Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Review: PUMP BOYS & DINETTES at Porchlight Music Theatre

Porchlight welcomes audiences back with this feel-good production.

Review: PUMP BOYS & DINETTES at Porchlight Music Theatre

After the long pandemic hiatus, Porchlight Music Theatre returns to in-person productions with a feel-good staging of PUMP BOYS & DINETTES. It's clear that Artistic Director Michael Weber knew that audiences would be craving some classic, lighthearted musical theater sentiment after such a long time away. He was wise to program director Daryl Brooks's production of this 1983 show as a welcome back.

Created by John Foley, Mark Hardwick, Debra Monk, Cass Morgan, John Schimmel and Jim Wann, PUMP BOYS & DINETTES is a quaint and charming musical revue about a fictional gas station and diner along Highway 57 in North Carolina. While the show's structure and jokes are not sophisticated, Porchlight's ensemble brings the high energy and humor that we've all been missing from live musical theater. In the show, we're introduced to gas station workers and eponymous pump boys Eddie (Rafe Bradford), Jim (Ian Paul Custer), L.M. (Frederick Harris), and Jackson (Billy Rude). The dinettes refer to the famous Cupp sisters of the Double Cupp Diner: Rhetta (Melanie Loren) and Prudie (Shantel Cribbs). The pump boys also form a four-piece band under the music direction of Robert Reddrick.

PUMP BOYS & DINETTES is the definition of a good time. It's not at all deep, but it has a driving purpose to charm and entertain viewers. The six performers lean into every moment with authenticity and full emotion, even when the material itself doesn't totally land. I had never seen PUMP BOYS & DINETTES, and I was intrigued by the inconsistent range of emotional notes. The musical has a great deal of genuine humor and some rollicking, high energy numbers that are powerful showcases for vocalists. It also has a number of jokes that wink at the audience and double entendres that tow an amusing line between innocent and a little bit adult.

Some of the other jokes feel dated and dusty, and the second half of the show introduces some slow ballads that don't make sense in the context of the generally fast-paced, lighthearted tone. While Loren and Cribbs harmonize beautifully on the duet "Sisters" late in the show, the song's maudlin sentiment is a too late attempt to introduce character development into a musical that really has none. In fact, PUMP BOYS & DINETTES is most successful because it overall consciously leans into the fun and paints the characters with broad strokes.

The production design mirrors the fact that PUMP BOYS & DINETTES is primarily about having a good time. Sydney Lynne's set design gives audiences a clear definition of place and has so many delicious details that make up the gas station and the Double Cupp Diner (Pay close attention to an anachronistic celebrity's photo on the garage door in the back of the stage). Rueben B. Echoles's costume and wig design reflect the "good ole times" sentiment of the show and has some modern touches too. Denise Karcewski's lighting design helps bring the energy up and adds dimension to the production's presentational style.

PUMP BOYS & DINETTES works best when it doesn't take itself too seriously, and it allows the audience to just have unadulterated fun watching the actors take on their roles. And when they're given those light-hearted moments to shine, they absolutely do! The performers sound great together, with the pump boys occasionally functioning as a fabulous barbershop quartet. And when all six actors come together to harmonize, that always feels special.

The individual performers have stand-out moments too. Frederick Harris's L.M. especially comes alive in the second act number "T.N.D.P.W.A.M." in which he recounts a surprising celebrity encounter. I won't reveal what that song title acronym stands for so as not to ruin the twist for other PUMP BOYS & DINETTES newbies like myself, but Harris makes the number a powerhouse vocal and comedic feat. Loren showcases her formidable vocal power and admirable range in her solo numbers "Be Good or Be Gone" and "Vacation." She lends the former a contemporary spin; it feels like she could be warning suitors in 2021 to step up their game or get out of her way. Custer displays his capacity for humor as he leads the "Fisherman's Prayer." Jackson's vocal range sits right in the pocket of Rude's capabilities, and he makes the most of the song "Mona" about his crush on a Wal-Mart cashier. Bradford has a calming presence as Eddie, but he knows when to lean into the humor with just the right beats. Cribbs and Loren harmonize terrifically on "Tips," which is a relatable and pointed "I Want" song.

PUMP BOYS & DINETTES is a reminder that Porchlight is a wonderful musical theater house right here in downtown Chicago, and this production delivers on the theatrical joy that I've missed for so long. If you're looking for a good time and to feel that special connection that comes with seeing a live musical, this is the ticket.

