Featured
Is This Your Show?
Submit Updates & Sell More Tickets
What If? The Songs You Love. Unexpectedly Recast. at 54 Below
Dates: 7/27/2026
at 9:30 PM
📍 Theatre: 54 Below
254 W 54th St. Cellar
New York, NY 10019
Phone: (646) 476-3551
Share
What if there was a multiverse where Glinda’s meltdown leads her to sing “Someone Gets Hurt” fromMean Girls? Or if Collins fromRentsang a Whitney Houston power ballad to his dying lover? Join us for an exciting evening ofWhat Ifsas your favorite musical characters sing songs that they’ve never sung before, all while interacting with characters from different shows. Come see familiar and new faces, from Broadway and beyond, sing unexpected combinations of the most beloved musicals in our seventh installment of this iconic series, while you ponder the question,What If?… Created and music directed byJorden Amir. Co-produced byAngelina AmatoandCooper LaMontagne. Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.
News About What If? The Songs You Love. Unexpectedly Recast. at 54 Below
We have no news on this show at the current time.
About the Theatre
Similar Shows Nearby
54 Below Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ
What shows are coming up next at 54 Below?
Schuyler Iona Press Plays Herself (08/10/26-08/10/26)
Jack Roden: My Days (08/10/26-08/10/26)
Ryan James Monroe (08/11/26-08/11/26)
Cabaret for the Chronically Dramatic (08/11/26-08/11/26)
Hooray (08/12/26-08/15/26)
Isaac Mizrahi Hooray (08/12/26-08/12/26)
54 Goes Classic Rock (Pt. 2): The Moody Blues (08/12/26-08/12/26)
Isaac Mizrahi Hooray (08/13/26-08/13/26)
Music by Matthew Meade (08/13/26-08/13/26)
Isaac Mizrahi Hooray (08/14/26-08/14/26)
54 Sings Prequels, Sequels and Threequels (The Sequel) (08/14/26-08/14/26)
Isaac Mizrahi Hooray (08/15/26-08/15/26)
Sing Us Out: Diving Down The Deep End (08/15/26-08/15/26)
Allison Bailey (08/16/26-08/16/26)
Allison Bailey, feat. Casey Cott, Lauren Paley, & Talia Suskauer! (08/16/26-08/16/26)
54 Sings The Sunday Scaries (08/16/26-08/16/26)
54 Sings Shuffle Along, Or… A 10th Anniversary Celebration (08/17/26-08/17/26)
First Drafts: Student Edition (08/18/26-08/18/26)
Adam Pascal & Anthony Rapp: In Resonance (08/18/26-08/18/26)
54 Sings Summerween (08/19/26-08/19/26)
Adam Pascal & Anthony Rapp: In Resonance (08/19/26-08/19/26)
Samantha Stratton: After One (08/20/26-08/20/26)
Adam Pascal & Anthony Rapp: In Resonance (08/21/26-08/21/26)
Tiano: The Tenor & Piano Duo (08/21/26-08/21/26)
Adam Pascal & Anthony Rapp: In Resonance (08/22/26-08/22/26)
54 Sings Broadway's Greatest Hits! (08/22/26-08/22/26)
Flame: The Songs of Brady & Browne (08/23/26-08/23/26)
54 Sings: Did You Bring a Condom? - A Benefit for BC/EFA (08/23/26-08/23/26)
Flame: The Songs of Amara Janae Brady and Xander Browne (08/23/26-08/23/26)
Did You Bring a Condom? (08/23/26-08/23/26)
Flame: The Songs of Amara Janae Brady and Xander Browne, feat. Sidney DuPont & more! (08/23/26-08/23/26)
Broadway's Hidden Hits (08/24/26-08/24/26)
Larry Kaufman: Sing Us A Song, Mr. Parody Man! (08/24/26-08/24/26)
54 Sings Bruno Mars (08/25/26-08/25/26)
Adam Pascal & Anthony Rapp: In Resonance (08/25/26-08/25/26)
Thomasina Gross: Eartha! (08/26/26-08/26/26)
Adam Pascal & Anthony Rapp: In Resonance (08/27/26-08/27/26)
Strength & Fury, feat. The Furies, Lee Moretti, & more! (08/27/26-08/27/26)
Broadway Gone Bad! (08/28/26-08/28/26)
Adam Pascal & Anthony Rapp: In Resonance (08/28/26-08/28/26)
Scott Siegel's Broadway Musical Brunch! (08/29/26-08/29/26)
54 Below! DEBUT! (08/29/26-08/29/26)
Adam Pascal & Anthony Rapp: In Resonance (08/29/26-08/29/26)
No Show (08/30/26-08/30/26)
Speaking Out, Singing Louder!: Standing Up Through Song Vol 2 (08/30/26-08/30/26)
Britani Bateman: What About Me? (08/30/26-08/30/26)
Basement After Dark: The Music of RAYE (08/31/26-08/31/26)
Britani Bateman: What About Me? (08/31/26-08/31/26)
Jack Roden: My Days (08/10/26-08/10/26)
Ryan James Monroe (08/11/26-08/11/26)
Cabaret for the Chronically Dramatic (08/11/26-08/11/26)
Hooray (08/12/26-08/15/26)
Isaac Mizrahi Hooray (08/12/26-08/12/26)
