Skip to main content Skip to footer site map
Review: THE SIMON & GARFUNKEL STORY at Providence Performing Arts Center

Review: THE SIMON & GARFUNKEL STORY at Providence Performing Arts Center

Ran through March 11th, 2023.

The Simon & Garfunkel Story-Providence Performing Art Center-March 11, 2023

The only sad part about this incredible performance was that it was only here for one night, gone like a phantom in the night yet leaving behind the songs and harmonies that filled the theatre long after the singing stopped.

As a big Simon & Garfunkel fan (my wife would have been a groupie if she was a little older), I didn't quite know what to expect from this one-shot performance, touring more than 50 cities across the country that started in February, but it certainly didn't take long to know we were in the right place. My wife even got emotional and introspective at times, where many of us felt like we were listeing to the real Simon & Garfunkel: it was just that good!

Brooklyn, New York native and singer, actor and songwriter Brendan Jacob Smith took the stage as the wild-haired Art Garfunkel while Jonah Bobo, also a musician and theatre artist from New York, grabbed his acoustic guitar and echoed to a T the quiet calmness and baritone voice of Paul Simon.

The story is told through the pair, commencing their musical career as Tom & Jerry and going throuugh their huge success in the 1960's leading to their breakup in 1970 and their monumental 1981 reunion concert in Central Park. Rock & Roll tends to make many good friends part ways and Simon & Garfunkel was no different. Starting with the "Sound of Silence", the pair talked of their troubles and triumphs through songs we all know and love including "Mrs. Robinson", "Cecilia" and "Homeward Bound". Like many artists singing popular songs, Bobo and Smith's voices worked far better for some songs then for others but Smith's rendition of "Bridge over Troubled Water" was truly incredible and haunting, as was Simon's crowd-pleaser "The Boxer". Several times during the two hour performance, I had wished I lived through that era and how cool that would have been.

But it's not just about the hits this night; many of the songs they featured weren't major hits at all but still ones that struck emotional cords with people and clearly still do today. "Richard Cory", "Patterns", "Somewhere they can't find me", "Wednesday morning, 3 a.m." and even their cover of their favorite band's classic, The Everly Brothers and "Wake Up Little Suzie"

The Simon & Garfunkel Story just had that special feel to it, like it touched your soul, brought back memories you hadn't thought about in yearsas well as create new ones. Most of us have heard their songs but their story, not so much. I forgot that Garfunkel got into acting, something Simon hated him for. Or that Simon, once "The Sound of Silence" broke free as a hit, had to decide whether he was going to continue his one-man-band touring and singing through England or come back to the states to continue to work with Garfunkel. What would have happened if he decided to stay put? Now that's haunting!

Bobo and Smith were perfectly cast for these roles, physically, emotionally and through their superior voices that brought us all back to a simpler time, even if many didn't consider it so back who lived through it. You'll have a blast with songs like "The 59th Bridge Song (Feelin' Groovy", get emotional with "Kathy's Song" or want to dance with "A Hazy Shade of Winter". For those who lived through those times that certainly were "a-changin" to many who never heard them live, The Simon & Garfunkel Story is a tremendous walk through some incredible music that impact us still and likely always will.

For more information or tour dates, go to

Jim Jefferies Comes To The VETS In Providence This Summer Photo
Australian comedian Jim Jefferies (Legit, FX; The Jim Jefferies Show, Comedy Central) brings his world-wide Give 'Em What They Want Tour to The VETS in Providence August 26, 2023.

TOPDOG/UNDERDOG, HANGMEN, and More Set For The Gamm Theatres 2023-24 Season Photo
The Sandra Feinstein-Gamm Theatre has announced its 2023-2024 season comprising Pulitzer Prize and Tony Award winners, landmarks of the American theater, and modern plays that have made waves in the theater world. 

Review: HADESTOWN Thrills At Providence Performing Arts Center Photo
What did our critic think of HADESTOWN at PPAC?

Newport Jazz Festival Announces 2023 Lineup Photo
The lineup also includes bounce legend Big Freedia, musical polyglots Thundercat, DJ Pee .Wee (aka Anderson .Paak), Big Gigantic and Alfa Mist, as well as songwriters Cautious Clay, Durand Jones and The War & Treaty. Special ensembles include Newport Jazz artistic director Christian McBride’s annual Jam Jawn, MoodSwing, Scary Goldings, and more.

From This Author - Jay Pateakos

Jay Pateakos has been a newspaper journalist since the late 1990’s, branching off into theatre reviews more than 10 years ago, reviewing more than a hundred plays for the Herald News and Cape... (read more about this author)

Review: THE SIMON & GARFUNKEL STORY at Providence Performing Arts CenterReview: THE SIMON & GARFUNKEL STORY at Providence Performing Arts Center
March 13, 2023

What did our critic think of THE SIMON & GARFUNKEL STORY at Providence Performing Arts Center?

Review: BAD JEWS at Gamm TheatreReview: BAD JEWS at Gamm Theatre
March 6, 2023

What did our critic think of BAD JEWS at Gamm Theatre? When a beloved grandfather passes away, leaving behind a sentimental family heirloom, what would your family do to possess it? Chances are, not to the extent of this family!

Review: 24-HOUR PLAY FESTIVAL at Contemporary TheaterReview: 24-HOUR PLAY FESTIVAL at Contemporary Theater
January 17, 2023

What did our critic think of 24-HOUR PLAY FESTIVAL at Contemporary Theater? It's been 18 years that Contemporary Theater Company has been putting on this 24-hour play festival, an amazing concoction of stories and actors and action that just can't be compared to anything else because, frankly, there is nothing else like it.

December 6, 2022

It was one of those shows that you did not quite know what to expect. Being an 80's kid, I knew the mastery of David Foster, mostly from my infatuation with Chicago, but didn't know if this show with singer-songwriter and wife Katharine McPhee would be more of a hit concert redux or a Christmas show or something completely different. It proved to be a wonderful mix of all.

Review: SENSE & SENSIBILITY at Burbage Theatre CompanyReview: SENSE & SENSIBILITY at Burbage Theatre Company
November 22, 2022

What did our critic think of SENSE & SENSIBILITY at Burbage Theatre Company? When it comes to Jane Austen, it's typically a love-hate relationship. My wife, so deep into the former category, worried how I would take Burbage's Rhode Island Premiere of Austen's SENSE & SENSIBILITY since I am not as familiar with Austen's work. But, in the end, she had little to worry about.