Meet the Cast of MAMMA MIA!, Now on Broadway

Christine Sherrill - Donna

Christine last enjoyed the role of Donna during her residency with the Las Vegas company of Mamma Mia! Other national credits include Kiss Me Kate (Kate); Next to Normal (Diana); Guys and Dolls (Adelaide); Sunset Boulevard (Norma Desmond) which earned her a Joseph Jefferson Award. Her work spans prestigious houses from The Goodman Theatre to DC Shakespeare. TV/Film/Video: “FBI Most Wanted,” “Prophet,” “Red Dead Redemption,” “Landline.”

Amy Weaver - Sophie

Amy is over the moon to be making her Broadway debut as Sophie Sheridan! She’s proud to have been a part of the Mamma Mia! 25th Anniversary National Tour for the last 2 years. Favorite credits: Jersey Boys National Tour (Francine), Hong Kong Disneyland (Merida), Dust and Shadow (Alliance Theatre). WKU alum. Special thanks to Kevin Metzger-Timson, the entire creative team, Bloc, my incredible family and God! Believes in mermaids and magic! @dreamweaver90210

Carly Sakolove - Rosie

Carly is elated to be making her Broadway debut after playing Rosie in both the 2013/14 and 25th Anniversary tours!  When her YouTube video “Broadway Divas Send in the Clowns” went viral in 2010, Carly started her career in NYC as an actor, celebrity impressionist, and cabaret performer. Off-Broadway: The Book of Merman (Ethel), NEWSical, The Marvelous Wonderettes. TV: “The Watcher” (Netflix).  Film: Joanna Gleason’s The Grotto. Boston Conservatory graduate. For my family! @carlysakolove

Jalynn Steele - Tanya

Jalynn is thrilled to be back on Broadway with this awe-inspiring production of Mamma Mia! Broadway: The Lightning Thief (Sally & Others). Off-Broadway: Sistas (Dr. Simone). National/International Tours: Mamma Mia! (Tanya), Fosse (Star). Regional Theater: Rock of Ages (Justice), Joseph (Pharaoh) and Mary Poppins (Mrs. Corry). Television: Titanique The Musical: Livestream (Ensemble) and “Sesame Street.” Love to my family & friends, this one’s for you Jason & Dad. @Jalynn_The_Entertainer

Rob Marnell - Harry Bright

Broadway: TINA: The Tina Turner Musical (OBC), Beautiful (Gerry Goffin u/s), Gettin’ the Band Back Together (Joe Perry). Other: Jersey Boys (Bob Gaudio in Las Vegas, Joe Long in Clint Eastwood film), Rock of Ages (Stacee Jaxx), Sunday in the Park With George (George), Little Shop of Horrors (Orin Scrivello D.D.S. et al). B.F.A. Elon University. Original comedy and music: robmarnell.com. Endless love to Laurel and our adventure buddy, Elliot Fox. @robmarnell

Jim Newman - Bill Austin

Broadway: Hands on a Hardbody (Mike Ferris), Curtains (Randy Weinstein), Minnelli on Minnelli, Steel Pier (Happy McGuire), Sunset Boulevard, Tommy. 1st National Tours: Kiss Me Kate (Bill Calhoun), Big (Josh Baskin), Joseph…Dreamcoat (Levi). Film/Television: “Succession,” “And Just Like That,” “The Equalizer,” “FBI Most Wanted,” “Daddyhunt,” “After Forever,” “Love is Strange,” “Hiding in Daylight,” “Hope and Faith.”

Victor Wallace - Sam Carmichael

Broadway: Sam Carmichael in Mamma Mia! final cast at the Broadhurst. Off-Broadway: Far From Heaven at Playwrights Horizons (Cast Recording). Tours: The Phantom of the Opera (Buquet, Phantom u/s, Raoul u/s), Les Misérables (Enjolras). Las Vegas: Mamma Mia! (Sky) at Mandalay Bay Casino. Regional: Fun Home (Bruce Bechdel) at Coachella Valley Rep, Dragone’s Carmen (Escamillo) at La Jolla Playhouse. Instagram: @MrVDubbs 

Grant Reynolds - Sky

Grant is so excited to be making his Broadway debut with this beautiful company. Credits: The Muny’s Sweeney Todd, The Color Purple, Billy Porter’s directorial debut Anything’s Possible on Amazon Prime. He is thankful to God, his fantastic family and his amazing team. For Grandma & Grandpa. @grantreynoldss

Lena Owens - Lisa

Lena (she/they) is over the moon to make their Broadway debut with this stellar Mamma Mia! 25th Anniversary company. Before making her National Tour debut in Toronto, she was seen as Peggy Sawyer in 42nd Street at Music Theatre Wichita, and has performed at The Kennedy Center, The MUNY, and The 5th Avenue Theatre. This is all thanks to my parents’ endless support, the ATX theatre community, and my Wichita & OUMT families!