54 Goes Classic Rock (Pt. 2): The Moody Blues (08/12/26-08/12/26)
Isaac Mizrahi Hooray (08/13/26-08/13/26)
Music by Matthew Meade (08/13/26-08/13/26)
Isaac Mizrahi Hooray (08/14/26-08/14/26)
54 Sings Prequels, Sequels and Threequels (The Sequel) (08/14/26-08/14/26)
Isaac Mizrahi Hooray (08/15/26-08/15/26)
Sing Us Out: Diving Down The Deep End (08/15/26-08/15/26)
Allison Bailey (08/16/26-08/16/26)
Allison Bailey, feat. Casey Cott, Lauren Paley, & Talia Suskauer! (08/16/26-08/16/26)
54 Sings The Sunday Scaries (08/16/26-08/16/26)
54 Sings Shuffle Along, Or… A 10th Anniversary Celebration (08/17/26-08/17/26)
First Drafts: Student Edition (08/18/26-08/18/26)
Adam Pascal & Anthony Rapp: In Resonance (08/18/26-08/18/26)
54 Sings Summerween (08/19/26-08/19/26)
Adam Pascal & Anthony Rapp: In Resonance (08/19/26-08/19/26)
Samantha Stratton: After One (08/20/26-08/20/26)
Adam Pascal & Anthony Rapp: In Resonance (08/21/26-08/21/26)
Tiano: The Tenor & Piano Duo (08/21/26-08/21/26)
Adam Pascal & Anthony Rapp: In Resonance (08/22/26-08/22/26)
54 Sings Broadway's Greatest Hits! (08/22/26-08/22/26)
Flame: The Songs of Brady & Browne (08/23/26-08/23/26)
54 Sings: Did You Bring a Condom? - A Benefit for BC/EFA (08/23/26-08/23/26)
Flame: The Songs of Amara Janae Brady and Xander Browne (08/23/26-08/23/26)
Did You Bring a Condom? (08/23/26-08/23/26)
Flame: The Songs of Amara Janae Brady and Xander Browne, feat. Sidney DuPont & more! (08/23/26-08/23/26)
Broadway's Hidden Hits (08/24/26-08/24/26)
Larry Kaufman: Sing Us A Song, Mr. Parody Man! (08/24/26-08/24/26)
54 Sings Bruno Mars (08/25/26-08/25/26)
Adam Pascal & Anthony Rapp: In Resonance (08/25/26-08/25/26)
Thomasina Gross: Eartha! (08/26/26-08/26/26)
Adam Pascal & Anthony Rapp: In Resonance (08/27/26-08/27/26)
Strength & Fury, feat. The Furies, Lee Moretti, & more! (08/27/26-08/27/26)
Broadway Gone Bad! (08/28/26-08/28/26)
Adam Pascal & Anthony Rapp: In Resonance (08/28/26-08/28/26)
Scott Siegel's Broadway Musical Brunch! (08/29/26-08/29/26)
54 Below! DEBUT! (08/29/26-08/29/26)
Adam Pascal & Anthony Rapp: In Resonance (08/29/26-08/29/26)
No Show (08/30/26-08/30/26)
Speaking Out, Singing Louder!: Standing Up Through Song Vol 2 (08/30/26-08/30/26)
Britani Bateman: What About Me? (08/30/26-08/30/26)
Basement After Dark: The Music of RAYE (08/31/26-08/31/26)
Britani Bateman: What About Me? (08/31/26-08/31/26)
Where is 54 Below located?
54 Below is at 254 W 54th St. Cellar, New York, NY.
What shows have played recently at 54 Below?
Jason Graae: It's a Graae Night For Singing! (08/09/26-08/09/26)
Citizens of Belleville: A Bad Cinderella Reunion (08/09/26-08/09/26)
No Show (08/09/26-08/09/26)
Jason Graae: It’s a Graae Night for Singing! (08/09/26-08/09/26)
Casey Likes: Back To The Past (08/08/26-08/08/26)
54 Sings Broadway's Greatest Hits! (08/08/26-08/08/26)
54 Holds Space: For Good (08/07/26-08/07/26)
Casey Likes: Back To The Past (08/07/26-08/07/26)
FORBIDDEN, by Serina Marshall (08/06/26-08/06/26)
Citizens of Belleville: A Bad Cinderella Reunion (08/09/26-08/09/26)
No Show (08/09/26-08/09/26)
Jason Graae: It’s a Graae Night for Singing! (08/09/26-08/09/26)
Casey Likes: Back To The Past (08/08/26-08/08/26)
54 Sings Broadway's Greatest Hits! (08/08/26-08/08/26)
54 Holds Space: For Good (08/07/26-08/07/26)
Casey Likes: Back To The Past (08/07/26-08/07/26)
FORBIDDEN, by Serina Marshall (08/06/26-08/06/26)
|
Flame: The Songs of Brady & Browne 54 Below (8/23-8/23) |
|
DiGangi With A “G” The Green Room 42 (8/18-8/18) |
|
Let's Get Schooled: The Broadway Community Returns to the Classroom Green Room 42 (8/26-8/26) |
|
Troy: Crooner to the Stars The Green Room 42 (8/21-8/21) |
|
Sara Al-Bazali: Wait For It 54 Below (10/04-10/04) |
|
54 Sings Noah Kahan: The Great Divide 54 Below (9/14-9/14) |
|
El David Aguilar Joe's Pub (11/06-11/06) |
|
The Bowery Boys: Ghost Stories of Old New York Joe's Pub (10/31-10/31) |
|
Selda and Derek: While The Coffee's Still Hot Joe's Pub (11/15-11/15) |
|
54 Sings: Did You Bring a Condom? - A Benefit for BC/EFA 54 Below (8/23-8/23) |