Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: JP COLETTA'S ROCK 'N' ROLL PIANO MAN at Milwaukee Rep

The production runs through January 3rd

By:
Review: JP COLETTA'S ROCK 'N' ROLL PIANO MAN at Milwaukee Rep

In “JP Coletta’s Rock n Roll Piano Man,” the humor, history and audience engagement are the keys to the fun, fast-paced musical journey – Coletta’s mastery of another 88 keys doesn’t hurt either.

The show is conceived, arranged and musically directed by Coletta, who takes center stage with lead vocals and piano. He is joined by Nathan Yates Douglass on bass and vocals, Chance Michael Wall on guitar and Casey D’Sola on drums.

The quartet pays tribute to the rock n roll piano men — and one woman — from the 1950s though the 1980s. “Piano Man” includes the classics but keeps the tone original and unexpected.  They highlights well-known artists such as Stevie Wonder and Elton John as well as pianists that were rarely center stage, such as of the Four Seasons’ principal song writer Bob Gaudio.

Not surprisingly, Coletta also highlights Jerry Lee Lewis, who he has portrayed in “Million Dollar Quartet.”  Coletta’s entertaining acrobatics during the JLL songs made the piano bench superfluous.

Coletta gave Douglass and Wall’s vocals space to shine – while he took well-earned mini-breaks.  The entire quartet shined on the spare Stacker stage and intimate cabaret setting thanks to lighting designer Petr Williams and sound designer Nick Depinto.

Pictured L to R: Casey D’Sola, Nathan Yates Douglass,JP Coletta and Chance Michael Wall. Photo by Michael Brosilow

Click Here to Get Tickets
More on Milwaukee Repertory Theater
Upcoming Shows
Heist
Heist
11/17 - 12/20/2026
Recent Articles
Review: JP COLETTA'S ROCK 'N' ROLL PIANO MAN at Milwaukee Rep
Review: JP COLETTA'S ROCK 'N' ROLL PIANO MAN at Milwaukee Rep
11/9/2026
Video: JP COLETTA'S ROCK 'N' ROLL PIANO MAN Rehearsal at Milwaukee Rep
Video: JP COLETTA'S ROCK 'N' ROLL PIANO MAN Rehearsal at Milwaukee Rep
11/5/2026

Reader Reviews



BroadwayWorld TV


Gravity and Other Myths in Milwaukee, WI Gravity and Other Myths
Marcus Performing Arts Center (11/13-11/13)
Hana's Suitcase in Milwaukee, WI Hana's Suitcase
Racine Theatre Guild (4/09-4/18)
"Somewhere" in Milwaukee, WI "Somewhere"
Checota Powerhouse Theater, Associated Bank Theater Center (4/13-5/09)
Theatre Gigante presents HOLIDAYS ON ICE in Milwaukee, WI Theatre Gigante presents HOLIDAYS ON ICE
The Brick House (12/05-12/06)
"MKE MVP" in Milwaukee, WI "MKE MVP"
Milwaukee Repertory Theater (1/16-2/28)
THE SNOW in Milwaukee, WI THE SNOW
First Stage (2/12-2/21)
At the Wake of a Dead Drag Queen in Milwaukee, WI At the Wake of a Dead Drag Queen
Next Act Theatre (4/21-5/09)
AUDITIONS - The Play That Goes Wrong in Milwaukee, WI AUDITIONS - The Play That Goes Wrong
Sunset Playhouse (11/16-11/17)
God of Carnage in Milwaukee, WI God of Carnage
Racine Theatre Guild (1/15-1/31)
"A Christmas Carol" in Milwaukee, WI "A Christmas Carol"
Pabst Theater (12/02-12/24)