Justin Sudderth - Pepper

Broadway debut! Previous Credits: The Color Purple (Ivoryton Playhouse),Jimmy Buffet’s Escape to Margaritaville (Ivoryton Playhouse), Evita (Axelrod Performing Arts), Jelly’s Last Jam (Long Wharf Theatre). Thank you to DGRW, friends, and family for their continued guidance and support. Montclair State University ’22. Probably thrifting. Love you momma! 757 @justinaaronsudderth

Ethan Van Slyke - Eddie

Ethan is making his Broadway debut in Mamma Mia! Previous Credits: Mamma Mia! 25th Anniversary Tour, South Pacific (Goodspeed), West Side Story (The Muny), Newsies (Arena Stage). Proud graduate of the University of Michigan Musical Theatre program (Class of 2024). Thank you to his teachers, his team at HCKR, and The TRC Company. So much love to Mom, Dad, Conor, and Logan. @ethan.vanslyke

Haley Wright - Ali, Ensemble

BROADWAY DEBUT! Haley was fortunate enough to perform this show in ~65 cities on tour and cannot wait to add NYC to the list. You probably haven’t seen her in anything else, but that’s okay. Hopefully you enjoy her in this. She has a lot of fun. So so so much love and thanks to her family, friends, PMA team, Kevin Metzger-Timson, and her Owala. @haleyleft

Sarah Agrusa - Swing

Sarah is thrilled to be making her Broadway debut in Mamma Mia! She is a proud graduate of CAP 21/Molloy University and would like to thank her family/friends for their support! Sarah would like to thank Tara Rubin Casting, Bespoke, everyone at FSE, and the entire Mamma Mia! team for this opportunity,  Instagram: @sarah_agrusa

Alessandra Antonelli - Ensemble

Broadway debut! Tour: Mamma Mia! 25th Anniversary (Ensemble, U/S Sophie), Off-Broadway: Waiting in the Wings (Gina), Regional: Sister Act (Mary Robert), The Addams Family (Wednesday). Voice work includes Netflix animated series, commercials, and toys. BFA: NYU. So much gratitude to TRC, Ryan, her family and the stellar MM team! For her Mamma, Dad, Danny, and Nicky. What a joy, what a life, what a chance! IG: @alessandra__antonelli

Caro Daye Attayek - Ensemble

Broadway debut! National tours: Mamma Mia!, Aladdin, Hairspray. Select regional: A Chorus Line (Signature Theatre), Holiday Inn (ACCC), Footloose (The Rev), The Pajama Game, Grease, and Catch Me If You Can (New London Barn). Proud Elon MT ’19 alum. Love to my parents Johnny & Pammy A, Nana & Papa, Pete, the besties, & my family & friends. Special thanks to Sean & Rikky at Hybrid, TRC Casting, & the entire Mamma Mia! team. IG: @caro_daye

Adia Olanethia Bell - Ensemble

Adia is ecstatic to be making her Broadway debut in Mamma Mia! Some regional favorites include: The Wizard of Oz (Dorothy, Capital Rep) and The Comedy of Errors (u/s Luciana, Chicago Shakes). She earned her B.F.A. at The University of Arizona. Bear Down! Enormous thanks to my amazing mother — I am all that I am because of you. I love you! Follow my journey on IG: @adia_bell

Emily Croft - Ensemble

Broadway Debut!! So grateful to share the joy of this show alongside this incredible company. National Tour: Mamma Mia! 25th Anniversary, Rock of Ages 10th Anniversary. TV/Film: “Law & Order: Organized Crime.” Other favorites: Tangled the Musical, We Have Apples. BFA Musical Theatre from University at Buffalo. Thank you to ATB, TRC Company, Martha, Janet & David. For Mom & Dad, Jake & Seth who were there through it all. To Josh: thank you. I love you. @emlurrr

Madison Deadman - Ensemble

Madison is thrilled to be making her Broadway debut with Mamma Mia! after an unforgettable journey on the 25th Anniversary Tour. Regional: Maureen (RENT), Sally Bowles (Cabaret), Eponine (Les Misérables). Netflix/Peacock: A Girl Like Her. CCM, BFA. I believe in angels: Connor, Mom & Dad — I wouldn’t be here without your unconditional love and support. Thank you Pete & Lauren at TTH, and Kevin & Spencer for taking a chance on me! Shine on! @mjdeadman