Porchlight Music Theatre's PUMP BOYS & DINETTES runs through December 12 at the Ruth Page Center for the Arts, 1016 North Dearborn. Tickets are $45-$74. Visit

Photo Credit: Chollette

Review by Rachel Weinberg

Lookingglass Theatre Company Announces Registration Is Now Open for 2023 Summer Camp Photo
The Department of Curiosity at Lookingglass Theatre Company invites high school students to participate in a one-of-a-kind experience this summer in the historic Water Tower Water Works on Michigan Avenue. 

TRADE FEDERATION Exploring Globalization Through Star Wars, Opens April 28 Photo
Otherworld Theatre Company, the premier science fiction and fantasy production company in North America, has announced the staging of Andy Boyd's “THE TRADE FEDERATION, Or, Let's Explore Globalization Through the Star Wars Prequels,” running April 28 - May 13, 2023 on the Ray Bradbury stage at 3914 N. Clark St.

Deeply Rooted Hosts Dance Education Spring Showcase At Logan Center For The Arts This May& Photo
Deeply Rooted Dance Theater, one of Chicago's premier professional dance companies for more than 25 years, hosts its Annual Dance Education Spring Showcase, this year honoring the legacy of Co-Founders Kevin Iega Jeff and Gary Abbott.

THE SPONGEBOB MUSICAL to Run June Through September at Kokandy Productions Photo
This summer, dive into Bikini Bottom as Kokandy Productions kicks off its 2023 season with Nickelodeon’s The Spongebob Musical, directed by JD Caudill.

From This Author - Rachel Weinberg

Chicago native Rachel Weinberg has been one of the most frequent contributing editors and critics for BroadwayWorld Chicago since joining the team in 2014. She is a marketing professional specializ... (read more about this author)

Review: THE BOOK OF MORMON National Tour Presented By Broadway In ChicagoReview: THE BOOK OF MORMON National Tour Presented By Broadway In Chicago
March 30, 2023

I was curious about the changes to Trey Parker, Robert Lopez, and Matt Stone’s THE BOOK OF MORMON, which underwent revisions before its post-pandemic return to Broadway in 2021. I imagined a substantial overhaul of the material, along with input from co-director/choreographer Casey Nicholaw (Parker also co-directed). After seeing the show, I can state the changes are minimal. All of the musical numbers are the same, and some of the dialogue may have been altered. But I don’t buy that the Ugandan characters have been given more agency or power.

Review: THE COMEDY OF ERRORS at Chicago Shakespeare TheaterReview: THE COMEDY OF ERRORS at Chicago Shakespeare Theater
March 17, 2023

Chicago Shakespeare Theater Artistic Director Barbara Gaines cleverly marries play and production concept in THE COMEDY OF ERRORS for her final production.

Review: LAYALINA at Goodman TheatreReview: LAYALINA at Goodman Theatre
March 15, 2023

Martin Yousif Zebari’s LAYALINA is a heartwarming multigenerational family play that spans from Baghdad to Skokie. While Zebari doesn’t shy away from portraying the family’s trauma and the challenges of their immigrant experiences, LAYALINA is the opposite of many other family plays. It’s about how the central family tries to reconnect and find commonalities, despite their generational and cultural differences.

Review: DESCRIBE THE NIGHT at Steppenwolf Theatre CompanyReview: DESCRIBE THE NIGHT at Steppenwolf Theatre Company
March 13, 2023

Rajiv Joseph’s DESCRIBE THE NIGHT, now in its Chicago premiere at Steppenwolf Theatre Company, is a sprawling exploration of the blurring of fiction and fact, censorship, and the quest to preserve truth.

Review: TONI STONE at Goodman TheatreReview: TONI STONE at Goodman Theatre
February 8, 2023

What did our critic think of TONI STONE at Goodman Theatre? TONI STONE is a memory play-in more ways than one. Lydia R. Diamond's play is indeed structured in non-linear (and yet, still mostly chronological order) as the titular Toni Stone recounts her memories as the first woman to regularly play professional baseball. It's also a memory play in the sense that it captures a moment in history that many audiences may not know before they see the work. In real life, Toni Stone played for the Indianapolis Clowns, a Negro League team, in 1953. The play itself never references that year-or any dates in Toni's timeline-outright (the program merely lists the setting as '1920's-1940's USA.') Instead, Toni weaves between different moments in her life, diving in and out of them-much like she might dive to catch a ball in the outfield (although she played second base).