Is This Your Show?
Submit Updates & Sell More Tickets
Is This Your Show?
Submit Updates & Sell More Tickets
Arsenic and Old Lace at Chicago Street Theatre
Dates: 10/2/2026 - 10/18/2026
📍 Theatre: Chicago Street Theatre
154 W Chicago St
VALPARAISO, IN
Tickets: $22–$25
Share
Written by Joseph Kesselring
Directed by Piper Bakrevski
Poisoners never go out of style – this timeless hit tells the story of two otherwise charming elderly ladies determined to get rid of all their lonely lodgers in the name of mercy.
We're kicking off Season 72 with a little mystery, a little wine, and a little murder, what's not to love!
Drama critic Mortimer Brewster’s engagement announcement is upended when he discovers a corpse in his elderly aunts’ window seat. Mortimer rushes to tell Abby and Martha before they stumble upon the body themselves, only to learn that the two old women aren’t just aware of the dead man in their parlor, they killed him! Between his aunts’ penchant for poisoning wine, a brother who thinks he’s Teddy Roosevelt, and another brother using plastic surgery to hide from the police – not to mention Mortimer’s own hesitancy about marriage – it’ll be a miracle if Mortimer makes it to his wedding. Arsenic and Old Lace is a classic dark comedy about the only thing more deadly than poison: family.
Ages: 14 and over
Cast and Creative Team for Arsenic and Old Lace at Chicago Street Theatre
Cast
Jami Anderson
Martha Brewster
Marcia Burbage
Abby Brewster
Grant Fitch
Dr. Einstein
Trey Georgion
Mortimer Brewster
Katie Golding
Elaine Harper
Lane Grote
Mr. Witherspoon
David Pera
Rev. Dr. Harper/Mr. Gibbs
Jeff Schultz
Teddy Brewster
Matt Stinnett
Officer Brophy
Todd Wilson
Jonathan Brewster
Trent Wilson
Officer Klein
Macy Wissig
Lieutenant Rooney
Kyle Yung
Officer O'Hara
Creative Team
Piper Bakrevski
Director
Dona Henry
Assistant Director/Producer
Barbara Malangoni
Costume Design
Set Design
Mady Ruzbasen
Lighting Design
Sam Haus
Sound Design
Dona Henry
Stage Manager
News About Arsenic and Old Lace at Chicago Street Theatre
We have no news on this show at the current time.
About the Theatre
Similar Shows Nearby
Chicago Street Theatre Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ
Where is Chicago Street Theatre located?
Chicago Street Theatre is at 154 W Chicago St, VALPARAISO, IN.
What shows have played recently at Chicago Street Theatre?
Ride the Cyclone (07/10/26-08/02/26)
Jellofish (03/27/26-04/12/26)
The Half-Life of Marie Curie (02/13/26-03/01/26)
That Other Person/Crazy Eights - Duo by David Lindsay-Abaire (01/23/26-02/01/26)
Lizzie (10/10/25-10/26/25)
See more shows at Chicago Street Theatre
Jellofish (03/27/26-04/12/26)
The Half-Life of Marie Curie (02/13/26-03/01/26)
That Other Person/Crazy Eights - Duo by David Lindsay-Abaire (01/23/26-02/01/26)
Lizzie (10/10/25-10/26/25)
See more shows at Chicago Street Theatre
|
|
Arsenic and Old Lace Chicago Street Theatre (10/02-10/18) |
|
Dinner Detective South Bend- Halloween Event Embassy Suites South Bend at Notre Dame (10/31-10/31) |
|
Holiday Pops Morris Performing Arts Center (12/20-12/20) |
|
Flanagan's Wake The Improv Mill (3/11-3/19) |
|
Holiday Pops Morris Performing Arts Center (12/19-12/19) |
|
Brahms’ Symphony No. 4 Morris Performing Arts Center (1/30-1/30) |
|
Symphony Sleigh Ride Adventure DeBartolo Performing Arts Center (11/29-11/29) |
|
Pictures at an Exhibition Morris Performing Arts Center (2/27-2/27) |
|
Scrooge! Interrupted The Improv Mill (12/18-12/20) |
|
Hollywood’s Greatest Scores Morris Performing Arts Center (2/13-2/13) |