Jordan De Leon - Ensemble

Broadway Debut! National Tour: Mamma Mia!, The Prom. Regional: Pasadena Playhouse, Fulton Theatre, Denver Center, The 5th Avenue Theatre, The Muny, PCLO, Seattle Rep, Ensemble Theatre of Cincinnati. CCM Musical Theatre. Thanks to The Price Group, The TRC Company, and Team Mamma Mia! For Meem, Plonk, my Nerfherder, Jennie, Gram, and Lola. Maraming salamat. And to the sixteen-year-old theatre geek from Bolingbrook with the big dreams: we did it. IG: @jordan_deleon_

Nico DiPrimio - Ensemble

Broadway Debut! Nat’l Tours: Mamma Mia! 25th Anniversary, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, Jimmy Buffett’s Escape to Margaritaville, Elf, Charlie Brown Christmas Live. Regional: Mamma Mia!, The Little Mermaid, Guys and Dolls. The most love to his whole family! Thanks to Tara Rubin Casting and UIA! @nicoo_d

Patrick Dunn - Ensemble

Patrick made his professional debut in A Christmas Carol: The Musical at Madison Square Garden as Young Scrooge. Recently led the North American tour of Les Misérables as Valjean. Other credits include The Phantom of the Opera, Waitress, and Hal Prince’s Candide (Lincoln Center). Graduate of The University of Hartford’s Hartt School.  Thanks to Mom, Dad, all the Dunns, Gibsons, Judith, Danny and Meghan at Hudson Artists. Love to Emma. Always for Penelope and Anna. 0-time Tony winner. TCB.

Andy Garcia- Swing

So beyond thrilled to be making his Broadway debut! National
Tours: Mamma Mia!, Elf (’17-’18). Regional: Mamma Mia!, Escape to Margaritaville, and
Holiday Inn. The Boston Conservatory alum. Lots of love and gratitude to my family,
friends, Bespoke Theatricals, Dave at Daniel Hoff Agency, and Nick! @andygarsha16

Erica Mansfield - Ensemble

Erica is thrilled to be coming home to the Greek Island of Mamma Mia where she made her Broadway Debut!  Other Broadway Credits: Almost Famous, Doubtfire, Kiss Me Kate, Bandstand, Finding Neverland, On The Twentieth Century, On The Town, Pippin, Evita, How to Succeed…Thanks to team Mamma Mia, DGRW and my parents!

Danny Lopez-Alicea - Swing, Dance Captain

BROADWAY DEBUT! International Tours: Mamma Mia!, Something Rotten!, Kinky Boots (NCL), Priscilla (NCL) Regional: In the Heights (Engeman), The Producers (ACCC), La Cage (ACCC), West Side Story (Palace Theatre). He is forever grateful to his Mom, Dad, Frankie, and Karina for their undying love and support. Many thanks to the creative team, Bespoke, Littlestar, WLP, and TRC for this amazing opportunity! Dreams do come true! @dannylopezalicea

Makoa - Ensemble

Makoa is so excited to be making his Broadway debut with Mamma Mia! A Native Hawaiian of Hilo, Hawai‘i and a graduate of NYU Tisch (‘22). Mahalo to this incredible cast, Henderson Hogan, Hilo Town and my ʻohana. Mahalo Ke Akua! @makoanyc 

Jasmine Overbaugh - Ensemble

Broadway debut! National Tour: Mamma Mia! 25th Anniversary. International: RENT 20th Anniversary; Disney’s Beauty and the Beast (Original Cast, DCL). Point Park University alumni. Eternally grateful for the unconditional support from Nana and Pop Pop. I owe you guys so much! James Kamphaus, you make all my dreams come true. I love you. @jasminemoverbaugh  

Gray Phillips - Ensemble

Broadway Debut! Touring: Mamma Mia! 25th Anniversary, TINA: The Tina Turner Musical, Legally Blonde. Pace University BFA Musical Theater. Endless gratitude to TRC Company, Janet, Martha and David. For my Mom, Dad, Ally, Coleman and to my biggest role model, Mychal — the reason I’m here. I owe it all to you!  @grelph_ 

Blake Price - Ensemble

National Tour: Monty in A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder. TV/Film: “FBI: Most Wanted,” “Awkwafina is Nora from Queens.” A proud Western Michigan Alum — Go Broncos! Thank you to The Price Group, Lacy Girl, and my incredibly supportive and ridiculous family. To my stunning and unbelievably kind wife, Kat: I cannot express how thankful I am to have you as my life partner. Let’s do this, y’all!

Dorian Quinn - Ensemble

Dorian is ecstatic to be making his Broadway debut with Mamma Mia! Dorian was born and raised in Oklahoma where he earned a BFA in Music Theatre at the University of Central Oklahoma. Credits: Jersey Boys (Tommy DeVito), Saturday Night Fever (Tony Manero), Xanadu (Sonny Malone). Love and thanks go out to Dorian’s family, friends, and Take3 Talent. Glory to God!

Xavi Soto Burgos- Ensemble, u/s Sky