Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

BWW Reviews: 'Proof' at Tennessee Repertory Theatre

Rene Dunshee Copeland is, perhaps, the best stage director in Nashville (competing with her husband, Scot Copeland, the heart and soul of Nashville Children's Theatre, for claim to the imagined title), having brought some of the most memorable works to local stages during her career . And with Tennessee Repertory Theatre (where she is producing artistic director) celebrating its 25th Anniversary Season this year, she has gone for broke, helming all four shows included in the silver season.

With Steel Magnolias and A Christmas Story already under her belt, for both of which she gained justified critical acclaim, she has added David Auburn's Proof to her resume. The result? Yet another sublimely mounted production to complement the ever-growing list of her successes.

Of course, every director is only as good as his or her latest show and with each subsequent production, Copeland proves herself worthy of any theatrical challenge. Her unerring eye for casting ensures that each show is superbly acted and her critical eye makes certain that every show is presented in a creative and imaginative manner. With her penchant for quality and her attention to detail, a Rene Copeland-directed show is certain to deliver more than an audience expects, thus ensuring that Tennessee Rep will remain an artistic leader both regionally and nationally.

In Proof, playwright Auburn focuses on Catherine, the daughter of Robert, a University of Chicago professor and a mathematician of much notoriety, who has recently died after a long battle with mental illness. Following Robert's death, one of his students - Hal - uncovers a proof about prime numbers among Robert's papers; the new proof, certain to shift mathematical paradigms when it is published, is of unclear and uncertain authorship. While it appears written in Robert's labored handwriting, Catherine claims ownership and the ensuing debate provides much of the conflict in the play.

Clearly, Auburn's play is intriguing and its consideration of Catherine's place in the male-dominated world of mathematics is illuminating, what is most confounding about the play is the fact that we never hear what the "proof" in Proof is really all about. Perhaps it would be over our heads, but couldn't the playwright have trusted his own writing skills to give his audience a more edifying experience? At play's end, when Catherine and Hal settle down to discuss the proof in question, the lights fade and the music swells. Sure, it's a lovely way to end the play, but audiences are certainly hoping for more.

With Proof, chief among Copeland's winning elements is her talented, capable cast of actors. Anna Felix makes her Tennessee Rep debut as Catherine, the 25-year-old daughter of a mathematical genius gone mad in his later years, delivering a performance that is elegantly layered and as genuine as any we've seen. There is not a false note to be found in Felix's portrayal of Catherine, with every line delivered effortlessly and realistically. Felix is at once charming and off-putting as she betrays Catherine's fears that she may succumb to the same madness that enveloped her genius father, rendering him unable to function in the world he so loved.

As Hal, Robert's Ph.D. Candidate student struggling to make his own way in the competitive world of top-flight university mathematicians, Eric D. Pasto-Crosby gives a finely tuned performance. Pasto-Crosby very ably combines boyish charm with the man's ambitions to create a memorable characterization that matches Felix's in intensity and sure-footed delivery. Their budding romantic relationship notwithstanding it is their shared love for mathematics that is most obviously felt.

Chip Arnold, cast as Robert, conveys a very real sense of paternal concern and patriarchal superiority in the face of his character's encroaching madness. His delivery of his lines is impeccable and he displays a sense of timing that his younger co-stars should study for future reference. Although some of Arnold's choices at first seem rather arch, they somehow add to his character's dramatic descent into madness.

But the true revelation of this cast may well be Erin Whited who, in real life, is probably one of the sweetest, nicest people on this earth. Quite simply, that cannot be said of her character - Claire, Catherine's over-protective older sister. Whited's Claire is a brittle, career-driven woman who has always felt out of place in her own family, and her arrival for her father's funeral unleashes her sense of responsibility and her overbearing ways threaten to upend Catherine's fragile equilibirium. Whited's performance is noteworthy for its lack of staginess; even with her character's obvious shortcomings, the actress somehow makes her sympathetic, thoroughly engaging the audience in her persona.

As is expected with Tennessee Rep productions, the design aesthetic found in Proof is exceptional: Gary Hoff's gorgeously rendered set fully realizes the backporch and yard of a professor's University of Chicago neighborhood home as described by Auburn in his script, thus providing the cast a well-conceived arena in which to present the play. Karen Palin's exquisite lighting design artfully creates a sense of time and place in which the play's action occurs. And TrisH Clark's costumes are perfect for the play's four characters, never looking like costumes at all, but merely the clothes worn by Catherine, Hal, Claire and Robert. Finally, credit goes to Copeland and Tennessee Rep technical director Andrew Bevaqua for their sound design and for the music that evocatively frames the play's action.

