My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

EDINBURGH 2014 - BWW Reviews: THE SECRET COLLECTOR, Greenside @ Nicolson, August 4 2014

By:
Jack is a collector. However, he is not a collector of stamps or buttons, he collects secrets. It is an interesting concept but not executed as well as it could have been.

There are some nice ideas. The play takes place on a small island where everyone thinks they know everything about each other. This is soon revealed to not be the case as we find out more about them.

This is a youth theatre production and I'm not entirely sure what the intent of the jarred movements and staring children is, but it comes across as very creepy. The narrator, Jack, is very sinister but this is intentional as he harbours a very dark secret himself.

The piece improves when they start exposing secrets of the island inhabitants. Some are quite sweet, like the lady who is secretly adding donations to a man's memorial fund for his late wife when he's not looking. Others are a bit darker, like the boy who is mistreating his ill mother.

The Secret Collector doesn't seem to know what is doing. There are some good ideas but the overall style of the piece is odd and although it has some potential, it needs a bit more work.

The Secret Collector runs at Greenside @ Nicolson until August 7th.

Reader Reviews

To post a comment, you must register and login.

Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best Revival of a Play - Top 3
1. Every Brilliant Thing
29% of votes
2. Death of a Salesman
26.7% of votes
3. Oedipus
9.7% of votes

Don't Miss a Scotland News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...


Videos


Dracula: Lucy's Dream in Scotland Dracula: Lucy's Dream
Pleasance at EICC (Lennox) (8/06-8/29)
Black Blues Brothers: Let's Twist Again! in Scotland Black Blues Brothers: Let's Twist Again!
Underbelly (McEwan Hall) (8/05-8/31)
Father, Away She Goes in Scotland Father, Away She Goes
Zoo (Playground 1) (8/07-8/30)
Reparations in Scotland Reparations
Pleasance Courtyard (Above) (8/05-8/30)
The Steamie in Scotland The Steamie
Alhambra Theatre (10/29-10/31)
How Not to Make it in America in Scotland How Not to Make it in America
Summerhall (Former Gent’s Locker Room) (8/06-8/31)
One Hour Wedding in Scotland One Hour Wedding
Underbelly (The Friesian) (8/05-8/23)
Baby Wants Candy  in Scotland Baby Wants Candy
Assembly George Square Studios - One (8/05-8/30)
Shamilton! The Improvised Hip Hop Musical  in Scotland Shamilton! The Improvised Hip Hop Musical
Assembly George Square Studios - One (8/05-8/30)
100 Years of Magic in Scotland 100 Years of Magic
Aberdeen Arts Centre (9/04-9/05)