Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: THE MUSIC MAN at Goodman Theatre

Review: THE MUSIC MAN at Goodman Theatre

Director Mary Zimmerman lends her whimsy to THE MUSIC MAN at Goodman Theatre in a production that pays homage to the small-town charm and iconic score of Meredith Willson's classic musical. Under Zimmerman's direction, this MUSIC MAN becomes a joyful company piece showcasing, in particular, the talents of the formidable actors in the supporting and ensemble roles. The production finds all the earnest humor embedded in THE MUSIC MAN, and Jermaine Hill's music direction ensures that each note rings out fully from the 12-member orchestra.

Zimmerman's staging allows audiences to indulge in all the nostalgia that comes from this 1957 musical. The tightly structured musical adheres to some of the best practices in writing from the Golden Age of Musicals, and that's plain to see here. The patter style of the opening number "Rock Island" introduces us to a troupe of traveling salespeople bemoaning the challenges of a life in sales-and wondering about the particular schemes of the infamous Harold Hill. George Andrew Wolff, Jeremy Peter Johnson, Bri Sudia, Matt Crowle, and Jonathan Stewart nail the song's unique, fast-paced rhythm without ever compromising diction. These performers also underscore the stark contrast between the lives of the traveling salespeople and the spirited townspeople of River City, Iowa, whose songs have a more traditional musical theater styling.

Production-wise, this MUSIC MAN remains firmly rooted in the 1950s. Daniel Ostling's set makes River City a sprawling and detailed playground for the entire ensemble. The train he has designed for the show's opening number is particularly stunning. Ana Kuzmanic's costume designs reflect the colorful personalities of River City's citizens and are visual marvels.

The worlds of the salespeople and the River City citizens become intermingled when Harold Hill arrives in town. Hill warns the townspeople that trouble is coming to River City (for the unfamiliar, "Ya Got Trouble" is perhaps one of the most iconic songs in the American musical theater songbook) and that parents can keep their children off the streets by having them join Hill's band. The real trouble, of course, stems from the fact that Hill has no musical training whatsoever, but rather plans to take the money he collects for the band instruments and uniforms-and run.

THE MUSIC MAN posits that Hill's charm and cleverness as a salesman can easily win over the townspeople and spread joy along the way. Given that, actors often have the option of playing Hill as either a slightly manipulative crook with a heart of gold or as a genuinely charming individual. While Geoff Packard makes an affable Harold Hill, he does not make a firm decision in either direction with his performance. Thus, I wish Packard's Hill had a slightly stronger personality so as to be fully convincing that his character could cause such a stir in town-and such a change of heart for the town's strongly independent and intelligent librarian, Marian Paroo.

Review: THE MUSIC MAN at Goodman Theatre

Monica West makes a formidable Marian. She delivers Marian's classic "I Want" songs "Goodnight My Someone" and "My White Knight" with beautifully crystalline vocals and carefully studied emotions. West also clearly plays the arc of the character, making us see how Marian becomes changed after meeting Harold Hill. But I wasn't fully convinced that Packard's Hill could bring about such changes in her character. West and Packard seemed to resonant better vocally, especially with their duet "Til There Was You," than they did acting-wise.

Accordingly, THE MUSIC MAN becomes more of an ensemble piece in this case. The performers essay the score's robust vocal harmonies with ease. Denis Jones's high-spirited and balletic choreography forms a centerpiece in the production, elevating some of the more outdated musical numbers in the show. "Shipoopi," in particular, feels terribly old-fashioned and dramaturgically non-sensical now, but Jones's choreography places the spectacle more on the movement than the lyrics.

The supporting roles are expertly and humorously portrayed. Ron E. Rains is magnificently daffy as River City's Mayor Shinn, pulling off all his non-sequiturs with a convincing determination. Rains is well-matched by Heidi Kettenring in the role of his wife, Eulalie Mackecknie Shinn. Kettenring is deliciously quirky as Eulalie. She's also in great company with her close-knit group of gossiping ladies: Alma (Nicole Michelle Haskins), Ethel Toffelmier (Lillian Castillo), Mrs. Squires (Danielle Davis), and Maud Dunlop (Bri Sudia). This quintet makes funny and clever work of the gossipy "Pick-a-Little, Talk-a-Little," and they're all gifted physical comedians, as well. As Hill's nemesis Charlie Cowell, Matt Crowle displays his natural knack for comedy and his ceaseless desire to beat out Hill.