- Proof. By David Auburn. Directed by Rene Dunshee Copeland. Presented by Tennessee Repertory Theatre at the Andrew Johnson Theatre at the Tennessee Performing Arts Center, Nashville. Through February 20. For details, visit the company's website at

Chip Arnold as Robert In Proof, photographed by Susan Adcox

From This Author - Jeffrey Ellis

Jeffrey Ellis is a Nashville-based writer, editor and critic, who's been covering the performing arts in Tennessee for more than 35 years. In 1989, Ellis and his partner l... (read more about this author)

Review: Studio Tenn Collaborates with TPAC for 2022-23 Season Opener of AIDA IN CONCERT at Polk TheatreReview: Studio Tenn Collaborates with TPAC for 2022-23 Season Opener of AIDA IN CONCERT at Polk Theatre
October 1, 2022

Studio Tenn – the Franklin-based professional theater company – launches its 2022-23 season in collaboration with Tennessee Performing Arts Center for a concert staging of Elton John and Tim Rice’s Aida, playing for just two nights at TPAC’s James K. Polk Theatre September 30 and October 1. Under the direction of Studio Tenn artistic director Patrick Cassidy (who shares duties with co-director and choreographer Gerry McIntyre), Aida features a starry cast of actors with Broadway pedigrees (Jackie Burns and Rex Smith), along with some of Music City’s most beloved stage veterans (Bakari Jamal King and Mark Cabus) and featuring the stunning triumph of a young woman who audiences have watched grow up on Nashville stages (Maya Riley) in the title role.

Review: Roxy Regional Theatre's 2022 Revival of INTO THE WOODS May Mark Another Turning Point For The CompanyReview: Roxy Regional Theatre's 2022 Revival of INTO THE WOODS May Mark Another Turning Point For The Company
September 30, 2022

In 2010, the Clarksville-based Roxy Regional Theatre staged a production of Stephen Sondheim and James LaPine’s “exquisitely off-kilter and melodiously rapturous musical Into the Woods” which remains firmly ensconced in my memory for its many attributes, not the least of which were the actors (Sarah Levine, Rachael Fogle, Josh Bernaski, Gregory Pember, Jackie Ostick and current artistic director Ryan Bowie) who brought the show so vividly to life and whose performances remain among some of the best we’ve seen at the venue in its 40 years. In fact, we often cite that 2010 Into the Woods (after another fondly remembered production some 15 years even before that) as a turning point, of sorts, in the history of The Roxy.

Review: PRETTY WOMAN THE MUSICAL Plays Nashville's Tennessee Performing Arts Center Through Sunday, 10/02Review: PRETTY WOMAN THE MUSICAL Plays Nashville's Tennessee Performing Arts Center Through Sunday, 10/02
September 28, 2022

Pretty Woman The Musical – the latest offering in the 2022-23 Broadway at TPAC Series – is one of those shows that almost defies explanation and proves even more difficult to review. (Case in point: I’ve rewritten that sentence 758 times in the past 22 hours and it’s still not “singing,” is it?) Pretty Woman The Musical is a pleasant enough diversion, entertaining even, but there is little in the show’s first act to convince most people that the 1990 rom com, which starred Julia Roberts and Richard Gere, needed to be transformed into a glitzy and glittering Broadway musical (a term we use loosely in this case), with Olivia Valli and Adam Pascal in the leading roles.

Review: Nashville Story Garden's U.S. Premiere of Lucy Kirkwood's THE WELKIN Will Have Audiences TalkingReview: Nashville Story Garden's U.S. Premiere of Lucy Kirkwood's THE WELKIN Will Have Audiences Talking
September 24, 2022

Nothing engages the theaterati in Nashville and the surrounding provinces as the production of an eagerly anticipated new play no one’s done before in these parts, but about which we’ve read glowing reviews. The very promise of something new to energize the cultural zeitgeist – particularly under the aegis of Nashville Story Garden (a creative collective whose work always generates major buzz); something new and unseen from across the pond which will provide a showcase for the remarkable talents of some of the region’s most respected actors – is virtually guaranteed to be a “must-see” for a theater-going public more accustomed to titles with which they are already quite often overly familiar.

LeLand Gantt Brings RHAPSODY IN BLACK to TPAC This Weekend for Three PerformancesLeLand Gantt Brings RHAPSODY IN BLACK to TPAC This Weekend for Three Performances
September 23, 2022

As with most intelligent and clever actors struggling to find paying work during difficult times, LeLand Gantt readily admits that he was inspired to create Rhapsody in Black, which has been described as “a powerful personal narrative on racism, identity, and self-image” to provide some work for himself, allowing him to “stay in town to do more tv and film.” Now, however, as acclaim for his one-man show continues to grow, he’s finding himself “out of town” – he's based in New York – to give theater-goers all over the country a chance to see his the result of his creativity on his personal journey to transcene racism in America.