Show Boat Porgy and Bess Oklahoma! Carousel South Pacific The King and I Kiss Me, Kate Guys and Dolls Annie, Get Your Gun My Fair Lady The Sound of Music Hello, Dolly!
You can start with these and go on from there.
Actually, you can end with these. If you have these, you don't really need anything else.
Nine OBCR Flower Drum Song (revival with the added songs) Anything Goes (Lupone) Follies (OBCR - remastered version from Kritzerland) Sweeney Todd (OBCR) 1776(OBCR) A Chorus Line (OBCR) Falsettos Ragtime (OBCR) Ain't Misbehavin' On The Twentieth Century (OBCR) City of Angels (OBCR) Avenue Q Fiddler on the Roof (OBCR) Company (OBCR) Grey Gardens Gypsy (OBC or Lupone) Little Shop of Horrors (Off Bway cast) Man of La Mancha (OBCR) Mame (OBCR)
Me too Wynnie. I didn't list it because I was trying to keep my list manageable. But yea, definitely Last 5 Years and also Parade (JRB's - not Jerry Herman's)
If anyone ever tells you that you put too much Parmesan cheese on your pasta, stop talking to them. You don't need that kind of negativity in your life.