A Black Sheep
January 6, 1896
·
Hoyt's Theatre
A Florida Enchantment
October 12, 1896
·
Hoyt's Theatre
A Fool of Fortune
November 30, 1896
·
Miner's Fifth Avenue Theatre
A Girl Wanted
January 6, 1896
·
Haverly's 14th Street Theatre
A House of Cards
March 23, 1896
·
Fifth Avenue Theatre
A House of Mystery
September 14, 1896
·
Haverly's 14th Street Theatre
A Light From St. Agnes
March 19, 1896
·
Garden Theatre
A Lion's Heart
April 6, 1896
·
People's Theatre
A Man of Honor
December 21, 1896
·
American Theatre
A Parlor Match
September 21, 1896
·
Herald Square Theatre
A Quiet Rubber
January 13, 1896
·
Abbey's Theatre
A Woman's Reason
January 27, 1896
·
Empire Theatre
An American Beauty
December 31, 1969
An Enemy to the King
September 1, 1896
·
Lyceum Theatre
An Innocent Sinner
November 16, 1896
·
Star Theatre
Arm of the Law
February 24, 1896
·
People's Theatre
Bohemia
March 9, 1896
·
Empire Theatre
Brother for Brother
December 14, 1896
·
Star Theatre
Burmah
January 28, 1896
·
American Theatre
Castle Sombras
December 16, 1896
·
Garden Theatre
Chimmie Fadden
January 13, 1896
·
Garden Theatre
Courted Into Court
December 26, 1896
·
Bijou Theatre
Darkest America
December 21, 1896
·
People's Theatre
El Capitan
April 20, 1896
·
Broadway Theatre
For the Crown
February 11, 1896
·
Palmer's Theatre
Gentleman Joe
January 6, 1896
·
Miner's Fifth Avenue Theatre
His Absent Boy
April 6, 1896
·
Garden Theatre
Hogan's Alley
October 12, 1896
·
People's Theatre
Izeyl
January 20, 1896
·
Abbey's Theatre
Lost, Strayed or Stolen
September 21, 1896
·
Fifth Avenue Theatre
Madame
March 23, 1896
·
Palmer's Theatre
Marie Deloche
March 16, 1896
·
Garden Theatre
Marriage
February 17, 1896
·
Empire Theatre
Marse Van
February 17, 1896
·
Empire Theatre
Mary Pennington, Spinster
October 5, 1896
·
Chickering Hall
Michael and His Lost Angel
January 15, 1896
·
Empire Theatre
Mrs. Ponderbury's Past
January 7, 1896
·
Garrick Theatre
My Friend from India
October 6, 1896
·
Bijou Theatre
On Broadway
October 12, 1896
·
Grand Opera House
Pamela Nubile
March 19, 1896
·
Fifth Avenue Theatre
Prince Karl
May 3, 1896
·
Hoyt's Theatre
Roaring Dick & Co.
November 16, 1896
·
Palmer's Theatre
Rosemary
August 31, 1896
·
Empire Theatre
Secret Service
October 5, 1896
·
Garrick Theatre
Society Shadows
December 28, 1896
·
Savoy Theatre
Sue
September 15, 1896
·
Hoyt's Theatre
The Art of Maryland
September 5, 1896
·
Weber and Fields' Music Hall
The Benefit of the Doubt
January 6, 1896
·
Lyceum Theatre
The Broken Melody
November 5, 1896
·
American Theatre
The Cherry Pickers
October 12, 1896
·
Haverly's 14th Street Theatre
The Chili Widow
November 30, 1896
·
Bijou Theatre
The Cotton Spinner
August 29, 1896
·
Grand Opera House
The Countess Gucki
January 28, 1896
·
Daly's Theatre
The Courtship of Leonie
November 24, 1896
·
Lyceum Theatre
The Gay Mr. Lightfoot
December 16, 1896
·
Bijou Theatre
The Geisha
September 9, 1896
·
Daly's Theatre
The Girl from Paris
December 31, 1969
·
Herald Square Theatre
The Governor of Kentucky
January 21, 1896
·
Fifth Avenue Theatre
The Great Northwest
August 31, 1896
·
American Theatre
The Great Train Robbery
October 19, 1896
·
People's Theatre
The Last Stroke
March 23, 1896
·
Star Theatre
The Late Mr. Castello
December 14, 1896
·
Lyceum Theatre
The Late Mr. Costello
December 14, 1896
·
Lyceum Theatre
The Law of the Land
April 7, 1896
·
American Theatre
The Liar
September 2, 1896
·
Hoyt's Theatre
The Light from St. Agnes
March 19, 1896
·
Garden Theatre
The Mummy
November 2, 1896
·
Garden Theatre
The Naval Cadet
November 30, 1896
·
Grand Opera House
The Nihilists
November 9, 1896
·
People's Theatre
The Politician
December 7, 1896
·
Murray Hill Theatre
The Prisoner of Zenda
February 10, 1896
·
Lyceum Theatre
The Queen's Proctor
December 7, 1896
·
Bijou Theatre
The Rogue's Comedy
December 7, 1896
·
Chickering Hall
The Seats of the Mighty
November 30, 1896
·
Knickerbocker Theatre
The Sign of the Cross
November 9, 1896
·
Knickerbocker Theatre
The Speculator
April 18, 1896
·
Fifth Avenue Theatre
The Squire of Dames
January 20, 1896
·
Palmer's Theatre
The Sunshine of Paradise Alley
May 11, 1896
·
Haverly's 14th Street Theatre
The Two Escutcheons
January 7, 1896
·
Daly's Theatre
The Village Postmaster
April 13, 1896
·
Haverly's 14th Street Theatre
The War of Wealth
February 10, 1896
·
Star Theatre
The White Flower
Opening date unknown
·
Lyceum Theatre
The Wife of Willoughby
December 14, 1896
·
Lyceum Theatre
This Picture and That
March 19, 1896
·
Garden Theatre
Thoroughbred
April 20, 1896
·
Garrick Theatre
True to Life
December 21, 1896
·
Murray Hill Theatre
Turn of the Tide
November 23, 1896
·
People's Theatre
Two Little Vagrants
November 23, 1896
·
Academy of Music
Two Old Cronies
January 6, 1896
·
Abbey's Theatre
Under the Polar Star
August 20, 1896
·
Academy of Music
Under the Red Robe
December 28, 1896
·
Empire Theatre
When London Sleeps
August 31, 1896
·
Haverly's 14th Street Theatre