Review: THE MUSIC MAN at Goodman Theatre

On the whole, Willson's score sounds extremely pleasant at the hands of this ensemble and orchestra. For audiences looking to revisit THE MUSIC MAN or see it for the first time, the joys of the score and the quaint humor in the musical are fully present to enjoy.

THE MUSIC MAN plays through August 18 in the Albert Theatre at Goodman Theatre, 170 North Dearborn. Tickets are $25-$142. Visit or call 312.443.3800.

Photo Credit: Liz Lauren

Comedian Moshe Kasher to Perform at The Den Theatre in June Photo
The Den Theatre will present comedian Moshe Kasher performing two stand-up shows June 16 & 17, 2023 on The Heath Mainstage.

THE LINCOLNS OF SPRINGFIELD Comes to Springfield Ahead of Potential New York Run Photo
Springfield, IL – historically significant as the State Capitol AND the place Abraham Lincoln called home from 1837-1861- when he began his tenure in The White House as one of the most lauded presidents in history-will serve as host for a joyous and riveting new musical love story.

Terence L. Cranerts New Musical THE LINCOLNS OF SPRINGFIELD To Open in Illinois This Summe Photo
Terence L. Cranert's stirring new musical for the whole family, THE LINCOLNS OF SPRINGFIELD, premieres in Springfield, Illinois, with sights set on New York.

Comedian Danny LoPriore to Perform at The Den Theatre in April Photo
The Den Theatre will present an evening of stand-up with comedian Danny LoPriore on Thursday, April 27, 2023 at 7:30 pm on The Heath Mainstage.

From This Author - Rachel Weinberg

Chicago native Rachel Weinberg has been one of the most frequent contributing editors and critics for BroadwayWorld Chicago since joining the team in 2014. She is a marketing professional specializ... (read more about this author)

Review: THE COMEDY OF ERRORS at Chicago Shakespeare TheaterReview: THE COMEDY OF ERRORS at Chicago Shakespeare Theater
March 17, 2023

Chicago Shakespeare Theater Artistic Director Barbara Gaines cleverly marries play and production concept in THE COMEDY OF ERRORS for her final production.

Review: LAYALINA at Goodman TheatreReview: LAYALINA at Goodman Theatre
March 15, 2023

Martin Yousif Zebari’s LAYALINA is a heartwarming multigenerational family play that spans from Baghdad to Skokie. While Zebari doesn’t shy away from portraying the family’s trauma and the challenges of their immigrant experiences, LAYALINA is the opposite of many other family plays. It’s about how the central family tries to reconnect and find commonalities, despite their generational and cultural differences.

Review: DESCRIBE THE NIGHT at Steppenwolf Theatre CompanyReview: DESCRIBE THE NIGHT at Steppenwolf Theatre Company
March 13, 2023

Rajiv Joseph’s DESCRIBE THE NIGHT, now in its Chicago premiere at Steppenwolf Theatre Company, is a sprawling exploration of the blurring of fiction and fact, censorship, and the quest to preserve truth.

Review: TONI STONE at Goodman TheatreReview: TONI STONE at Goodman Theatre
February 8, 2023

What did our critic think of TONI STONE at Goodman Theatre? TONI STONE is a memory play-in more ways than one. Lydia R. Diamond's play is indeed structured in non-linear (and yet, still mostly chronological order) as the titular Toni Stone recounts her memories as the first woman to regularly play professional baseball. It's also a memory play in the sense that it captures a moment in history that many audiences may not know before they see the work. In real life, Toni Stone played for the Indianapolis Clowns, a Negro League team, in 1953. The play itself never references that year-or any dates in Toni's timeline-outright (the program merely lists the setting as '1920's-1940's USA.') Instead, Toni weaves between different moments in her life, diving in and out of them-much like she might dive to catch a ball in the outfield (although she played second base).

Review: LADY DAY AT EMERSON'S BAR AND GRILL at Mercury Theater ChicagoReview: LADY DAY AT EMERSON'S BAR AND GRILL at Mercury Theater Chicago
February 5, 2023

What did our critic think of LADY DAY AT EMERSON’S BAR AND GRILL at Mercury Theater Chicago? To say Alexis J. Roston's performance as Billie Holiday in LADY DAY AT EMERSON'S BAR AND GRILL is a masterclass in acting and singing is no exaggeration. Roston gives the kind of lived-in, seamless performance that only comes from knowing the material intimately well, and indeed, it's a role she's played many times before.