE TOLLS at Tennessee Williams Threatre Company
April 5, 2022

Returning to the stage since the pandemic shutdown is one New Orleans theatre company that has been sorely missed. The Tennessee Williams Theatre Company and their current production of FOR WHOM THE SOUTHERN BELLE TOLLS is a comedic romp that will give audiences the best medicine of all.

BWW Interview: Cecil Baldwin of WELCOME TO NIGHT VALE at Civic Theatre
March 30, 2022

A groundbreaking podcast known for pushing the boundaries of storytelling celebrates 10 years as WELCOME TO NIGHT VALE returns to New Orleans this Thursday. WELCOME TO NIGHT VALE is a radio-style show focusing on the community of the eerie desert town of Night Vale. Featuring announcements from the Sheriff’s Secret Police, mysterious lights in the night sky, and dark hooded figures who frequent the local dog park, NIGHT VALE is Twin Peaks for your ears.